Autonomy Vs Paternalism

Words: 2082
Pages: 9
Open Document
In recent years, ethicists have argued against most forms of medical paternalism. They have claimed that it is wrong for physicians to make decisions for their patients, or to impose their own values upon their patients. On this view, when physicians act paternalistically, they fail to show adequate respect for their patient’s autonomy. I believe that physicians have the right to act paternalistically if the patient gives the doctors permission and/or if the patient is not capable/conscious to be able to make a decision that will benefit their greater good in the long run.
What is Autonomy? Before jumping right into paternalism, I thought it might be informative to know what autonomy is because they are so closely related. Autonomy is the …show more content…
Paternalism is used by officials and medical professionals. They look at your all around preferences and judge them on a standard of deeper preferences when configuring limitations and freedoms. However, there are four types of preferences that prevent paternalistic intervention. They are relevant, settled, preferred, and your own preferences (Komrad 2014). As long as officials are convinced you are acting on one or all of those preferences, they have no right to step in. The disadvantages to paternalism are that most people feel that they should be able to make their own decisions without having any interference. Paternalism is looked down upon when someone feels that their best interest was in the choice they made but paternalists feel differently. For example take a girl named Alexis. She had been smoking from the age of 15, a very effectible age, and though she attempted to quit many times, the loss of her autonomy caused the addiction to take over. Her smoking then caused cancer; paternalism was too late for her. The paternalistic view may say that, at age 15, Alexis’ decision may have been to smoke, but her decision later in life is to live. If paternalistic intervention occurred when she was 15, she may not have liked it then, but knowing what she knows now, she would have been grateful later in life. This is an example of the decision being something you would regret later and being
Show More

Related Documents: Autonomy Vs Paternalism

Hard Vs Soft Paternalism

evidence of institutionalization and broadly-based cultural support) - paternalism: it involves some kind of limitation on the freedom or autonomy of some agent and it does so for a particular class of reasons. As with many other concepts used in normative debate determining the exact boundaries of the concept is a contested issue - hard vs soft paternalism: soft: the view that the only conditions under which state paternalism is justified is when it is necessary to determine whether the person…

Words 326 - Pages 2

The Chief Of Medicine

2:00 PM PHIL 327 Think Piece #2 The Chief of Medicine How would you describe the Chief of Medicine in terms of his view of the patient/physician relationship (Strong Autonomy vs. Strong Paternalism)? During the article, the Chief of Medicine is showing strong paternalism in terms of his view of the patient/physician workforce. Paternalism as a description of patient-physician relationship is defined as "the attitudes or actions of a person that protects people and gives them what they need but does…

Words 327 - Pages 2

Personal Liberty Vs. Social Responsibility

who, what, when, and where). Too much of this detail should not be put in your intro paragraph, but in the first major body paragraph of your essay (this one). b) Go into details of the ethical issue at stake. Is it about personal liberty vs social responsibility? A conflict of duties or interests? The exploitation of the vulnerable? The creation of harm without unequal consideration? Here, you should also connect concepts like duty, lying, reasoning, double standards, harm, consequences…

Words 385 - Pages 2

Who's Life Is It Anyway Essay

meaning to exist. Ken’s doctors believed that since he was breathing, talking and thinking, that his life still had value. They felt morally obligated to keep him alive, even if it was not his choice. The fundamental argument in the quality of life vs. sanctity of life debate is the value of life. Ken felt that the quality of his life had diminished enough to warrant euthanasia. He became extremely frustrated because he felt his sexuality had been taken away from him and he had lost the ability to…

Words 1454 - Pages 6

Study Guide for Human Resource Management Test Essay

(tie people to job) Job Status-Based Rewards - Includes job evaluation and status perks Advantages: job evaluation tries to maintain fairness, motivates competition for promotions Disadvantages: encourages bureaucratic hierarchy, reinforces status vs egalitarian culture, and employees exaggerate duties, hoard resources Competency-Based Rewards Types 1. Broad competency-based pay bands - employees paid more within pay band as they demonstrate more competencies 2. Skill-based pay - employees paid…

Words 5351 - Pages 22

Essay on United States and Power Major Power

Explorative relationships Rich countries make developing countries dependent upon them Through trade Through debt Constructivism How we frame and define, in order to create meaning/power Privilege some meanings over others Examples Pro-life vs. Pro-choice Pulling out vs. Withdrawal Collateral damage State system: evolution & structure Polarity Theories of war Power Stability When major power changes, war is likely to occur Unipolar A single country (hegemon) has most of the power, can do anything they…

Words 5539 - Pages 23

Beyond Culturalism Essay examples

Aust. Educ. Res. (2013) 40:91–108 DOI 10.1007/s13384-012-0080-x Beyond culturalism: addressing issues of Indigenous disadvantage through schooling Amanda Keddie • Christina Gowlett • Martin Mills Sue Monk • Peter Renshaw • Received: 20 July 2012 / Accepted: 28 November 2012 / Published online: 7 December 2012 Ó The Australian Association for Research in Education, Inc. 2012 Abstract This paper draws from a study that explored issues of student equity, marginality and diversity in two secondary…

Words 8913 - Pages 36

Gp Essay Mainpoints

GP NOTES 2010 (ESSAY) Content Page 1. Media a. New vs. Traditional b. New: narcissistic? c. Government Censorship d. Profit-driven Media e. Advertising f. Private life of public figures g. Celebrity as a role model h. Blame media for our problems i. Power + Responsibility of Media j. Media ethics k. New Media and Democracy 2. Science/Tech a. Science and Ethics b. Government and scientist role in science c. Rely too much on technology? d. Nuclear technology…

Words 24667 - Pages 99

Sources of Ethics Essay

TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0- JOHN STEINER AND GEORGE STEINER SIX PRIMARY SOURCES OF ETHICS: 6 1- Religion: 6 2- Genetic Inheritance: 8 3- Philosophical Systems: 8 4- Cultural Experience: 8 5- The Legal System: 9 6- Codes of Conduct: 9 2.0- EXPLANATION OF THE SOURCES OF ETHICS: 10 2.1- RELIGION: 10 Teaching business ethics 12 2.11- Impact Of Religiosity: 13 2.12- Ethics Of Islam: 14 Nature of Islamic Ethics 17 The Human-Environment Relationship: 20 The Sustainable…

Words 20200 - Pages 81