Essay on An Unfit Ruler from the Start

Submitted By Brandtgeddy1
Words: 1516
Pages: 7
Open Document
An Unfit Ruler from the Start
One cannot rule by being crazy or belligerent; one must have courage and at least try to do good for others, which obviously Macbeth cannot do. Machiavelli has distinct rules in which a Prince – in this case King – should live and abide by and if Macbeth were compared to those rules, he would fail so miserably; Macbeth has received advice from Lady Macbeth which he didn’t ask for at all and also with Macbeth going crazy proves he’s unfit to do anything. Lady Macbeth believed the prophecy for told by the sisters right away, in doing so when she became evil she helped Macbeth to achieve the goals of the prophecy; Lady Macbeth gave Macbeth advice/help when he did not ask for it, Machiavelli has a distinct rule in which a Prince shouldn’t be given advice unless he asks. “then, That made you break this enterprise to me? When you durst do it, then you were a man; And to be more than what you were, you would be so much more than a man. Nor time nor place Did then adhere, and yet you would make both. They have made themselves, and that their fitness now.” (Shakespeare, 1.7. 55-61) Lady Macbeth is questioning Macbeth’s man hood, for when Macbeth sent Lady Macbeth a letter that for told the great prophecy that he was supposed to gain and now it seems like Macbeth wants to in a sense “back out,” and just remain the Thane of Cawdor to not kill Duncan. Lady Macbeth wants Macbeth to do anything to gain this power that he deserves and this is what she craves. “When Duncan is asleep (Whereto the rather shall his day’s hard journey Soundly invite him), his two chamberlains Will I with wine and wassail so convince That memory, the warder of the brain, Shall be a fume, and the receipt of reason a limbeck only. When in swinish sleep Their drenched natures lies as in a death, What cannot you and I perform upon Th’ unguarded Duncan? What not put upon His spongy officers, who shall near the guilt Of our great quell?” (Shakespeare, 1.7. 62-72) Lady Macbeth has created a plan to kill Duncan. First off, what’s going to happen is that Duncan is going to fall asleep since he’s had a long journey getting to the Macbeth’s house. Secondly, Lady Macbeth will make sure that guards get so drunk they fall asleep and when they awaken, they don’t know what’s happened. Thirdly, Macbeth can then go into the chamber in which Duncan is asleep and kill him with a knife to the heart. Lastly, when the guards wake up, Lady Macbeth and Macbeth can then blame the guards for what’s happened to Duncan; since they guards were so drunk they won’ t know if they killed Duncan or not which creates a great escape route for Lady Macbeth and Macbeth. Machiavelli statesm “…he ought rather to discourage every one from offering advice unless he asks it…” (Machiavelli, 23.) This states that a prince should discourage the advice anyone else gives him unless he asks for it. Macbeth had not discouraged his wife’s advice when telling him to kill Duncan to fulfill the prophecy that the three Weird Sisters had told him. This proves that Macbeth is an unfit ruler if he cannot Macbeth goes crazy from the sight of Banquo at dinner with his worthiest of friends; this puts an idea into everyone’s brain that maybe it was Macbeth who killed Duncan and Banquo make decisions for himself. When not following set rules that a prince/king should abide by makes Macbeth unfit to fulfill the prophecy that the three Weird Sisters led him to believe. “And above all things, a prince ought to live amongst his people in such a way that no unexpected circumstances, whether of good or evil, shall make him change…” (Machiavelli, 8.) Machiavelli explains that in Chapter 8 of the Prince shouldn’t change himself no matter if it’s good or bad. Well, Act 1 through Act 3 shows that Macbeth is changing himself, in an evil way because when first hearing the prophecy from the Weird Sisters, killing Duncan and Banquo made the circumstances for Macbeth to unrealistic and outlandish. : “…for
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on An Unfit Ruler from the Start

Thomas Jefferson Abuse Of Power

issues that the people had toward the King of Great Britain. He mentions in detail how the people who are being oppressed are constantly in a battle for peace. People questioned The King of Great Britain’s position of power and thought he was an unfit ruler and they wanted to become free people. Was the King fit to rule the states? Thomas says that the king had a history of committing repeated injuries against the people. The king had made the colonist suffer. Thomas was prepared to show the world…

Words 599 - Pages 3

Essay about Venezuela and Simon Bolivar

speaking country in South America has undergone great change in past decades, starting with its secession from Spain. Venezuela came from humble starts, being founded by the Spanish simply in order to hold other European countries off from trying to conquer Latin America. However, the natives did not care for their Spanish rulers as the Spanish only gave non-natives positions of power. The shift from colonialism to nationalism shook Spains grip on her colonies. Simón Bolívar, known as El Libertador in…

Words 695 - Pages 3

Thomas Jefferson's Rhetorical Analysis: The Declaration Of Independence

Sutton English 102 17th February, 2016 Rhetorical Analysis – The Declaration of Independence By writing “The Declaration of Independence”, on 4th July 1776, Thomas Jefferson successfully called for a right to freedom of the 13 American colonies from the vigorous and dictatorial rule of the Great Britain by usage of logos, ethos and pathos along with a strong persuasive appeal to make his points clear in the declaration. The audience had been targeted extraordinarily by Jefferson which not only…

Words 1051 - Pages 5

Essay about Sir Thomas Stamford Raffles

additional information provided, Raffles is not the only one credited with the establishment of early Singapore and thus gives a more objective view of early history of Singapore under British possession. The third source I’m going to examine is from suit101 . This passage gives a general overview of Raffles and his involvement in Singapore. This source is a summary of his early life, his career, and also how it links to the founding of Singapore. Compare to the first two sources, this source…

Words 1887 - Pages 8

Summary: Recognizing The Armenian Genocide

The Ottoman rulers permitted the Armenians to have a self-government system, but that did not mean that they got fair and just treatment, Armenians were regarded as infidels and unfit and that led to many difficulties and complications, people were suspicious about them, the regime thought that since they are Christians they will be more biased towards…

Words 1602 - Pages 7

Book Thief Symbolism

Mock Exam Essay Statement of intent: my intention with this formal writing piece was to adapt my English mock exam into a piece more suitable for the writing portfolio. It was intended to be marked by a teacher with the possibility of it being shared within a senior English class. The question for this piece was to "analyse how symbolism was used to show one or more ideas in the written texts". Three of Liesel's books (both stolen and gifted) where chosen to symbolise three different ideas. The…

Words 1821 - Pages 8

A Bug’s Life Through the Lens of Karl Marx Essay

proletariats as a unique class. Applying his theory, the ants are the majority in the colony and share a common miserable existence; this is what essentially brings them together to destroy the system of exploitation and start a revolution. Marxism states the bourgeoisie are the owners and the rulers of production. He also describes the bourgeoisie as…

Words 2089 - Pages 9

Essay on Josh Warren Empire So Nearly

of those great quotes from the new book I have about Empires in general. Canada has been suggested as the point in which the cracks began to show for Empire. The British granted the Canadians 'independence' in 1867 with the Constitution Act. This saw Canada transition from dominion to colony. The act saw Canada become a 1"Quasi Independent Actor" when it came to trade according to Taylor. The fact that the act was implemented shows that there was some thirst for autonomy from the Canadians. However…

Words 4284 - Pages 18

What Was The Relationship Between The American And The French War

- Other colonies are going to look at the weaker colonies and look at them as something that they can eventually take over. English Killed anyone they didn’t like French took the approach of I can learn from you, you can teach me, I can trade with you, we can get along. The french in the north that is now canada had a very good relationship with the natives. The relationship between native americans, algonquins, and even the french is extremely close and very dependant. Because their relationship…

Words 8075 - Pages 33

Theories Of The World-Systematic Perspectives In Identifying Patterns Of How Things Work

2-3 pages…. Theorists are embedded in the world that they are trying to discuss. Use selection and specification when formulating their theory. Theorists react to other theorists and the world around them. All the theorists in this class span from the revolutions in Europe through wwii and into the middle of the 20th century. This period is called the long 19th century. (1770s-1920s) they were living through a transformation in society, and the society was in crisis! Focusing in class on three…

Words 7937 - Pages 32