Arguments: Reasonable Minimum Wages Essay

Submitted By maya_djuric

Words: 403

Pages: 2

Open Document

Topic 3 - If a Canadian firm owns a factory located in a foreign country, should Canadian firms pay the same wages in both countries?
Counterpoint: No, since the cost of living in the foreign country is likely to be much less than in Canada therefore the workers do not require as much income.
__________________________________________________________________
Argument #1: Paying a factory worker in a foreign country similar wages to a factory worker in Canada would inflate their economy because the factory worker could make a salary similar to a doctors.
Consumer Prices in Indonesia are 48.36% lower than in Canada
Consumer Prices Including Rent in Indonesia are 51.00% lower than in Canada
Rent Prices in Indonesia are 58.09% lower than in Canada
Restaurant Prices in Indonesia are 70.09% lower than in Canada
Groceries Prices in Indonesia are 44.93% lower than in Canada
Local Purchasing Power in Indonesia is 75.86% lower than in Canada

Low paid nurses/ teachers would leave their jobs to join working in a factory because of easier workloads and better hours which would result in ruining the education and health systems of that country
Governments, not companies, set reasonable minimum wages:
Governments have to think about their international competitiveness, and are all too aware that corporations will move elsewhere if labour costs become too high

Argument #2: Outsourcing is much more cost effective, and in order for a Canadian company to be profitable and remain in business they must outsource work to foreign countries.

Apple has to source parts worldwide because similar Car

Toulmin Argument Analysis

method is an analysis that goes very in depth in an argument. It breaks the argument in parts and when read, it shows how effective the argument is all together. The passage goes over how the United States is facing a problem with illegal immigrants and the United States wants to get rid of them. The authors go over the possible way of overcoming that obstacle by providing clear cut facts and in depth analysis. This overall was a very effective argument due to the author using the Toulmin method. The…

Words 852 - Pages 4

Inmate Labour In America Research Paper

system. In both government operated and privately run prisons, inmates are often times forced to work for extraordinarily low wages or for free, or, alternatively, face unpleasant consequences if they refuse to do so. While some believe that this is simply a consequence of being incarcerated and/or they are getting what they deserve, inmates should be entitled to a reasonable wage and the right to refuse to work for anything less than that or,…

Words 1055 - Pages 5

Minimum Wage Research Paper

Research Essay Minimum wage Jacob R Pettry Zane State College Minimum Wage As early as 6.00 am in a dark and cold morning of Midwest winter, a few people walking on an icy sidewalk. Under chilling wind, those people walk to a large, old building. Inside the building, the people work for repetitive, backbreaking low waged jobs. In the same day, late at night, you can see similar scene: some people walking out of the building under heavy snowstorm. Like all workers, they feel exhausted after…

Words 1396 - Pages 6

Minimum Wage Argument

The argument of minimum wage has been around for a long time and is still a problem in society today. Some people find minimum wage to be enough to live on while others do not. Some struggle trying to make ends meet on minimum wage, while others do not. That is why it is such a common problem in today's society as a whole. Some believe that society needs to change the minimum wage while others believe it is fine just the way it is. An author named Mike Kilen tells about how people are trying to…

Words 1649 - Pages 7

Unemployment: Unemployment and Small Businesses Essay

it is a nationwide issue. Many individuals have been affected due to this; in addition, many individuals are suffering. A few of these solutions may help reduce the unemployment rate: creating or saving small businesses, reimburse some part of minimum wage paid to American workers, crack down on immigration. By saving small businesses they can help reduce unemployment rate, giving more jobs to people who really need them. Economists, Ben Shalom Bernanke, and organizations like the Small Business…

Words 895 - Pages 4

Essay about Executive Memo Muhammad Ali

Ontario Liberal government’s push to increase the minimum wage up to $11.00 per hour from $10.25 per hour. Kline claims that an increase in the minimum wage is not the solution. According to him, a minimum wage increase is in fact detrimental for the economy because it increases the poverty stricken population and drives communities further below the poverty line. Instead, he argues that progress can be made on this front by shifting the focus from the wage increase to more promising alternatives, which…

Words 2902 - Pages 12

Externality and Government Essay

country’s economy based on National minimum wage that was introduced in 1999.Government intervention is an action taken from the government that alter or change economic activeness, supply ability, and the unconstrained decisions made through normal market trade. Throughout numerous years many companies have been paying employee’s very low wages the minimum wage is a price that is imposed by the government on the labour market. The main aim of implementing a minimum wage was to increase the standard of…

Words 2242 - Pages 9

Essay on Assignment 1

integrity, assets, trading practices, etc. Disciplinary actions, including termination, could be enforced towards any associate that violates or chooses to not follow their principals. They state that when bringing in third parties there should be reasonable steps taken to insure that they are provided and made aware of Wal-Mart’s ethical statement as well their reputation for integrity. As the nation’s largest retailer, second-largest corporation, and largest private employer, Wal-Mart made headlines…

Words 1818 - Pages 8

Essay on Employment Law in NZ

Hubbard, Thomas and Vamham have written that “employment differs from other contracts in that there is frequently a substantial inequality of bargaining, especially in times of widespread unemployment”. This essay will discuss about the notion of equality of bargaining in an employment agreement. This will also discuss the provisions and related cases on unjustifiable dismissal in the Employment Relations Act 2000. Over the course of the last century, the employment law has favoured strongly…

Words 2498 - Pages 10

Outsourcing: United States and Economy Essay

From a business standpoint, outsourcing has major benefits. Much more lax labor laws, and requirements in other countries mean more production for less money. In the United States, corporations face a plethora of taxes, and comparatively higher minimum wage standards than in countries such as India where many jobs are outsourced to. This allows for a cheaper priced product than what is totally produced in the USA. Multinational corporations have come under fire in the last few decades for the conditions…

Words 592 - Pages 3