Broken Window Fallacy Theory

Submitted By Tjsureboy
Words: 978
Pages: 4
Open Document
GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE

In class, we have talked about disasters driving the economy, or money spent to stimulate the economy. However, there are economists that say this really doesn't help and explain it with the "Broken Window Fallacy" theory.
Research what this theory is. And provide your answer to:
1. BRIEFLY summarize the theory
2. If this theory is true, explain why government money spent on rebuilding after a natural or man made disaster seems to create jobs and stimulate the economy inspite of the "Broken Window Fallacy"

“SUMMARY OF THE BROKEN WINDOW FALLACY THEORY”
The “Broken Window Fallacy” theory was first expressed by the great French economics, Frederic Bastiat when he used the story of a broken window to illustrate the why destruction doesn’t benefit the economy.
Frederic Bastiat’s tale cited a story of James B (the shop keeper) whose son threw a stone at a glass window and got the window broken. The community/onlookers gathered around the scenario and said that the boy has done the community a service which his father (the shop keeper) will have to pay for. (Beattie, 2008)
James B, has to contact the Glazier who will fix the window that was broken. In replacement of the broken window, James B has to give some money to the glazier to buy a new window and fix it in replacement of the broken window.
The summary of the theory is the movement of money in circulation from the shop keeper (James B) and the glazier who fixed the broken window in relation to the economy and its benefits.
There are two sides to the theory which are the “seen and the unseen” sides. The seen sides
Analysis of the theory is illustrated below:

S/N
JAMES B (the shop keeper) (Unseen)
Glazier (Seen)
1).
James B has to spend money to replace the broken window. (Loss)
The glazier has to receive money to replace the broken window. (Gain)
2).
James B would have used the same money to purchase other things like: buying shoes for his wife, additional books to his library, investment etc. which also increases jobs, sales and helps the economy as well.
The glazier having received the money used it to purchase food, shoes, transportation, etc.
3).
His wife loses because she will not be able to have the shoe and the shoe producer/seller too will not sell.
The glazier has money to buy shoe for his wife and the producer/seller sells.
4).
Reduction in income/savings of James B’s money.
Additional money for the glazier who earned the money from his service.
4).
Destruction destroys the prosperity of the baker, things and places.
This creates job for the glazier, artisans, the manufacturers of the glass, the transporters, etc.
5).
The destruction leaves some people desolate and deserted as their things/properties have been broken/destroyed. Emotionally and physically traumatized. It also damages/destroys wealth.

2. If this theory is true, explain why government money spent on rebuilding after a natural or man-made disaster seems to create jobs and stimulate the economy inspite of the "Broken Window Fallacy"
The economist believes that money can circulate from people in an economy without destruction. This is the belief and opinion of the economist that people doesn’t have to use their moneys to repair destroyed properties or things
Why government spend money on rebuilding after a natural man-made disaster:

There are two ways to these theory.

Government: The angle when the government pays more money to rebuild the damaged/destroyed property and earn more taxes when this has been done. This creates higher taxes and inflations
Taxes, subsidies, tariffs,
People: This creates jobs for some people through finance and public works programs like construction, buildings, who later pay taxes. These citizens would have paid less taxes and use their money on other things.
This has a lot of consequences which are not seen when natural or man-made disaster happens. The truth is that we don’t have to damage/destroy properties for people like
Show More

Related Documents: Broken Window Fallacy Theory

Paglia's First Logical Fallacy Analysis

first logical fallacy that appears in her writing is appeal to authority. In paragraph one of her editorial, Paglia begins discussion by recalling her experiences in college when she was still young. She establishes how restricting social expectations were on women, explaining how “throughout history, women have been chaperoned [...] we had to be in the dorm under lock and key by 11 o’clock” (Par. 1). She continues, writing that despite opposition, her “generation was the one that broke these rules”…

Words 511 - Pages 3

Political Correctness Definition

Political Correctness Political correctness was a term originally used by conservatives to describe, “the attitude or policy of being careful not to offend or upset any group of people in society who are believed to have a disadvantage,” (Oxford Dictionary). Popular usage began in the 1990s by conservative politicians, it was used to express their concerns about the liberals the academic culture. In 1991 an article used political correctness to describe academic policies that promoted multiculturalism…

Words 561 - Pages 3

Ethos Pathos Logo Analysis

In the live lesson, we learned about the three persuasive appeals: ethos, logos, and pathos. Ethos uses ethics, knowledge, and credibility to appeal to the listener. For example, a dentist recommending a certain brand of toothpaste to keep teeth white, people would be swayed to buy this brand because of the professional’s area of expertise. Logos uses facts and logic to appeal to the listener. For instance, nine in ten doctors recommend eating fruits and vegetables every day to reduce the risk of…

Words 315 - Pages 2

Govt Essay Note

relieve anxiety * Freud’s five psychosexual stages * Oral * Anal * Phallic * Latency * Gentital * Freud VS. neo-Freudians’ approaches to personality * Three influential followers of Freud who later broke from him were: * Alfred Adler- * emphasized the inferiority complex and the compensating will-to-power * Carl Jung * Introduced the collective unconscious and archetypes * Karen Horney…

Words 782 - Pages 4

Camille Paglia On Date Rape Summary

argues that dating is risk taking and women that are victims of rape or sexual assault are fully responsible for what has happened to them. She simply starts out her essay by talking about her generation in 1960s and claims that they were the ones that broke the strict dating rules. She has gratification in the fight against double standards with other young ladies because she wanted the freedom and equality that women have fought for. The author also mentions that compared to modern generation, while…

Words 834 - Pages 4

Essay on Response to Hunter S. Thompsons Ferar and Loathing in Las Vegas

a hit. But their loss and failure is ours too. What Leary took down with him was the central illusion of a whole life-style that he helped create... a generation of permanent cripples, failed seekers, who never understood the essential old-mystic fallacy of the Acid Culture: the desperate assumption that somebody... or at least some force - is tending the light at the end of the tunnel.” (F&L pg 178) Thompson’s criticism of society does not exclude the counterculture generation. In fact, his…

Words 1171 - Pages 5

Belonging Essay

his father ‘kept pace only with the Joneses of his own mind’s making,’ to illustrate his father’s strong and unbreakable identity. From this, through his vivid imagery coupled with the simile to describe Feliks’ ‘fingers with cracks like the sods he broke,’ he interrogatively questions how he ‘often wondered how he existed on five or six hours sleep each night.’ But Skrzynecki attempts to explain through his hyperbole coupled with a simile about how his father ‘loved his garden like an only child, spend…

Words 1212 - Pages 5

English Essay

because nobody else is allowed to draw back the curtain that hangs over the portrait. Only the Duke is allowed to look at it or show it to anyone else. This is clearly his private gallery, and we’re a little afraid of what might happen to someone who broke the rules there. Curtains – hiding, blocking something out. He is in control of her. Knowledge and realization. He has control of the truth. He can control people’s perception of her. Reinforces how much control he believes that he is entitled to…

Words 962 - Pages 4

The great gatsby Essay examples

appear to uphold the expectations of “the Jazz age” as you would think. This raises the question of why Tom Buchanan, an ostentatiously wealthy and attractive man, would have a mistress that lived in such a pauperized place. Fitzgerald uses pathetic fallacy at the beginning of chapter 2 in order to reflect Nick’s feelings towards meeting Tom’s mistress and his disinterest towards spending time with Tom, but when Nick is describing his surroundings with words such as; “paintless days” and “dismal scene”…

Words 1068 - Pages 5

The History Of Psychology

Interacting factors Individual differences Cultural influences Social influences Psychology has a rich past… Psychology’s philosophical roots: What is thought? Are the mind, body, and soul separate? 1875 – Psychology is born Late 1800s, psychology broke away from philosophy & began to use the tools of science to explore the mind. In 1875, William James created a small psychology laboratory at Harvard University. In 1879, Wilhelm Wundt conducted the first psychology experiment in Leipzig, Germany…

Words 1154 - Pages 5