Bartleby enters as an enigma to the readers and the lawyer himself. With this enigma comes the desire from the lawyer, along with the reader due to human instinct, to understand the complexities of Bartleby and the slow removal of the green divide the lawyer sets. Melville describes Bartleby through the lawyer at the first entrance as, “pallidly neat, pitiably respectablel, incurably forlorn” all of which are sarcastic comments made by the lawyer to describe Bartleby (301). The lawyer almost feels obligated to compliment him but with these comments come an adjective to negate this compliment. These comments attributed to Bartleby correlates to his eventual death which foreshadows the eventual fate of Bartleby and the decline of himself with the “charitable” acts of the lawyer. This also gives rise to the secret the lawyer eventually tells of Bartleby’s previous occupation in a dead letter