Baseball Rules: Court Case Study

Words: 438

Pages: 2

Open Document

There is currently a rule in place called the “Baseball rule,” which says that baseball stadiums only need to have netting behind home plate and that fans are sitting in the seats close to the action at their own risk. (Juliano, 2010) There have been a couple of lawsuits that have been filed dealing with the so-called “Baseball Rule.” An example is Mantovani vs. Yale University. In this lawsuit, the plaintiff was injured by a foul ball in the right field pavilion at a minor league baseball game. (Juliano, 2010) The pavilion had picnic tables with seating that were facing away from the field. The plaintiff argued that the defendant, which in this case was the baseball stadium, knew about the risk of foul balls in the pavilion but failed to protect or warn patrons ahead of time. …show more content…
(Juliano, 2010) The baseball stadium won this case because of the "baseball rule." In another related lawsuit that happened in the Massachusetts Appeals Court, a spectator was injured by a foul ball at Fenway Park. (Abrams, 2015) Her claim was that she had never attended a game before and had no idea of the risks involved. (Abrams, 2015) The Justice ruled against her though and said, “The dangers are obvious to a person with average intelligence.” (Abrams, 2015) This person had to have known that a foul ball could enter the stands at any time during the game. While the MLB remains protected from lawsuits due to the "Baseball Rule," fans continue to be injured each year in situations the could be prevented. As Roger Abrams states “Why would anyone subject themselves to such danger at a baseball game? Because it is the experience of going to a game.” (Abrams, 2015) This experience is what keeps fans coming back in spite of the possible risks of

Exam #1 Study Guide Essay

Comparative Advantage * Demand and Supply * Price elasticity of Demand * Relationship between price, price elasticity and demand, and total revenue * Concept of Production Function * Marginal Revenue Product = marginal factor cost – rule for determining how much resource input to employ Factors Influencing Behavior of Sports Franchises * Goals/objectives (maximize profits or winning percentage) * Fans prefer wins to profits, however the owners may prefer profits over…

Words 2443 - Pages 10

African American and Civil Rights Essay

most effective and celebrated leaders of the underground railroad. In 1857the Dred Scott Decision Dred Scott was a slave whose master took him to live in a free state of Illinois after his master died he sued in court for his freedom based that hews living in a free state the Supreme Court decided that black are not U. S citizen and could never be U.S. citizens this was a hard blow for blacks. They slaves used to be bullwhipped and lots of them had scar on their backs. In 1865 on April 9th…

Words 2575 - Pages 11

Political Science2 Essay

POLITICAL SCIENCE 001 Dr. DURUKAN TEST # 2 STUDY GUIDE Chapter 11- THE CONGRESS Why was Congress created? Congress was created so that states would have representation. Congress is in charge of controlling the federal government, foreign trade and policy, and the military. What are the functions of Congress? Congress has four functions lawmaking, representation, constituent services, and oversight. The Lawmaking Function The principal and most obvious function Requires decisions about the size…

Words 1627 - Pages 7

Violent Crimes Should Be Tried As Adults

other criminals are being released from jail every day after serving very short and lenient sentences. Who are these criminals and what makes them so special? The criminals are juveniles who commit violent crimes. They are being tried in juvenile courts and are receiving shortened sentences, if a person under the age of 18 is able and willing to commit a violent crime, they should be tried as an adult according to the government laws. Somehow age doesn’t seem reason enough to justify or dilute the…

Words 869 - Pages 4

What Were The Events That Led To The Meeting Of The Constitutional Convention?

100. When and where did World War I start? The event that triggered World War I was the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo on June 28, 1914. He was shot by Gavrilo Princip, a Bosnian revolutionary opposed to Austro-Hungarian rule. 101. When did the United States enter the war? April 6, 1917 102. Who was the United States president at the time? Woodrow Wilson 103. When was the armistice signed? How do we observe that date now? November 11, 1918 at…

Words 2531 - Pages 11

Vs. Americ How DIII College Athletes Fuel Their Bodies In The Fast Food Age

where we can fit them in” (Jackson). The problem is that our days are not centered around meals, or food for that matter. Our days are centered around the next task. In college, students are walking (or running, if late) to class, meeting with their study group, planning a project, writing a paper, going to practice, heading to the sporting event, working on a lab, or trying to squeeze in a movie with friends. After class, a meeting, a practice, they’re…

Words 5589 - Pages 23

AP Human Geography: Conflicts Between The North And South Korea

Randall Kirby AP Human Geography Ethnicity Case Study 1) Conflicts Between the North and South Korea A) Korean Peninsula is located at East Asia, between China and Sea of Japan. In Korean Peninsula, there are two sovereignty states: North Korea and South Korea. Both sides have been fighting since 1950’s. North Koreans prefer communist government by influence of both China and Soviets, while South Koreans favor unitary presidential constitutional republic, influenced by U.S.. Since after…

Words 1758 - Pages 8

Rachel Yates Argument Essay On Success And Passion

Yates1 Rachel Yates World Literature (Argument Essay) Mr.Branham April 15, 2015 Is Passion The Key To Success? “Passion has little to do with euphoria and everything to do with patience. It is not about feeling good. It is about endurance. Like patience, passion comes from the same latin root: Pati. It does not mean to flow with exuberance. It means to suffer.” Mark Z. Danielewski once said. This quote proves that success can not be achieved without passion, you have to bust your butt to…

Words 3160 - Pages 13

Essay on Home: High School and San Antonio

Effectively Teaching Disadvantaged Students Andrés Garduño Claremont Graduate University Effectively Teaching Disadvantaged Students Twenty-nine years ago, the department of education released A Nation at Risk; a report that pointed out the academic underachievement of the nation’s youth. Several outlined problems still exist today. Many argue that bullying, budget cuts, violence, and lazy teachers are preventing the nation from getting back “to the good old days.” However, it is important…

Words 3253 - Pages 14

The Negative Effects of Media on Sports in Usa Essay

Federation, introduced his entirely media-based league to the world. The XFL or Extreme Football League used sex and incredible amounts of violence to improve ratings. Unlike the NFL, the XFL had no fair-catches, no extra-point kicks, and virtually no rules whatsoever combined with immense violence and “none-too-shy” cheerleaders. The XFL often had gimmicks such as a cheerleader running a…

Words 4287 - Pages 18