Case: Motivation and Bonuses Essay

Submitted By jianglu0413

Words: 429

Pages: 2

Open Document

Lu Jiang
Prof. Williamson
Section KY
Case #3 Bonus Backfire
10/1/2014
Do you think that, as a manager, you would use bonuses regularly? Why or why not?
From my point of view, it is beneficial for managers and leaders to use bonuses regularly. According to EXPECTANCY THEORY, an individual’s motivation is a multiplicative function of expectancy, instrumentality, and valence. Thus motivation will be high when instrumentality is high and valence is strongly positive. To avoid problem mentioned in case, managers may reward employees through 360°EVALUATION. It measures customer ratings, self ratings and evaluations from boss and peers. Workers who given rewards for behaviors are more likely to engaged in rewarded behaviors.
Can you think of a time in your own life when being evaluated and rewarded on a specific goal lead you to engage in negative or unproductive behavior?
I learned playing piano when I was in primary school. In order to encourage me to practice more time, my mother made promise to buy me a gift if I finish practicing two hours every per day during a month. However, although I succeed in doing the goal, later on I somehow lacked my interest in playing piano. Therefore I thought rewards can cause negative effects, since people would feel themselves being compelled to do things simply to get the rewards they want.
3. Do you think providing group bonuses instead of individual bonuses would be more effective or less effective? Why or why not? I think group bonuses have both positive and negative influences, but it can hardly be more effective than individual bonuses. Take PROFIT-SHARING PLANS for example, managers will reward employees based on their overall organizational profit. The criticism think organizational profits

The Scanlon Bonus Plan

The case facts (brief summary; 2-4 sentences of what’s happening and who’s involved): In 1998, Ron Bent was hired to manage Engstrom Auto Mirror after the plant experienced a significant downturn. Production was delayed and the plant was unprofitable. Bent introduced the Scanlon Bonus Plan in 1999, a performance based incentive, which was voted in by 81% of the workers. However, in 2005, the plant experienced another downturn – productivity, employee morale, and product-quality declined – and the…

Words 913 - Pages 4

Credit Life Insurance Essay

INSURANCE CASE WAC Problem Analysis MOTIVATION OF SOME LEADING TO DEMOTIVATION OF SOME FOLLOWED BY DISCRIMINATION Through analyzing the California Credit Life Insurance Group it could be seen that the company is facing some serious issues regarding the gender biases within the company. Though the management believes in equal employment opportunity EEO, the executives have faced some issues related to sexual discrimination which is turning into bad reputation for the company. A case was filed…

Words 1790 - Pages 8

Essay on Engston Auto Mirrors Plant

2008 BUSA 305 Case Analysis Engstrom Auto Mirror Plant: Motivating in Good Times and Bad Engstrom Auto Mirror Plant is facing the problem of not being able to keep their employees motivated in both good and bad times. Before the problem occurred, Ron Bent, the plant manager, had adopted the Scanlon Plan. The Scanlon Plan was an incentive plan used to motivate employees and to drive changes in their behavior and attitudes. The plan consisted of monthly bonuses for employee productivity…

Words 1639 - Pages 7

Essay about Rewarding Employees

reward their employees. Some award themes consist of bonuses, paid days off, awards and certificates. In many cases rewarding employees seems easy, however they’re few challenges that occur. Many companies set performance measures to track progress such as bonuses. This is considered a way to create worth for the company and its investors. There are three types of bonuses that are generally given longevity, non-performance and performance bonuses. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics…

Words 553 - Pages 3

Essay Ikea Way

1990s and early 2000s, the company implemented several initiatives that promoted 'life balance' and diversity. The case discusses the innovative human resource management practices adopted by IKEA and describes its work culture. Initiatives related to flexible work design, comprehensive benefits, quality of work life, and employee training and development are outlined. The case also discusses the prominent elements of IKEA's culture, such as diversity, openness, equality, cost consciousness…

Words 3203 - Pages 13

Essay on LET1 Expectancy Theory

Expectancy Theory LET1: Leadership Concepts and Application In the business community employee motivation has long been a major concern for managers. There have been many theories that endeavor to explain motivation, and the underlying stimuli that affect it. One of the more widely accepted of these theories is the expectancy theory. Victor Vroom originated the expectancy theory of motivation in 1964 (Sandler, 2008). His theory is comprised of three main principles: valence, instrumentality, and…

Words 932 - Pages 4

The Process Of Thinking Involves Multiple Clusters Of Thoughts Essay

These ideas are triggered by the individual intrusive and extrusive motivations. The understanding and interpreting of the patient’s sense of the word can be a vital treatment to build on the client’s strength. The social worker can use words and ideas appealing to the person he is helping. This is called emotional intelligence. Emotional intelligence is affected by the individual intrusive and extrusive motivation. Intrusive motivation can be defined as a feeling of joy, a sense of achievement or accomplishment…

Words 891 - Pages 4

Essay about Johannes Linden HBS Case Study

problems to focus on business development in the fiscal year 2011. The report concentrates on three issues affecting the Global Executive Committee of Fluss Washer and Dryer; the organisational structure hindering growth, leadership efficiency and motivation of employees. The analysis covers centralisation vs decentralisation of the organisational structure…

Words 3262 - Pages 14

Fair And Equitable Compensation

carefully weighed against the overall organizational goals and expectations. Compensation must reward employees for past performance while serving as a motivation tool for future performances. There are many different ways to motivate employees. Employers can motivate their workers as individuals, groups, teams, or the organization as a whole. Motivation takes forms like offering rewards, improving working conditions, or employee recognition. When people get motivated, they will have a reason to put…

Words 1146 - Pages 5

Maslow ' s Hierarchy of Needs and Motivational Techniques Essay

Evaluation question on motivation AS Business Studies I run a small business, why are my staff demotivated? Starter  - Maybe they are on short-term contracts - Maybe you only pay them the minimum wage - Maybe there are few opportunities for promotion as you are only a small business - Maybe they are low skilled and you are trying to increase their level of responsibility and it is proving too much for them Answer Motivational techniques have been the main method used by The Authentic Food…

Words 520 - Pages 3