Assess The Reasons For The Pilgrimage Of Grace

Words: 1305
Pages: 6
Open Document
Using your understanding of the historical context, assess how convincing the arguments in these three extracts are in relation to the reasons for the outbreak of the Pilgrimage of Grace.

Firstly, Extract A provides valid and useful inference into the social and political reasons for the outbreak of the Pilgrimage of Grace, but it undermines the important factor of religious influence, which interfered heavily with the motivation for the Pilgrimage of Grace at the time and was an essential contributor to its outbreak, due to the collapse of societal order perceived by most Catholics and ordinary civilians. For example, the extract states that the outbreak was “linked not to feudal or popular uproar but to the increasing distrust.towards a …show more content…
We could link this to the turning point in society made by 1534’s Act of Supremacy, which defined Henry as the supreme head of the Church of England. Fear may have arisen from this not only because of the lack of protection that the Pope could provide, but also Henry’s well-known ruthless nature and the potential for Catholicism as a whole to be banned- we could also see this fear arising from 1534’s Treason Act. Additionally, the new responsibility taken on by parliament was another major turning point, which strengthened the motivation for the Pilgrimage of Grace- mentioned in “A common interest joined the defeated court faction with the anti-court “country”.”. Therefore, Extract A is shown to have value in its depiction of the Pilgrimage of Grace being a social war of sorts. However, Extract A lacks any supporting opinion on the religious side of the reasons for the outbreak of the Pilgrimage of Grace, which was vital to its creation. Evidence for this could be seen within the Pontefract Articles, which were drawn up near the end of the Pilgrimage of Grace and could be assumed to be a final list of aims after the rebellion. They mentioned a need for the abbeys to be restored, and for Mary to
Show More

Related Documents: Assess The Reasons For The Pilgrimage Of Grace

Assess The Claim That Reform Of The Pri Essay

Assess the claim that reform of the Privy Council was the most important achievement of Cromwell’s Thomas Cromwell became Lord Privy Seal in 1536, a role which gave him as much authority over the king as a chief minister and allowed him to influence Henry and impose his own beliefs on the kingdom. During his tenure in such a high position, he made a number of changes- so much so that it has even been argued his policies amounted to a “revolution in government”. His most important achievement should…

Words 906 - Pages 4

In the context of the years 1485 to 1603 to what extent was the government of England dysfunctional in the mid-Tudor period? Essay

In the context of the years 1485 to 1603 to what extent was the government of England dysfunctional in the mid-Tudor period? During the Tudor Dynasty it is easily thought that the years between 1547 and 1558 were ones of crisis. With the succession of a child and the first woman within England, people have assumed that the years between Henry VIII and Elizabeth I were an unproductive interlude. The mid Tudor period is seen as negative years within the Tudor Dynasty. It is regarded that Henry VIII…

Words 3548 - Pages 15

Essay on Menstrual Cycle and Fanciful Isadora Wing

a heightened degree, Alice, the prototypical child, exhibits this same sense of confusion in wonderland. Within the framework of her adventures, reality and fantasy, sense and nonsense, sanity and insanity are juxtaposed to create a dream-like world. Erica Jong's repeated references to Carroll's work clearly link Alice to Isadora. Because of their repetitiousness, Isadora describes her conversations with Adrian “like quotes from Through the Looking-Glass.” In Wonderland, the Red Queen explains to…

Words 4678 - Pages 19