Asia: Atomic Bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and Source Essay

Submitted By John_Smith197
Words: 1052
Pages: 5
Open Document
US policy of ‘nation building’ had succeeded in Japan by 1954.
In my opinion, the US succeeded in rebuilding Japan in their image and for their benefit. Sources A, B and D believe that the US succeeded in their ‘nation building’, whereas sources C and E disagree with and say that the US failed in this area.
I believe that source A agrees with the statement the most but I also believe it to be the most unreliable source. We can see that the source agrees with the statement, from when it says “Greatest reformation recorded in modern history” and also when he states “they have done this with commendable will, eagerness to learn, and marked capacity to understand.” This could show what was actually happening in Japan or it could just have been positive propaganda, so the US congress does not feel as though all of their money has gone to waste. But we can also say that MacArthur could have been lying to congress because we know that when he says that “a truly representative government has been created”, we know that this is not true because in the first democratic election in Japan the US just rigged the election so that someone they could control was in power, so we can say that he only said some of these things to make sure that congress kept providing money. I believe that this source supports the statement the most but also could be assumed as the most unreliable.
Source B also supports the statement but it also states what the Japanese people want from their new rulers as it is from a Japanese people themselves. From this source we can compare what the Japanese people they want and what the USA actually did, for example when the people ask for the US to “establish a popular government, based on the true will of the people never to break the peace of the world again.” We know this is not true because as I said earlier in the first democratic election the US rigged the election so that their wanted candidate got into power. But they do succeed in one of the points, to “achieve political and economic and social conditions which will not jeopardize the livelihood of the people.”, we know this to be true because it is one of the main points that the US set out to do, so that they had a major trade partner in the Pacific. From the text we may also be able to assume that the person writing is attempting to get onto the good side of the US, from when he says “We express our sincerest appreciation for the measures taken by the allied powers”, this may have been a lie because we can assume that the Japanese people were not very happy that the USA had atom bombed 2 of their cities killing millions of people, so we can presume that he is just saying this, so that his ideas could be thought about by the General. This source does support the statement but it also, in a way, tells the USA what the Japanese really want them to do with their country.
Source D in my opinion agrees with the statement. Source D in, I believe, is the least biased in its thought that the US succeeded in Japan, and it seems to focus more on the industry and the economic successes, for example “In 1947 the Americans improved the economic situation by relaxing their policy on the control of Japanese industry.” Which shows that the US succeeded in improving the Japanese economy, which was one of the points noted in source B as what the Japanese people want from the US policies. But he does also say that progress in this area was slow and that one of the only reasons the Japanese and Americans worked together was so that Japan did not fall to communism. In my opinion this source definitely supports the statement and he seems to quite a trustworthy source although it was written in 2001, 60 years after these events, so he may not have got all of these facts correct.
Source C I believe
Show More

Related Documents: Asia: Atomic Bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and Source Essay

History Atomic Bomb Essay

In early August 1945 atomic bombs were dropped on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. These two bombs quickly yielded the surrender of Japan and the end of American involvement in World War II. By 1946 the two bombs caused the death of perhaps as many as 240,000 Japanese citizens1. The popular, or traditional, view that dominated the 1950s and 60s – put forth by President Harry Truman and Secretary of War Henry Stimson – was that the dropping of the bomb was a diplomatic maneuver aimed…

Words 3526 - Pages 15

Toby s Essay

age. An example of a successful use of soft power is by the Soviet Union (USSR), in power in Russia officially from 1922 to 19913. The USSR were able to promote their political ideology of the communist party across the globe, particularly in Asia and Eastern Europe. Although they did use force to ensure annexed states remained under their control, they primarily launched a communist propaganda campaign showing the virtues of their culture to entice other states to follow soviet sponsored communist…

Words 2200 - Pages 9

Why Did Truman Dropped The Atomic Bomb

1. Identification and evaluation of sources The investigation, examining Truman's decision regarding the atomic bomb, that is his resolve to drop the destructive forces upon the Japanese city of Hiroshima and Nagasaki whilst still in his beginning months of presidency will attempt to answer the question: What factors influenced President Harry S. Truman to deploy the atomic bomb? The primary sources that will be analyzed are the writings of distinguished military writer historians Thomas B. Allen…

Words 1779 - Pages 8

Treaty Of Versailles Research Paper

troops soon spread out and by August Allied troops had liberated France. The first US troops later cross into Germany in September In October, General MacArthur and his troops invaded Philippine Island of Leyte hoping to separate Japan from S.E. Asia and its oil supply. Japan assembled what remained of the naval forces and engaged the U.S., wanting to drive them off the Philippine island. Ultimately, the battle was so one-sided that much of the Japanese fleet was destroyed and the remaining Japanese…

Words 2198 - Pages 9

Essay on Humn410 Final Exam

Top of Form |1. (TCO 1, 2) Analyze how nationalism and militarism contributed to the outbreak of World War I. | | | |Use historical examples to support your answer. | |…

Words 2063 - Pages 9

World War 2 Research Paper

estimated that more than 55 million people perished. More than 50 countries took part in the war, and the whole world felt its effects. Men fought in almost every part of the world, on every continent except Antarctica. Chief battlegrounds included Asia, Europe, North Africa, the Atlantic and Pacific oceans, and the Mediterranean Sea. The United States hoped to stay out. Drawing on its experience from World War I, Congress passed a series of Neutrality Acts between 1935 and 1939, which were intended…

Words 5356 - Pages 22

Taisho Research Paper

Introduction The radical shift in attitudes of Japanese society during the culmination of Meiji era and the dawn of the Taisho period “was characterized by a diminishing influence of the traditional authorities […] and more by open attitudes towards the West” (Tanaka). During the Taisho period (1912-1926 CE), western pop culture, persisting from the Meiji era, filtered through to the Japanese people and more and more progressive ideas began to take shape; notions like feminism, or even democracy…

Words 3593 - Pages 15

History Notes Essay

CHC2De Review World War One Causes Nationalism: a feeling of deep loyalty to one’s people and homeland Extreme nationalist movement People would go to war just to promote support of their homelands Especially intense in Serbia Austria-Hungary took Bosnia, where many Serbians lived Serbians were angered, and the “Black Hand” terrorist group was formed to unite Serbians Members threatened to kill Archduke Ferdinand if he entered Bosnia Austrians were also expressing nationalism, and strongly…

Words 5857 - Pages 24

A Brief History of Japan and How It Relates to Japan's Current Conflicts Essay

1 Introduction The country of Japan has had a tumultuous, and at times tragic, history. Since its inception in 300 B.C. from hunters and gatherers, to its almost complete isolation from the rest of the world in the seventeenth century, to two atomic bomb attacks in World War Two, and the earthquake in 2011, Japan’s people have been tested again and again. PAGEREF _Ref351725146 Despite these many conflicts, Japan’s influence throughout the rest of the world can be seen in art, technology, business…

Words 8068 - Pages 33

The Science Fiction Museum And Hall Of Fame

[EIGHT] WHAT INSPIRES THEM: SCIENCE FICTION’S IMPACT ON SCIENCE REALITY You can never tell when you make up something what will happen with it. You never know whether or not it will come true. —DONNA SHIRLEY The Science Fiction Museum and Hall of Fame appropriately stands in the shadow of Seattle’s futuristic landmark, the Space Needle. Set in a multicolored, globular Frank Gehry-designed building that looks like a cut-up guitar (a “ridiculous . . . monstrosity of postmodern architecture” is…

Words 8778 - Pages 36