Antonin Scalia Case Analysis

Words: 1080
Pages: 5
Open Document
Recently, Antonin Scalia, one of the eight associate supreme justices died at the end of Barack Obama’s term which is causing major controversy for the next supreme justice that will fill his vacancy can cause a significant power shift to liberals in the Supreme Court justice union. With only 8 Supreme Court justices left there is an equal balance between liberals and conservatives in the Supreme Court justice union (4-4). The next supreme justices to fill the vacancy of Antonin Scalia will break that 4 to 4 tie and give the power to either the liberals or the conservatives. The process of getting a new supreme justices is pretty simple. The current president which is Obama, him and his advisors will have to nominate someone they think will strongly and honestly enforce the law, being a …show more content…
If a liberal is put to be the new supreme justice it could change the way the Supreme Court deals with cases that are similar to past cases that have set precedents in which the court declare certain acts constitutional or unconstitutional. With Conservatives having to rule the court 5 to 4 for decades the change of liberals coming on top on a 5-4 decision they have the supremacy to uphold or break old laws and precedents changing the way federal laws are dealt with. Essentially, with the senate’s decision on fighting against Obamas’ nominations of a new supreme justice it could lead to a filibuster which will delay the voting process of a new supreme court until next January when the new president is in office serving his first term. The SCOTUS will still have to go to deal with pending cases with eight supreme justices that will most likely will result in 4 - 4 ties leaving the lower court decisions to be upheld. Importance cases involving abortion, affirmative action, and voting rights in which Scalia were all opposed to would have been denied and deemed unconstitutional but with Scalia presence missing these cases have a high chance of having a
Show More

Related Documents: Antonin Scalia Case Analysis

Abortion: a Routine Abortion Rights Case Essay

Senate are in power. Two or three key justices retire and are easily replaced by justices of the Scalia-Thomas mold. A routine abortion rights case makes its way to our nation's highest court...and in a 5-4 majority ruling, Justice Antonin Scalia writes words never before handed down by the Supreme Court: "We find in the Constitution no implicit right to privacy." Unlikely? Very. But in the final analysis, this is what we're fighting over. Conservative presidential candidates say that they will work…

Words 413 - Pages 2

Death Penalty Essays

September 26, 1981 Amanda and Nick Wilcox, whose daughter was murdered, are against the death penalty as the solution for punishing those who committed murder. The families of those who were murder victims may say that justice will be served in the case of the death penalty, but that is not the opinion of the Wilcox’s. The Wilcox’s feel even more so with what happened to their daughter that the death penalty will not return their daughter and may not bring the closure that families seek. The Wilcox’s…

Words 1382 - Pages 6

Death Penalty Essay

September 26, 1981 Amanda and Nick Wilcox, whose daughter was murdered, are against the death penalty as the solution for punishing those who committed murder. The families of those who were murder victims may say that justice will be served in the case of the death penalty, but that is not the opinion of the Wilcox’s. The Wilcox’s feel even more so with what happened to their daughter that the death penalty will not return their daughter and may not bring the closure that families seek. The Wilcox’s…

Words 1384 - Pages 6

patriot act Essay

United States v. Jardines In 2006, Detective William Pedraja of the Miami-Dade Police Department received an unverified tip that marijuana was being grown in the home of respondent Joelis Jardines. One month later, the Department and the Drug Enforcement Administration sent a joint surveillance team to Jardines home. Detective Pedraja was part of that team. He watched the home for fifteen minutes and saw no vehicles in the driveway or activity around the home, and could not see inside because the…

Words 4455 - Pages 18

Science, Intelligent Design, And The Constitution

of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech.” His answer, in brief, is that religion should, and constitutionally may have, a more prominent place in the public school curriculum than is currently the case in most public schools, but whatever public schools do, they may not teach “religious propositions” as true or have students participate in religious activities. Greenawalt thus stakes out a position in the culture war that falls between the extremes…

Words 6559 - Pages 27

Civil Liberties And The War On Terrorism

executive in wartime and upheld the removal of Japanese Americans from the West Coast.7 The McCarthy era saw enormous persecution of those suspected of being communists. Jobs were lost and lives were ruined on the flimsiest of allegations. In the leading case of the era, Dennis v. United States,8 the Court approved twenty-year prison sentences for individuals for the crime of “conspiracy . . . to advocate the overthrow of the [g]overnment” for teaching works by Marx and Lenin.9 This brief recitation of…

Words 8949 - Pages 36