Essay on battered spouse syndrome

Submitted By kjdeol
Words: 1295
Pages: 6
Open Document
The battered spouse syndrome has caused many controversies in the court system. The battered spouse syndrome was introduced in the 1980s and was used to explain a woman’s actions, and was used in defense by lawyers when a woman killed her husband or boyfriend due to the fact of being abused over several years. But now that syndrome also applies to men, gays and lesbians as well. In order to use this defense the evidence has to be admissible. For many trials the battered spouse syndrome was used, but the expert testimony was being viewed as excuse. But with evidence and changes in the law the battered spouse syndrome is a justification. Many women who have been in an abusive relationship use this syndrome as a way to avoid criminal responsibility.
In the court case R. v. Lavallee, the appellant is on trial for the killing of her husband. At the time the appellant was twenty two and was living with Kevin Rust in a common law relationship for three to four years. On August 30, 1983, there was a part being hosted at the residence of Kevin Rust and the appellant. The appellant was talking to a guest and Kevin pushed her making her run into the house and hiding in the closet from him. Kevin entered the appellant’s room and told her to come out, but due to the fact she was scared she did not. Kevin grabbed her right arm and yelled at her and both began to push each other and then Kevin hit her on the right side of the head. The appellant was scared and was shaking and then was given a gun by Kevin, and a shot was fired through her screen. Then again Kevin loaded the second shot and gave it to the appellant. The appellant said that she was going to shoot herself and pointed the gun towards herself. The appellant sat on her bed while Kevin made hand motions for pulling the trigger and told her that she is his old lady and she should do what she is told. Kevin tells her when everybody leaves, she is going to get it and that either she wills him or he will get her, and that was where the appellant shot Kevin.
The relationship between the two was a violent one full of arguments. Both would argue many times throughout the day. There was evidence of the appellant being abused by Kevin Rust. Between 1983 and 1986, the appellant suffered many injuries which included bruising, fractured nose, multiple contusions and a black eye. The appellant would lie about the injuries and the physicians would not believe her explanations. Many witnesses testify that they always heard the argument and did see that the appellant had sustained some type of injuries. The appellant told the police officer that if she did not kill him first that he would kill her, but she hoped that he would live because she loved him.
The expert evidence came from Dr. Fred Shane who is a psychiatrist with expensive professional experience in treatment of battered wives. In Dr. Shane’s opinion the appellant was being abused by Kevin to a point where her life was in danger and she felt trapped. Dr. Shane states in his opinion the appellant shot Kevin because it was the only option of her not being killed. The expert opinion came from the interview from the appellant, the police report, hospital reports and the interview with the appellant’s mother. Much of his testimony was lacking admissible evidence which could not be taken into consideration. In the end of the trial the appellant was acquitted by the jury but the verdict was overturned by a majority of Manitoba Court of Appeal and case sent back for retrial.
The psycholegal assumption made in the court was on how the expert testimony is weighed in the trial and whether a woman who was under stress from an abusive relationship be able to use the battered spouse syndrome. The court took the evidence of Dr. Shane to be not admissible and the judge made it clear to the jury that some evidence should not be taken into consideration when it came to their verdict. In the courts they doubted the facts that Dr, Shane was bring up
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on battered spouse syndrome

PSY344 DomesticAbuse14 2 Essay

Psychology Domestic Violence and Abuse Plan for Today  Domestic Abuse  Battered Women Syndrome  Learned Helplessness  Post Traumatic Stress Disorder  Rape Trauma Syndrome Domestic Abuse (Jones, 1994a)  Leading cause of injury in American women sending more than 1 million for medical treatment every year  Spousal violence contributes to one fourth of all suicide attempts by women  37% of all obstetric patients are battered during pregnancy  50% of homeless women and children are fleeing from…

Words 1066 - Pages 5

Battered women Essay

Coulten Trumbull Ms. Blair English 1101 6 January 2014 Battered women “But even when I stop crying, even when we fall asleep and I'm nestled in his arms, this will leave another scar. No one will see it. No one will know. But it will be there. And eventually all of the scars will have scars, and that's all I'll be--one big scar of a love gone wrong.” ― Amanda Grace Kathleen* cringes at the memory of waking up in a hospital…

Words 1723 - Pages 7

Intimate Partner Injustice

The cops were called by my boss to get him off the clubhouse grounds, when the cops arrived the story was told to them and we were both arrested. He was released within 4 hours and I was held for 26. I had only had a busted lip was later said to be self-inflicted in my “rage” to get out the car ad fight him. We then went back to school and my apartment was broken into and I was put into protective custody. I was told by the school they were doing a hearing to expel this man and I should get a restraining…

Words 1804 - Pages 8

Essay about spousal abuse

About 1 in 4 women (24.3%) and 1 in 7 men (13.8%) have experienced severe physical violence by a spouse and most female and male victims of rape, physical violence, and/or stalking by an intimate partner (69% of female victims; 53% of male victims) experienced some form of intimate partner violence for the first time before 25 years of age. Men and women who experience physical violence by a spouse in their lifetime are more likely to report frequent headaches, chronic pain, difficulty with sleeping…

Words 930 - Pages 4

Domestic Violence

stage", that police and prosecutors had such a hard time getting abusers locked up, the mistreated, more often than not, believed the abusers and eventually decide to give them another chance. The before mentioned cycle is one part of the "battered women syndrome", the other part of Dr. Lenor Walker's theory…

Words 1959 - Pages 8

Moral And Ethical Standards Of Australian Society In Relation To Family Members

for divorce is the irretrievable breakdown of the marriage. Prior to the concept of divorce, married couples had to apply for divorce under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1959 on the ground of “fault”. This meant that in order to divorce, one or both spouses had to prove that they engaged in acts of adultery, cruelty, insanity and desertion. The Family Law Act eventually removed that ground of divorce and established the Family Court. For divorce to legally occur, both parties must live separately and…

Words 1003 - Pages 5

Essay about Domestic Violence

violence as a complex problem rooted in the interactions among various factors at the individual, family and community/societal levels of an individual’s environment (WHO, 2002). Learned helplessness has been applied to domestic violence and battered women cases, due to the frame of mind that women are limited to, as well as to answer questions such as why women will not leave an abusive environment. According to Barnett (1993), sex-roles play a major part in…

Words 4465 - Pages 18

Essay on VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN

VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN Violence against women is a pervasive and widespread plague on our society- one that crosses geographic, economic and racial lines. While men are also victims of a family violence, women overwhelmingly are the targets especially when it comes to sexual assault and psychological abuse. So why should we care about violence against women? Chances are, someone close to you has been, is or will be a victim. This is not something that only happens to “other people” or in “those…

Words 7929 - Pages 32

domestic violence the strength that made me Essay

Shannon McAnallan English 150 Professor Douglas 5 November 2014 Domestic Violence: The Strength That Made Me Domestic violence is a very seriouse problem all over the world but here in the United States it is out of control. Almost every nine seconds in the US a woman is beaten or assaulted. Men can be abused also, and this fact is not as well recognized as the mental image that we all get when someone says domestic violence. Many people do not see themselves as victims of domestic violence, and…

Words 3769 - Pages 16

Child Abuse and Spousal Emotional Abuse Essays

& Enright, 1996; Lin, Enright, Mack, Krahn, & Baskin, 2004; Rye et al., 2005). FT directly targets ongoing resentment, which can lead to Spousal emotional abuse is a significant problem, with approximately 35% of women reporting such abuse from a spouse or romantic partner (O’Leary, 1999); in addition, women often demonstrate negative psychological outcomes long after this abuse. Despite the frequent calls for efficacious therapies for these…

Words 9506 - Pages 39