In this subsequent decortication state she was totally dependent on a mechanical respirator for breathing. Nonetheless, the trial court on November 10, 1975, denied the plaintiff's application, siting that Karen was not legally or medically dead. Thus, Mr. Quinlan was denied the right to authorize termination of "life-assisting apparatus" and granted Karen Quinlan's physicians the right to continue medical treatment over the objections of the Quinlan family. This ruling was then overturned on March 31, 1976. The New Jersey Supreme Court ruled that “Karen's "right of privacy" included a right to refuse medical treatment and that her father, under the circumstances, could assume this right in her stead, (Joseph T. Quinlan v. Guardian Ad Litem Thomas R. Curtin., 1976, slip op. at, p