Case Study Brophy Case

Words: 685

Pages: 3

Open Document

The Brophy Case The right to die has been a highly controversial topic for numerous years. While progress has been made, it still has a long way to go before a definitive answer will ever be made. The many factors involved in the right to die create roadblocks that make finalizing a decision in state or federal court nearly insurmountable. To help shed some light on this contentious topic I will illustrate and provide background into the Brophy Case, with special emphasis on how the principles of beneficence and justice are pertinent in the case, how the right to die could be approached from a religious perspective and justification on what I would do if faced with this same decision. What originated as an excruciating headache landed …show more content…
The principle of beneficence is a directive for the physician to “first avoid harm, then prevent it, then eliminate it. After these come the positive duties to maximize possible benefits and minimize possible harms” (Barry, 2012, p. 81). If we contemplate the case from this perspective, we must decide which option will bring the least amount of harm upon the patient. Clearly, the physicians believe that the cessation of food and water is inhumane and as such will harm the patient. On the other hand, those close to Mr. Brophy have confirmed that he distinctly stated that he did not want to be kept alive in a vegetative state so it can be noted that to continue to do so is in direct violation of the patient’s wishes causing him inadvertent harm. The principle of justice is defined as the equal and fair distribution of welfare and obligations within a society (Barry, 2012). Barry (1985) explains that money that is expended on care that is essentially futile ends up depleting funds that could be better spent elsewhere. In a sense, keeping this patient alive will deny another patient the funds for a lifesaving treatment he desperately needs, which in turn, harms the patient, violating both

Reduce Medical Errors In Health Care

to reduce the cases of medication errors in the health care facilities. Problem Statement Medical errors are mistakes made by medical professionals in handling their clients. These mistakes range…

Words 641 - Pages 3

Motivation In English Learning

research. Motivation in English learning, as the key point of this study, is overviewed based on theories from some experts in the first section. Description and explanation of after-school programs and activities, including academic achievement towards motivation of students for learning English, is also reviewed. The reviews from previous studies about students’ motivation in English learning, as the main aspect of this research study, are provided in the last section. 2. 1 The Overview of Motivation…

Words 1245 - Pages 5

Essay on “Alternative Lifestyle, and Why Many Believe the “Choice” Is Genetic.”

RUNNING HEADER: Alternative Lifestyle, And Why Many Believe the Choice” Is Genetic A heated debate over the existence of a "gay gene" evolved from a 1993 report published in the journal Science by then-NIH researcher Dean Hammer, PhD. That study linked DNA markers on the X chromosome to male sexual orientation. While female sexuality seems to be more “normal,” research suggests that male homosexuality is an inborn, unalterable, and strongly genetically influenced trait. However considering…

Words 1203 - Pages 5

Cause or Effect Essay

solution found to help these kids change their diets and improve their lives. Obesity has been considered more of an environmental problem than a genetic one. It is more of what they witness as they are growing up that will affect them the most. Studies done by The American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry notes in “Obesity in children and Teens” (January 2001, http://www.aacap.org/cs/root/facts_for_families/obesity_in_children_and_teens), show that, “If one parent is obese, then there…

Words 1053 - Pages 5

African American Reparations Negative2 Essay

African American Reparations Negative We negate the resolution, Resolved: The United States Federal Government ought to pay reparations to African Americans Framework: First, This debate revolves around the idea of race relations. At that point, the team that is best able to evaluate the root cause of racism should win the round. If we prove that reparations don’t solve for the underlying issues of racism, a negative ballot is in line. Second, the topic uses the phrase “pay reparations to African…

Words 1793 - Pages 8

Self Harm Research Paper

irrespective of the apparent purpose of the act’ (2004:16). The incidence of self-harm in young people appears to be increasing and there is a strong link between self-harm and increased risk of completed suicide (Cleaver, 2007). McDougall and Brophy (2006) produced a summary of the Mental Health Foundation publication, Truth Hurts, examining the implications for nurses and mental health professionals. They report that the incidence of self harm has risen by 30% since the 1980’s and that children…

Words 4130 - Pages 17

Essay Health Care and Care

Congestive Heart Failure Stephanie Gray, Jessica Keith, Karen Rowland, Jorge Sanchez, Tracy Sansossio, Dana Taylor and Lori Wells Distance Learning-Online Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements in the course Nursing 464: Developing Case Management Skills in the School of Nursing Old Dominion University NORFOLK, VIRGINIA Summer, 2007 An Interdisciplinary Approach to Congestive Heart Failure Congestive heart failure is “an extremely common illness, accounting for increasing hospital…

Words 4437 - Pages 18

BO Good Teaching Learning Copy Essay

down to the ‘new’ Head of Department. Marzano (2003) identifies three levels of factors that make a school – (a) school, (b) teacher, and (c) pupil. In this study I will like to focus on the teacher level factors that make a good school. I will briefly describe two cases from my observations to elucidate the key features of a good school. Case 1 Mr P introduces the topic and the students are expected to complete the set task. Talking begins and the class soon gets very unruly, with no work taking…

Words 2987 - Pages 12