Nathaniel Hawthorne's Hypocrisy: The True Sin

Words: 1209
Pages: 5
Open Document
An Examination of the Hypocrisy in The Scarlet Letter: The True Sin
Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter highlights the complexities of Puritan society in a colonial American setting. The protagonist, Hester Prynne, faces many obstacles and impediments due to her infidelity. She has an affair with Arthur Dimmesdale, a beloved reverend, while her husband (using the alias “Roger Chillingworth” later in the book) is absent. The Puritan leaders publicly shame and isolate her with her daughter, Pearl, and although Hester accepts the outcome given by the overseers, she does not believe she sinned. Throughout Pearl's adolescence, Dimmesdale would not confess to being her father; though both his ego and the toxic presence of Chillingworth forces …show more content…
Pearl asks her mother multiple times if the minister will hold their hands and be seen in public together (105, 145, 157). Hawthorne writes this to present the obvious hypocrisy that only an innocent child can see. Although Dimmesdale and Hester have an intimate relationship, it is clear that Dimmesdale is not willing to be connected with Hester and wants to keep it hidden. This proves that his love for Hester, or lack thereof, is not as powerful as his reputation. Because he does not admit publicly, there is no way to truly repent. Instead, he beats himself with a scourge and fasts in order to punish himself (99). Self-mutilation is indeed a sin and he uses torture methods, “in accordance with the old, corrupted faith of Rome” (99). He would rather punish himself than be punished by those he preaches to. Subsequently, he tries to indemnify his sins and persuade the leaders to treat him as a sinner, they take it as modesty and humility. The community worships him as an example and deem him a miracle of holiness, even though his religious influence and charm are built on a fabrication of lies. As he gets weaker, his sermons become stronger, leaving the readers questioning whether he would have been a better minister for the weak if he indeed confessed his sins rather than punishing himself. He will always be “the mouthpiece of Heaven’s …show more content…
She believes the sin of adultery is an act of love, and because “she felt no love” for Chillingworth, Hester does not regret her actions (51). However, she still accepts the clergymen’s verdict with no rebuttal. After more than seven years with the scarlet letter branded on her chest, she still believes that it is a, “sin of passion, not of principle, nor even purpose” (137). Although she follows Puritan beliefs, she has a rebellious attitude through her daughter. Hester wears dull clothes, while she dresses Pearl in a “velvet tunic... abundantly embroidered with fantasies and flourishes of gold thread” (69). Hester raises Pearl alone, even after Governor Bellingham and the other leaders spoke of taking Pearl from Hester (68). Pearl also defies the law of succession; she receives Chillingworth's inheritance, and marries well. However, after Pearl, Chillingworth, and Dimmesdale are gone, Hester still decides to go back to the town, live in the same house, and wear the scarlet letter (179). She dreamt of once leaving, crying, “Is the world, then, so narrow? Doth the universe lie within the compass of yonder town?” She still returns at the end. As much as she rebels, and thinks she did not do anything wrong, she wears the scarlet letter until she
Show More

Related Documents: Nathaniel Hawthorne's Hypocrisy: The True Sin

Hester Prynne In The Scarlett Letter By Nathaniel Hawthorne

The Scarlet Letter is a 19th century novel about 17th century Puritans written by Nathaniel Hawthorne. In this novel, Hawthorne follows the life of Hester Prynne, an adulteress forced to live the rest of her life with a scarlet A engraved on her clothes. For almost seven years after being publicly shamed, she resides in a cottage outside the skirts of the town as a single mother with her illegitimate child, Pearl. She does not breathe a word of the father’s name to anyone, even when her husband,…

Words 699 - Pages 3

Why Is Sin Important In The Scarlet Letter

Sin is clearly a matter of great importance in the mid-17th century Puritan Community of The Scarlet Letter, as religious sin is associated with breaking the law. In this novel, we see a hierarchy of sins. Roger Chillingworth's Pursuit of revenge is deemed a "worse sin" than the passion that led Hester Prynne and Arthur Dimmesdale to commit adultery. No character in the book questions the idea that sin should be punished, and all recognize that sin will be punished, if not here on earth by man, than…

Words 1279 - Pages 6

Hypocrisy In Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter

making an abundance of money. In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter, many themes are addressed: guilt, revenge, confession (accountability) and hypocrisy. Through reading the novel, the reader often reflects on the effects these matters have on his or her own life. In this book, Roger Chillingworth shows the effects of revenge on his life and the character of Dimmesdale brings to light the consequences of hidden guilt. Additionally, the theme of hypocrisy is addressed not with just one main…

Words 645 - Pages 3

The Scarlet Letter Hypocrisy

Hypocrisy can be defined as a “behavior that does not agree with what someone claims to believe or feel” (Merriam-Webster). Nathaniel Hawthorne, who grew up in Salem Massachusetts during the early 1800’s, was aware of the hypocritical actions that his ancestors were involved in within their Puritan society. After completing college in 1825, Hawthorne moved back to Salem and was once again surrounded with the historical remnants of Puritan life (Short Stories... 295). These roots of dissimulation…

Words 1538 - Pages 7

Compare And Contrast Young Goodman Brown And The Minister's Black Veil

In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s short stories “Young Goodman Brown” and “The Minister’s Black Veil” there is an overarching motif of unpardonable sin. Hawthorne, born in Salem Massachusetts in 1804, was born into a struggling Puritan family in which he had never met his father, who died when he was a young boy. The tragedies and hurdles he faced as a child created the vivid imagination and overall grim and unpleasant mood that is present in his writing. Although these stories have very distinctive plots…

Words 1798 - Pages 8

English Scarlet Letter Essay

American Literary Traditions October 3, 2014 The Wild Forest: Suppression of Human Nature in The Scarlet Letter In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter, he uses the setting of the wild forest and how different characters—the townspeople, Pearl, and Dimmesdale—view and interact with it to critique how the rigid structure of Puritan society suppresses human nature, creating a clash with the wildness of nature. In the beginning of the novel, Hester Prynne is condemned to wear an “A” on her chest…

Words 1368 - Pages 6

Hypocrisy In The Scarlet Letter

Situations where humans become uncomfortable have always defined what their true character can be.Throughout Hawthorne’s stories, a common theme had been displayed of placing his character’s within difficult situations that eventually affected their viewpoints of those around them. In Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter, “Young Goodman Brown,” “Minister’s Black Veil,” and “Rappaccini's Daughter,” the forces of conformity and hypocrisy had an effect on the character’s lives that resulted in testing their…

Words 1542 - Pages 7

Scarlet Letter Analysis Essay

Nathaniel Hawthorne was born in Salem, Massachusetts in 1804. After the death of his father due to the Yellow Fever epidemic, he was raised with his two sisters by a single mother. As a writer, Hawthorne produced many pieces including House of Seven Gables. However, The Scarlet Letter, written near the end of his career, is thought to be his Magnum Opus. In relation to the novel, Hawthorne not only lived in the same general area as his characters, but also under many of the same circumstances…

Words 1326 - Pages 6

The Scarlett Letter Essay

the Puritan era. As a result, guilt can drive people to commit acts they would normally think of as being inconceivable. In Nathaniel Hawthorne's, The Scarlett Letter, characters have to live with some form of guilt. When faced with guilt, a people can either face their actions or run from them. Hawthorne reveals the evils that emerge from characters when they conceal their sins. As a result, Hawthorne shows how characters such as Arthur Dimmesdale, Roger Chillingworth, and Hester Prynn realize that…

Words 956 - Pages 4

Flaws In Nathaniel Hawthorne's Hester Prynne

for Jesus Christ, has found a way to be perfection: without flaws, without quirks, without faults, and without past regret. Nathaniel Hawthorne’s Hester Prynne is undoubtedly a flawed woman. But when attacked and tried for these flaws, she finally accepts her punishment with admirable dignity, enduring to lead the rest of her life. By choosing to act in this manner, the true nature of her character shines through and she goes on to lead a life worthy of example. The Catholic Church has also been…

Words 1501 - Pages 7