Abortion Canadian Law Essay

Submitted By nikkitreestump
Words: 494
Pages: 2
Open Document
Nicole Stumpf
Erik King
CLN4UI
October 9, 2014

Dying Generation Abortion is a topic that is constantly debated worldwide. I believe that is should not be happening anywhere because you are killing innocent babies and it does not benefit anyone. I feel as if the law should change so that abortion is illegal. These three natural law philosophers: St. Thomas Aquinas, R.M Dworkin and Plato would agree with my newly changed law. St. Thomas Aquinas was greatly influenced by Christian Teachings. The bible to him was basically law. Aquinas dealt with the question of whether it is permissible to section the uterus of a pregnant woman if this is the only way to baptize the fetus that is in danger of dying. The argument in favor of doing this is that the eternal life of the fetus is more important than the temporal life of its mother. Aquinas refuses to allow this and quotes St. Paul (Rom. 3:8) who says: "We should not do evil that there may come good." It is an impermissible evil, according to Aquinas, to impose direct physical harm on a pregnant woman (in all probability causing her death) even when the good that is intended "the eternal salvation of the fetus" might be construed in a particularly theological sense to be a greater good than continuing the temporal life of the mother. "Abortion is a violation of natural law and is always wrong, no matter when a soul may be infused into the developing child's body." (Catholic Answers, Aquinas opinion). He believed that abortion was unnatural and against the teaching of the Roman Catholic Church. The Roman Catholic Church believes " that all life is sacred from conception until natural death, and the taking of innocent human life, whether born or unborn, is morally wrong". (Fr, William Saunders, "The Catholic Church And Abortion"). "You shall not murder"
Show More

Related Documents: Abortion Canadian Law Essay

Legalization Of Abortion In Canada

The first Criminal law for abortion in Canada was passed in 1869 which punished those who obtained an abortion with a penalty of life imprisonment. A women only faced a penalty of two years if she, herself was convicted. The law was created in order to protect women from dangerous procedures performed under uncertified physicians. Many, however, argued that it did not focus enough on the provisions of the mother in question and as a result, this new law faced scrutiny from physicians, lawyers and…

Words 1392 - Pages 6

Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms Essay

The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is part of the Canadian Constitution. The Canadian Charter was created, signed, and acted upon starting from 1982. This took place when the 15th Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau wanted to bring the whole Constitution to Canada. In order to get certain documents signed by the provinces, the Charter had to be part of the Constitution as well. The Canadian society has a much more clear view of human rights and freedoms with the Charter, as it basically just lists…

Words 855 - Pages 4

How Did Pierre Trudeau Helped Canada

making several law reforms which gave increased liberty to Canadians. Under the divorce act, Trudeau made it easier to become divorced. Previously, in order to file for divorce, there must be proof of adultery. With Trudeau’s changes, other reasons justifying divorce now included separation or mental/physical cruelty. This political change gave an increased freedom to people. Another amendment he made was legalizing abortions. At this time, hundreds of thousands illegal abortions were being performed…

Words 432 - Pages 2

Abortion In Canada

thoughts, values, and beliefs in society. Collective actors organize social movements in order to challenge societal rules and norms. Abortion has been a topic of Canada’s societal and political concerns for many years and as of 1988 it was recognized that it is a woman’s right to control her own reproductive system. There are numerous debates surrounding abortion laws in Canada and the discussions generally range from merely opposing the rules/norms to a broader concern about the legal and social/moral…

Words 2364 - Pages 10

The Women's Movement In Canada

is divided into two waves. The Feminist Movement during World War One and Two allowed many women in each province the right to vote, women were allowed in the labour force, and had access to attend the Olympics for the first time as apart of the Canadian team. During the Cold War period, the Royal Commission on the Status of Women shone the spotlight on the ladies, the Native Women’s Association of Canada was established, the federal government declared a fair wages policy, and Quebec passed a…

Words 1175 - Pages 5

R V. Morgentaler Case Analysis

such as the “right to chose” (Biklen). In Canada, through the 1970s until the 1990s, the cases of R v Morgentaler were fought on the bases of women's rights to abortions, most significantly being the case from 1988. Morgentaler came out in favour of the right to choose in the 1970s; opening abortion clinics to provide illegal yet safe abortions to women unable to otherwise (Sethna). They were able to bring the fight to the Supreme Court, and a majority decision was made that found that section 251 of…

Words 620 - Pages 3

Legalization Of Abortion In Canada

Reasons for abortions vary among women. It could just be the wrong time to introduce a child into their life. Although there are precautions can be taken to prevent an unwanted pregnancy, there is still a slim chance of getting pregnant. A failure of birth control may result in an unexpected pregnancy which could be a factor contributing for an abortion. As we all know, babies cost a considerable amount of money and time to ensure they receive proper care. The financial situation can be a huge influence…

Words 900 - Pages 4

American Lazyness Essay

Jack Iles ESSAY ON ABORTION Abortion has become an irrational and controversial issue with no permanent solution in sight. There are actually only three real arguments or sides to this issue. People either think it is legal, illegal, or acceptable under certain defined circumstances. According to the results from an Angus Reid poll (global monitoring company) show that 49% of Canadians think it should be legal while only 5% think it should be illegal. The remaining 42% think it should…

Words 487 - Pages 2

Persuasive Essay On Pro Abortion

pro-choice, abortion has been a long running controversial topic even before it became legal in the United States from the time the earliest settlers arrived. At the time Canada’s Constitution was adopted, abortions, before the point at which a pregnant woman could feel the movements of the fetus (approximately the fourth month of pregnancy), were openly advertised and commonly performed. In the mid-to-late 1800s jurisdictions began passing laws that made abortion illegal. Currently in Canada abortion has…

Words 1771 - Pages 8

Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms

The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is a document that impacts the everyday lives of Canadians. The document guarantees that the rights and freedoms are respected and honored in all levels of government in the laws they make and the programs and services they give to Canadians. The freedoms our charter guarantees for everyone are: Freedom of conscience and religion Freedom of thought, belief, opinion, and expression including freedom of the press and media Freedom of peaceful assembly Freedom…

Words 348 - Pages 2