Critique Of Counseling Theory: The Bondage Breaker

Submitted By takingcareofyou
Words: 969
Pages: 4
Open Document
Anderson Theory Critique No name

Critique of Counseling Theory: The Bondage Breaker
Summary
In The Bondage Breaker, Neil T. Anderson (2006) presents a very religious and somewhat controversial approach to therapy. He believes that some problems may be the result of demonic possession and his therapeutic approach incorporates traditional Christian methods for dealing with demonic possession. It is important to realize that Anderson does not believe all psychological problems are the result of demonic possession or even that they represent the struggle with sin. Instead, he believes that demonic possession and the concept of sin should be examined after ruling out organic and traditional psychological causes for problems. He points out that the belief that there can be metaphysical causes for real-world problems may go against modern scientific notions. It is supported, not just by Christian theology, but by the modern Western interest in what he refers to as the “two tiers” of reality: an upper transcendent world and a lower empirical world (Anderson, 2006). He also believes that Satan is overtly interested in manipulating people on the earthly plane, and that reliance upon Christ can be key to overcoming that manipulation, which manifests as mental illness. Anderson has a very basic theological approach to sin, in that he believes that earthly issues are inherently sinful. He believes Satan rules over Earth, while God rules over Heaven, though he also believes that every believer in Christ has authority over the “kingdom of darkness” (Anderson, 2006). He does not think of himself as an exorcist, nor does he believe that exorcism is necessary to free people from demons. Instead, he presents specific steps to spiritual wholeness: renunciation of any past involvement with non-Christian beliefs; changing self-talk to reflect truth; forgiving those who have sinned against the individual, submitting to God and resisting Satan; embracing humility; choosing freedom; and renouncing the sins and curses of one’s ancestors.
Strengths and Weaknesses At first blush, many in the counseling community may want to dismiss the idea of possession as a possible source of mental illness. After all, the history of psychology demonstrates a development in understanding of mental illness that has transitioned away from the idea of demonic possession, rather than moving towards the idea of demonic possession. Therefore, one of the weaknesses to his theory is that it may not be accepted by many mainstream mental health professionals and may even be rejected by other Christian counselors who do not believe that the concept of sin extends to actual demonic or satanic control over an individual. As a result, it could be difficult for a therapist embracing Anderson’s theories to work in conjunction with other mental health professionals. Furthermore, when one looks at the types of horrific abuses that some well-intentioned people have committed under the guise of exorcism, there is a concern that any discussion of possession will have people concerned about the ethical implications of such treatment. However, the reality is that Anderson incorporates a comprehensive approach to treating patients with a suspected demonic possession. First, he does not suggest avoiding scientific approaches; he is not against medication or traditional counseling interventions. Instead, he suggests that when someone has proven resistant to scientific, earthly interventions, it may be appropriate to examine metaphysical causes and take a metaphysical approach to healing. Furthermore, it is important to examine the core steps of Anderson’s intervention theory. None of those steps would appear to have negative mental health consequences, even if a person was not suffering from a possession. The only possible negative consequence would be that mentally ill individuals who did not find release from suffering through his program
Show More

Related Documents: Critique Of Counseling Theory: The Bondage Breaker

Coun 507 Theory Critique Anderson Essay examples

Counseling Theory Critique: The Bondage Breaker by Neil T. Anderson Brianna Zuver L24770662 Liberty University Course and Section #: 201120 Fall 2012 COUN 507-D12 LUO Sub-term D; Deadline: 12/02/2012 Instructor’s Name: Dr. James A. Laine Date of Submission: 12/01/2012 Counseling Theory Critique: The Bondage Breaker by Neil T. Anderson “Dealing with the demonic should be seen as a truth encounter rather than a power encounter” (Anderson, 2000, p. 258) this quote by…

Words 1586 - Pages 7

Black Counter Narrative And The Public Secret In Critical Race Theory

Black Counter Narrative and The Public Secret in Critical Race Theory Kate S Kelley University of Missouri (1999) Abstract This essay examines the use of counter narrative in Critical Race Theory and its exposure of racism in the United States as a public secret. Anthropologist Michael Taussig (1999) points out that the core of secrecy is power; thus the core of public power is the public secret. The power inherent in the idea of a secret is that it is privileged knowledge that should…

Words 1873 - Pages 8

Critique Of Dr. Hart's Theory: Stress And Depression

Theory Critique 3 – Hart Anonymous Graduate Student Liberty University Theory Critique 3 – Hart In an interesting summation of adrenaline and its effect on brain tranquillizers, Dr. Archibald D. Hart (1999) presents a fascinating perspective on the adrenaline-anxiety connection in his well-received book, The Anxiety Cure. Hart suggests emotional tranquility and wholeness is possible and examines strategies to overcome anxiety as he explores the connection between stress…

Words 1849 - Pages 8

Essay History: Second Boer War and Capitalist Financiers

drive for imperialism. Historians have often viewed it as a polemical (controversial) approach as it misses out important parts of British imperialism that does not necessarily contain an economic drive for expansion. This view is supported by M.S Anderson in which he has associated imperialism with not just economic expansion but also with political and religious factors to support imperialism. After his experience in the Second Boer War, Hobson’s view simply contain the actions of greedy capitalist…

Words 647 - Pages 3

Supply Chain Management Literature Review

Supply Chain Management: A Literature Review David Smith BUSI 610 Organizational Design and Structure Abstract Supply chain management is a practice that involves the planning, supervision, and implementation of strategies and controls to direct the movement of goods and services provided to customers. The intent of this essay is to incorporate a synopsis of existing literature and to provide the reader with a general understanding of how supply chain management correlates with the organizational…

Words 5857 - Pages 24

Media Portrayal Of Modern Family

numerous deferent families that all have different theories connected to them. There are three families that star in the show. The show centers around three families, all of which interact with each other. Not only does Modern Family deal with the traditional family (portrayed by the Dunphys), but also introduces a homosexual couple (Mitchell Pritchett and Cameron Tucker), and a mixed marriage (the Pritchetts). The main theory however, is the feminist theory. “It examines womens social roles, experience…

Words 1916 - Pages 8

Theories Of Internationalization

into new markets is “natural” while for others it is quite challenging (Alon and Banai, 2000). Internationalization brings challenges to a firm in terms of where they are likely to invest, how to access the new market, the methods as well as the theories which the firm should make use of. While some of the firms might be forced to internationalize in the early phases of their operations as a result of saturated markets at home, others often choose to move abroad as a result of the available opportunities…

Words 3571 - Pages 15

PAD510Assignment 2 Essay

Federal Death Penalty Law, the Capital Case Review Procedure and indicate the context of the day and urgency of these policies. This paper will also analyze the social, economic and political environments for the times the policies were implemented. Critiques and effectiveness will also be discussed. A one page summary will be given on the Capital Case Review Procedure including the purpose, the context and recommendations from the policy to address the problem. Official players, unofficial players and…

Words 1517 - Pages 7

Mass Media Forms Essay

Screens are everywhere • Both public and private spaces • We multitask • When they fail we are “anxious” • Shift away from “mass” to narrow markets 2 The Masses and Mass Media • Emile Durkheim • Karl Marx - concept of the masses • Media Theory - concept of the masses • Term Mass Media 3 Emile Durkheim (French sociologist) - in industrial societies, collective sentiments and a collective conscience of the masses came to determine what constituted a crime, the action is deemed a crime…

Words 3576 - Pages 15

Impact of Micro-Finance on Economic Development Essay

Introduction In both developing and emerging economies, microfinance has vastly and increasingly been seen as one of the most important means for enhancing the lives of the poor and therefore a major tool for economic and social development mostly in rural areas. Lately, contrary to this widespread belief, critics have raised eyebrows against this growing popularity of microfinance as a major tool for enhancing economic development. Contrary to belief, they are of the opinion that microfinance is…

Words 3747 - Pages 15