Carleton had come across the territory which would become Bosque Redondo in 1852, and was able to revisit it in 1854 during his prior excursions to the Southwest. Carleton saw what he believed to be a land that was rich enough for the Navajo to live, citing its proximity to the Pecos River, which he believed would allow the Navajo to properly irrigate land for farming. Furthermore, the land was deemed by him to have strategic value, as it was believed by Carleton that the openness of the Bosque would work against the will of any Navajo who sought to resist, as the terrain would disallow Navajo to “elude pursuit and recapture.” Another notable benefit of Bosque Redondo in Carleton’s mind was that the land allowed for a cheap maintenance of the Navajo, who’s care under the government was of considerable