Arguments Against Brain Identity Theory

Words: 944
Pages: 4
Open Document
Living creature is composing with material substances and immaterial substances. There are physical properties and mental properties in human body. When thinking or doing something, our brain starts to process what is going and our mind starts to gather all the feeling and emotion associated to our thought. I will be arguing that brain and mind identity theory is not in a defendable position which explains that mind is an existing immaterial substance. I will be begin from defining key terms to clarify the meaning and follow with the arguments against my thesis with the evidence to backed up my point of view.

Everything in the universe is made up of matter, universe is made up of small physical materials in the space or even human body that …show more content…
It has it own mass, size and weight and interactive with other physical bodies. Mind is an immaterial substance that consider as a part of brain that includes consciousness, thought, mental processes and events as well as feeling of pain. Mind needs a privilege to access which others cannot access our mind unlike body that everyone could see it physically. Mind is an immaterial substance so it cannot work with out brain or move the body which implies that for mind to work we should have brain.

As oppose to the argument that mind-brain identity theory is not in a defendable position, Descartes theory seem to be the theory that I could use support my point. However, identity theory has an argument to weaken Descates theory of dualism. Real distinction argument that supports dualism becomes a problem in this context as well as the causal interaction with …show more content…
Scientific evidence is well prove with the theory. In the production to create heat, it starts from the kinetic energy. Molecules combine together to create heat which is like a process in our human mind. Thought was created by the brain, which thought and heat can’t be exist by themselves. They are the result from another processes. Therefore, there will be no metal state brain is not exist. Identity theory said that mind is brain, if its not how can immaterial like mind can involve. The evolution theory comes to take place, we all begin with the physical stage since we are an egg which has no mental properties. The mental properties start to develop when physical properties reached the certain level (Adebayo A., 2012). However, it’s possible for life to be form in the mental state with no brain involve in the same chemical-physical state. Saying that if mind and brain are identical, brain state and mental state must be the same, so what happen in mental state must happen in brain too which mental state develop at different time in our body. Therefore, how can immaterial mind be
Show More

Related Documents: Arguments Against Brain Identity Theory

Essay about Dualism: are the mind and body really insync or are they completely different entities?

there have been a numerous amount of theories that ultimately try to explain the world around us. Some of these theories such as the idealism theory, the theory of a parallel universe or the identity theory that try to explain why things are the way that they are. One of the most well known theories often discussed by philosophers is the dualism theory. Although it is a concept that is very abstract and difficult to grasp, it is one of the most dynamic theories that discusses the relationship between…

Words 831 - Pages 4

Ryle's Initial Argument Against Cartesian Dualism

I. Part one: Ryle's initial argument against Cartesian dualism is based on an epistemological viewpoint, meaning that this view has to do with the existence and understanding of knowledge. He claims that if we were to believe the Cartesian explanation of dualism, which claims that the mind and the body are completely separate things, we would have no way of understanding what others are feeling or thinking. Seeing as, with this explanation, it would be impossible to understand another human’s behaviors…

Words 1938 - Pages 8

Philosophy Paper

physically detectable source, but a product of the narratives we tell. We have the ability to create our own “selves,” which are represented by our behavior and language. Dennett uses his own narratives and metaphors to explicate his theory of a “self.” Each individual argument is illustrated in its own section as his thesis is developed and evolved. This reading attempts to modernize the older versions of a “self.” The initial idea of Dennett’s view was sparked during his first trip to London. He walked…

Words 1893 - Pages 8

Cartesian's Foundation On Metaphysics And Epistemological Thinking

Cartesian method bases its foundation on metaphysics and epistemological thinking. Their idea of knowledge was derived through reasons of innate ideas. This goes against the traditional beliefs of empiricism (all concepts originate with experience) that was established by Aristotle. Cartesians created probabilistic scientific concepts by observing and experimenting. However, they did not rely on the uncertainty in science since their beliefs of God were powerful. Their religious beliefs were that…

Words 1368 - Pages 6

Comparing Two Ways To Belong In America

disapproves of UT’s treatment of its Vietnamese language program. Make a copy of this document and share with me. Choose a good topic from your brainstorming (written). You’ve seen lots of examples: two things that represent different parts of an identity (Guavas); two types of people/approaches to life (Neat People vs Sloppy People, Two Ways to Belong); two approaches to a task (The Transaction); and two things that aren’t being treated equally (Football vs Asian Studies). There are more options…

Words 1601 - Pages 7

finalpsychology assignment done 2728 Essay

com/definition/english/philosophy?q=Philosophy, 2014) Theorists/Philosophers Before 1879 (2.1) Hippocrates (460 BC – 377 BC) René Descartes (1596 - 1650) Charles Darwin (1809- 1882) Hippocrates was a Greek physiologist who believed the mind and soul were in the brain and that the mind and body were separate things that interact, known as dualism. He is also known as being the father of medicine, Hippocrates rejected superstition of priests and started a medical school, teaching that all diseases were a result of…

Words 2825 - Pages 12

Geron Essay

respiratory functions. 3. irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain, including the brain stem. 4. irreversible cessation of the capacity for consciousness Answer | a. | 2 and 3 | | b. | 1 and 2 | | c. | 2 and 4 | | d. | 1 and 3 | __________ deals mainly with the notion that human beings survive in some form beyond the death of the physical body Answer | a. | Transgression theory | | b. | Mortal transformations | | c. | Personal mortality | | d. | Nonempirical…

Words 7080 - Pages 29

Gender Stereotypes In The Media

Male and female identities are not just represented in the media or in music that I listen to that drills into my brain, but also the magazines I am reading, the culture and ethnicity that I belong to. Furthermore, even the religion that I grew up with my family, that believes women have diminished men’s assurance and lost status. There are representations of men and women, which are expressed in different ways and with diverse characteristics. For example, the quote from the article, “Just as’…

Words 636 - Pages 3

School: Human and Wolfe Essay

behavior, knowledge, and beliefs, manners, and mores, and, above all for Wolfe, status, which then informs human motivation and actions. Wolfe is open to the idea that neuroscience might eventually be able to explain every detail of how and why the human brain functions as it does but he is skeptical that it will be able to explain away completely the idea that each of us is an individual, striving for honor and success within our status sphere. Keywords: science, human nature, Tom Wolfe ach year, the National…

Words 9513 - Pages 39

Chapter 13 Outline Essay

others' behavior and form an impression of them Attribution * Interferences means to determine the underlying cause for an individual's behavior then taking that information and coming up with a guess about who someone is * Attribution theory is people's motivation to discover the underlying causes of behavior in order to make sense of it * The three dimension of attribution: * Internal/external causes * Internal attributions are the individual's traits and abilities…

Words 2941 - Pages 12