Arguments Against Legalizing Assisted Suicide

Words: 1655
Pages: 7
Open Document
Introduction

In the world of medical ethics, the debate over the legalization of assisted suicide has sparked interest. The contention revolves around whether assisting terminally ill patients to end their lives upon request is morally justifiable. This paper contends that legalizing assisted suicide at the request of the patient is a compassionate and ethically defensible response to the suffering of terminally ill individuals. By upholding the principles of autonomy, compassion, and dignity in end-of-life care, assisted suicide provides a humane option for those facing unbearable pain and irreversible conditions.

Presenting Arguments to Support the Thesis.

Looking at this topic, there are very many different ideas that can support this …show more content…
Terminally ill individuals, facing the prospect of prolonged suffering and loss of quality of life, should have the autonomy to choose the timing and manner of their death. Legalizing assisted suicide empowers patients with the autonomy to exert control over their final moments, preserving their dignity and sense of agency. As well as helping healthcare professionals feel as though they are helping the patients how they want to be treated. Another key point is relief from unbearable suffering, as many terminally ill patients endure immense physical and psychological suffering as their conditions progress. Despite advancements in palliative care, some forms of suffering remain unmanageable, leading to diminished quality of life. Diane Pretty suffers from motor neurone disease and is experiencing the disintegration of her own body. In the end, she was denied the legal right to choose the circumstances of her death. This decision may be consistent with legal precedent, but it’s morally wrong (Doyal, 1). Diane is going to suffer the rest of her life until her death because of the issues with not allowing assisted suicide, even when the …show more content…
For objection 1 ethical concerns about the sanctity of life, there are deeply held moral principles that make sense but they must be balanced against other ethical considerations, such as autonomy and compassion. In cases where individuals face intolerable suffering with no hope of relief, respecting their autonomous decisions to end their lives can be a morally justifiable course of action that upholds the important principles of compassion and dignity. The perfect example would be Diane Pretty, who was denied the ability to end her life even when she would be in pain for the rest of her life. Even if doctors believed that medical treatment could provide no benefit because of her inability to even engage in any type of self-directed activities, they could legally withdraw life-sustaining treatment like hydration and nutrition (Doyal, 1). Looking closer at objection 2, the risk of coercion and abuse, some safeguards and regulations can be implemented to mitigate the risk of coercion and abuse in the practice of assisted suicide. Looking closer into this, there are new laws quite often to make sure that there are correct laws in place that protect the people targeted such as the elderly, psychologically ill, etc. These regulations may include stringent eligibility criteria, thorough evaluations by multiple healthcare
Show More

Related Documents: Arguments Against Legalizing Assisted Suicide

Assisted Sucide Essay

Physician Assisted Suicide Should Be Legal Laura Germinario PHI Informal Logic/103 May 7, 2012 Stephen Carter, Ph.D. Physician assisted suicide is the practice of providing a patient with information, medication, and or equipment to use to end their own life. Physician assisted suicide remains a controversial issue both legally and morally (Wolfsast, 2008).The debate on whether to legalize physician assisted suicide has been alive for centuries. Some parts of the world like Australia have legalized…

Words 1695 - Pages 7

Physician Assisted Suicide Research Paper

Physician-Assisted Suicide According to a poll taken in 2015, nearly 68% of people think leagalizing would be a practice(When a person has a disease…). Physician-assisted suicide can be defined as a case in which a doctor knowingly gives a patient the means to end their own life at their request. It is often confused with euthanasia, which is the execution of lethal means by a physician instead of the patient. Five states, including Oregon, Washington, Vermont, Montana, and California, legally allow…

Words 808 - Pages 4

Prohibition: United States and Suicide Essay

the fact that we don’t always like to be told what to do so how much control does the government really have over us? One big topic that has been continually controversial to our country over the years in assisted suicide. Currently there are three states in the United States where assisted suicide is legal; Oregon, Washington and Vermont. There are certain conditions in the states of Oregon and Washington before a physician will commit to helping a patient. In both Oregon and Washington the conditions…

Words 794 - Pages 4

Legalizing Euthanasia In Canada

In recent decades, the question of legalizing euthanasia has been a global controversy in medical, philosophic and human rights field. Several countries in Europe and in North and South America already allow doctors to help patients end their lives. However, in Canada, the law of legalizing euthanasia has not totally been passed by the Supreme Court of Canada yet. According to Paul C Webster’s article “Canada to legalise physician-assisted dying,” in February 2015, all nine judges in Canada's Supreme…

Words 1449 - Pages 6

Physician Assisted Suicide

society suicide is seen as something ghastly, but what about Physician-assisted Suicide? how is it seen? Is it still just as bad as a “regular suicide” or is it different because it is being done by a professional? Most cases of suicide are performed by the person themselves over 34,000 people commit suicide a year, in later years suicide will bypass deaths from cancer, stroke, war and accidents according to the World Health Organization. Most people who do not have an illness commit suicide due to…

Words 1461 - Pages 6

Physician Assisted Suicide Ethics

Over the past decade one of the most controversial topics in modern American society has been discussion involving the moral and ethical standards linked to physician assisted suicide. Physician assisted suicide can be described as any case when a medical practitioner is allowed to help a patient actively determine the time and circumstances of their death. This process is most commonly carried out when a medical practitioner provides a patient with access to a lethal dose of medication which the…

Words 1015 - Pages 5

Legal Euthanasia Essay

Washington has legalized euthanasia as well as the Netherlands, Belgium, and Luxembourg. Montana’s Supreme Court in 2010 determined that assisted suicide is considered a medical treatment. Euthanasia and assisted suicide are almost the same thing but they are also slightly different. Euthanasia occurs when a doctor performs the act in which causes death. Assisted suicide is when the patient performs an act with the prior help of a doctor that causes death. For example, if the performing doctor injects…

Words 2464 - Pages 10

Law docx Essay

Voluntary Euthanasia/ Physician-Assisted Suicide. Voluntary Euthanasia/ Physician-Assisted Suicide as being practiced in some parts of the western world today to me is immoral. Physician-Assisted suicide ( physician provide patients with drugs to kill them) is legal in countries such as Germany, Switzerland, and Japan , as well as states like Washington, Oregon, Vermont, New Mexico, and Montana. This policy should be changed for these following logical and ethical reasons because to me it is unjust…

Words 974 - Pages 4

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

choose when they want to end their life. By legalizing PAS, terminally ill patients will have the right to choose immediate death instead of suffering through a terminal illness which will ultimately cause unbearable pain and suffering for the patient and family. The patient can die with dignity rather than becoming a shell of their former selves. Without PAS people may commit suicide in a messy, horrifying or traumatic manor. Physician assisted suicide (PAS) is not for everyone, but for someone who…

Words 2413 - Pages 10

Assisted Suicide Research Paper

Assisted Suicide and Physicians Part Ethically Unacceptable and Morally Wrong Abstract Assisted Suicide: No Toleration Should We as a Society Play God? 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Background Terminally-ill patients choose to take their own life but require assistance. The state of Oregon classifies such an intention as assisted suicide and in legal terms through its Death with Dignity Act as when “a terminally ill Oregonian chooses to end their life through voluntary self administrating of…

Words 2201 - Pages 9