Essay about Affirmative Action & Admissions Policies

Submitted By lglyrics13
Words: 2094
Pages: 9
Open Document
The Past, Present, & the Future: Affirmative Action and Admission Policies
Steve Robert
Dr. Skipworth
MPAC 7156
12/04/ 2012
Since its first use in President John F. Kennedy’s Executive Order 10925 in 1961, the phrase “Affirmative Action” has taken several different meanings, but its intentional purpose remains the same. The overall objectives of affirmative action policies are to combat inequality by promoting equal opportunity and ensure inclusions of minority groups in governmental and educational programs. However, implementing those objectives has proven to be both difficult and controversial. Opponents have questioned whether it is the government’s duty to interfere by means of affirmative action. In response, proponents remind us that the government actively supported slavery and discrimination against some groups in society, therefore has an obligation to rectify the social imbalance (Rabe 2001). Over the last few decades, race-conscious admissions policies in Higher Education have triggered a series of court cases questioning the purpose and legality of affirmative action. The purpose of this paper is to analyze some of the legal issues challenging affirmative action in school admissions policies, the courts’ positions and its past rulings, and the future of affirmative action in universities’ admissions policies.
Supporters like the NAACP argue that affirmative action is well needed corrective justice. On the other hand, there are those who argue, undoing one wrong with another only creates further injustice. According to Sowell (2005) affirmative action, is considered needed remedy to compensate for past oppression or exploitation by the ruling class of a culture and to deal with existing discrimination. This point of view is generally shared by the higher courts. Justice Brennan, along with Justices White, Marshall, and Blackmun agreed that universities' attempts to alleviate the effects of past societal discrimination was itself “sufficiently important to justify the use of race-conscious admissions programs where there is a sound basis for concluding that minority underrepresentation is substantial and chronic, and that the handicap of past discrimination is impeding access of minorities” (Bakke, 1978). However, it is necessary to note that several of the cases were initially ruled against affirmative action on the basis that a race-conscious admission policies could not be used for the purpose of remedying past discrimination, and/or that diversity is not a government’s compelling interest. This is an interesting tendency that is common among the lower courts. For example, delivering the opinion of the Fifth Circuit court in Hopwood v. Texas (1996), Jerry E. Smith writes
"The University of Texas School of Law may not use race as a factor in deciding which applicants to admit in order to achieve a diverse student body, to combat the perceived effects of a hostile environment at the law school, to alleviate the law school's poor reputation in the minority community, or to eliminate any present effects of past discrimination by actors other than the law school."
In higher learning institutions, supporters argue the overall benefits of having affirmative action outweighs the so called injustice that it creates. However, implementation of affirmative action policies is often very problematic due to its unconstitutional nature. Some argue that affirmative action defies the very principles for which it stands, as it is within itself a form of discrimination against unfavorable groups, violating protected rights of others, and fosters a non-competitive environment. (Regents of the University of California v. Bakke, 1978)
The unconstitutional aspect of affirmative action is a constant debate, and is often challenged in the courts. Legislatures have attempted to deal with affirmative action and admissions policies through different means. Many states successfully banned affirmative action through
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Affirmative Action & Admissions Policies

Affirmative Action Case Study

Essay 4 Draft 1 November 6th, 2015 A Case for Affirmative Action in Higher Education Introduction Affirmative action in the United States has been controversial since it was first introduced by President John F. Kennedy in 1961 through Executive Order 10925. The term “affirmative action” had become popular in the years leading up to Executive Order 10925. Used by those advocating for increased government action in promoting civil rights, “affirmative action” refered to the active process of offsetting…

Words 1333 - Pages 6

Affirmative Action In The College Admissions Process

Affirmative Action in the College Admissions Process Racial inequality has alway been a major topic of debate and criticism throughout United States history. America and racism have almost always gone hand and hand. However, in the last half-century, the narrative that the United States is unfair to minorities has started to change. Through Affirmative Action programs, especially with regards to colleges, many of the racial prejudices and inequalities of the past have disappeared, bringing up an…

Words 1521 - Pages 7

Gratz Vs Bollinger Essay

higher education admissions decisions was constitutional. In June, 2003, the Supreme Court ruled on two major affirmative action cases involving the University of Michigan’s admissions policies. Two petitioners claimed they were denied admission to the university’s schools due to their race. Justices Rehnquist, O’Connor, Stevens, Scalia, Kennedy, Souter, Thomas, Ginsburg, and Breyers, who made up the Rehnquist Court at the time, had to deem whether or not the university’s policies were constitutional…

Words 1643 - Pages 7

Diversity Argument

The diversity argument Supporters of affirmative action say it ensures diversity on the campus and at the workplace. It develops tolerance as it promotes exposure to various cultures. It helps level the playing field, as many groups were discriminated against and started late in the race to development. Affirmative-action activists say the policy has helped remove racial stereotypes by providing opportunities to disadvantaged groups to prove their abilities—though critics say it has only reinforced…

Words 1805 - Pages 8

Isler's Arguments Against Affirmative Action

supporters Affirmative Action is Not the Appropriate Action In the modern context of society, it seems that the majority of Americans go out of their way to be politically correct. This censorship is done in an effort to sensitize the discrimination that existed decades ago by racially preferring minorities. Both government and society attempt to resolve racism through racial preference. Affirmative action is a government-initiated policy of racial preference in the college admission process, but…

Words 1480 - Pages 6

Grutter V. Bollinger Case Brief

because it upheld affirmative action, with the court stating that the fourteenth amendment places state interest in fostering diversity within the classroom, situating race as a constitutional admissions factor. However, during the 1964 trial it was concluded that racial quotas were unconstitutional, for example, how UC Davis set aside 16 of their 100 seats for minority students. In Grutter v. Bollinger, the Equal Protection Clause was found to not prohibit the use of race as an admission factor based…

Words 629 - Pages 3

Research Paper On Affirmative Action Final

Affirmative Action Katie Narloch, Tyler Young, Josh Barr, Aaron Broadwater University of Wisconsin Whitewater Abstract The objective of this paper is to inform readers on the topic of Affirmative Action. This paper will explore the history, importance, supporters and critics, organizational roles, and connections of affirmative action. Affirmative action is a controversial and often poorly understood topic. Affirmative Action is a policy that emphasizes a particular attention on jobs and…

Words 3628 - Pages 15

Final Paper ENG102

Affirmative Action's Intentions: Education and the Workplace Caitlin Campanella ENG102 February 26, 2014 Affirmative Action's Intentions: Education and the Workplace Does the idea of affirmative action do what it was intended to do or does it create even more inequalities in the workplace and education? Ever since the civil war of the 1800s and the civil rights movement of the 1960s in which minorities in America, majorly composed of blacks and women, were denied the opportunity to use public…

Words 1743 - Pages 7

American Domestic Policy Pros And Cons

and cultures. Immigrants have poured into this great land for centuries now. Originally, the United States sought to assimilate immigrants in hopes of achieving homogeneity. After countless years under the assimilation strategy, American domestic policy evolved. Washington acknowledged the potential advantages of its citizens possessing different backgrounds, meaning everyone brings different tools to the table. Without diversity, society has the potential to succumb to tunnel vision. When everyone…

Words 1846 - Pages 8

Arguments Against Affirmative Action

Introduction to Affirmative Action Affirmative Action Laws are defined as “those in which an institution or organization actively engages in efforts to improve opportunities for historically excluded groups in American society” (NCSL). In America, Affirmative Action laws emerged as a result of the Civil Rights movement of the 1960s. Affirmative Action laws were intended to give opportunities to minority groups who were previously repressed. The Affirmative Action was first used by President Kennedy…

Words 3683 - Pages 15