Essay on Canada and United States and the Kyoto Protocol

Submitted By iskk051
Words: 2319
Pages: 10
Open Document
Steven Hill
Public Policy
Thom Yantek
4/8/2013
Canada Vs United States
In 2001, President George W. Bush confirmed that the United States would not ratify the Kyoto Protocol. However, much to the surprise of everyone in the international community and some factions of the Canadian government, Canada ratified the Kyoto protocol in 2002. It is important to note the political differences that led up to Canada signing the Kyoto Protocol and the United States withdrawing from the Treaty. I hope to show why two similar countries had different outcomes. Firstly, Canada negotiated similar target commitments to the United States. During the summit, the prime minister of Canada told his negotiator to stay one percent below the Americans. It was a big political win for him because he wanted to beat the United States in target goals. (“Canada committing to a 6% reduction and the US to 7% below their 1990 baselines by the 2008 to 2012 compliance period. Arguably more significant, the anticipated reductions below the business-as-usual trajectory were very demanding in both cases, at 29% and 31% below projected “business as usual” emissions in 2010 for Canada and the US, respectively.”.) The United States and Canada were also closely intertwined economies and trading partners via the North American Free Trade Agreement. Both countries would expect the other to sign the Agreement so they would remain competitive with each other and less attractive to foreign investment, again, given the imbalance in the trading relationship in which the US market and US investments are much more significant to the Canadian economy then. This made the Canadian ratification even more surprising because they chose to ratify even after it was clear the United States would not. I assumed that public opinion would be a driving reason for Canada to ratify over the United States, however, (“Policy-makers motivated by re-election will be concerned first and foremost with voters’ preferences. In that regard, the level of concern about climate change appears to have been somewhat higher in Canada than the US. An international survey conducted in 1992 found that 47% of Americans compared to 58% of Canadians considered global warming to be “very serious.” However, the combination of those who considered the issue either “very serious” or “somewhat serious” was high in both countries: 78% in the US and 85% in Canada. Similarly, a 2003 survey found that 31% of Americans compared to 40% of Canadians considered global warming to be “very serious,” while the combination considering the problem to be “serious” or “somewhat serious” was 71% in the US and 81% in Canada.5 Public opinion in the US also seems to have been somewhat less supportive of ratification than in Canada. Lisowski reports that 61% of Americans polled in early 2001 supported ratication.6 In contrast, in the lead-up to ratification in Canada, 73 to 79% of Canadians supported ratification.“)These statistics sort of destroy the argument that the reason the Kyoto Protocol was not ratified was because of public opinion while Canada did have higher percent of support. Instead, it shows that in both countries there was majority support to ratify the Kyoto protocol. High amounts of public support do not equal high amounts of attention. In the United States, 47% of Americans thought the global warming threat was very serious, yet according to Gallup Poll only a maximum of 5% of Americans ever called global warming the country’s most important problem. The same was true in Canada, where only 6% of Canadians called the environment Canada’s biggest problem. (“Consistent with this, three years after the US withdrew from the Kyoto Protocol, 42% of Americans still believed President Bush supported the treaty and fewer than half of Americans (48%) were aware of the President’s opposition to the Protocol. Similarly, despite a high profile debate over Canada’s ratification in the fall of 2002, only half of
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Canada and United States and the Kyoto Protocol

Commuter Challenge Research Paper

to get some fresh air”, a phrase people often hear on their everyday lives. The question is, is there any remaining fresh air left? Admittedly for many years, scientists all over the world have proven that the air has already becoming on its poor state- the so called “Air pollution.” Air Pollution is one of the major environmental concerns nowadays. With the modernization and progress of industries, people have noticed the terms smog, greenhouse gases-Carbon dioxide, methane, CFCs, global warming…

Words 728 - Pages 3

Essay from columbus to castro

the students a chance to explore in detail some issues related to global warming using Google Earth such as CO2 (carbon dioxide) emissions. Using CO2 emissions data obtained from many virtual data bases ( Google Earth) and websites such as the United States Energy Information Administration (EIA), National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), etc… (see references and reading materials), students will also learn to construct a linear, and quadratic regression model using SPSS and to use a…

Words 1541 - Pages 7

357 Essay Final Draft

reductions, absolute limits have been adopted at the international level in the Kyoto Protocol, where in the US the president adopted an intensity target instead. The Kyoto Protocol is basically an international treaty that sets binding obligations on industrialized countries to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases. This would be known as an absolute-based policy as opposed to an intensity-based approach. As part of the Kyoto Protocol, many developed countries have agreed to legally binding limitations/reductions…

Words 3808 - Pages 16

Polar Bears Research Paper

Summary Polar bears are an important arctic species that is in danger from climate change. A keystone species, polar bears are essential for a balanced ecosystem in the Arctic Circle. As the overall temperature of the earth is increases due to global warming and the greenhouse effect, the sea ice that polar bears live on for most of their lives is disappearing. Polar bears require sea ice to survive, as it is their hunting grounds and habitat. When the ice melts, polar bears are forced to move closer…

Words 2565 - Pages 11

Climate Change In Canada

layer (Environment Canada, 2010). As a result, the land and ocean surface temperature is constantly increasing in a linear trend from 1880 to 2012 (Stocker, et al., 2013). The Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change (IPCC) states that the temperature had increased 0.78 degrees Celsius globally from 2003 to 2012 (Stocker, et al., 2013). The increase in temperature is now causing serious consequences like the melting and disappearance of Greenland’s…

Words 1726 - Pages 7

Essay about Op Ed Poli 201 Morgan Bellamy

Arctic ice, in 2005 he revealed the project, then again in 20082, and just now are we actually seeing any real work being done. With the project’s estimated arrival time of 20222, Harper’s claims on the Arctic are seemingly slipping away, as the United States, Russia, and Denmark are also trying to stake a claim.2 What horrors might this hold for future Canadians and the sovereignty over the Arctic? For one, there is the possibility that the Canadian Conservative party may increase taxation in order…

Words 654 - Pages 3

Essay about International Trade and Alternative Energy Sources

Spectrum (Left wing) Middle (Right Wing) ___________________________NDP Canada__Liberal___USA___________________ Collectivism (gov’t intervene) -Mixed Economy (Canada) Conservative Communism -Social programs Laissez faire (no gov’t) Equality -Free Health care…

Words 1437 - Pages 6

Essay Emissions Trading and Climate Change

The Business and Politics of Environmental Regulation and Activism 3028IBA – Energy and Environmental Security Dr Tapan Sarker Department of International Business and Asian Studies 3028IBA - 2013 Topics Covered in this Lecture • The business/corporate sector and the environment (essentially business and the climate change issue); and • Emissions trading schemes (the key strategy, considered the most cost-effective strategy, by which economic activity is to be guided towards meeting…

Words 3587 - Pages 15

Action To Reduce Canada's CO2 Emissions: An Environmental Health Issue

producers have no need to factor the cost of GHG emissions into their decision making.” (Hodgson, Glen, Gilles Rheaume, and Len Coad 2008) According to Environment Canada at 94%, Carbon Dioxide represents the majority of the total reported greenhouse gas emissions. (Environment Canada 2014) In order to tackle the climate change issue, Canada should therefore be focused on reducing their carbon output first and foremost. 2. Issue Context The ever-increasing issue of global warming is a direct result…

Words 3306 - Pages 14

Global Warming Research Paper

Global Warming: Its effects on the Economy by Vincent Colletti Professor Shakely English Composition II July 1, 2008 Outline THESIS: From the findings of experts on Global Warming and Climatology, it can be concluded that Global Warming has a direct effect on our current global economy and the instability of the future. Introduction I. Background A. The study of Environmental Economics B. Economic issues and relations to past and future global warming estimates II. The…

Words 3775 - Pages 16