Case Study Of Surrogacy

Words: 750
Pages: 3
Open Document
2. Surrogacy: Legal Approach

Surrogacy was legalized in the year 2002 in India. As the Assisted Reproductive Technologies [ART] is emerging as a flourishing industry in India and has become a preferred destination for ‘persons’, foreign as well as domestic, opting for ART treatment as well as “the destination”1 on the lookout for surrogates. Some of the factors contributing to this have been identified as low costs for high end medical facilities.
It is a sensitive issue to deal with due to the complexity involved. Various guidelines aspire to fill the void that exists in the legal regulation of surrogacy in India. The various provisions merely aim at regulating the thriving ART industry by checking it and putting it under the guidance of …show more content…
The report has regarded that the laws related to surrogacy are multifaceted and has suggested a pragmatic approach while legislating on this issue. The report considered Indian and foreign decisions on surrogacy (also constitution right to procreate) including the Baby M case and the Baby Manji’s Case for reviewing the position on the constitutional validity of surrogacy in India. Though the report has highlighted various issues on surrogacy, the report has not moved into the more pressing and deeper aspects of surrogacy vis-à-vis the Indian situation. The report has failed consider the prevalent socio-economic situation and the cultural stigma attached to surrogacy in India. The report has been unsuccessful in identifying the scope of surrogacy in India, and has not made recommendations for regulation of the practice of …show more content…
The proposed legislation on surrogacy essentially needs to address not only the domestic but also the international requisites of surrogacy. India has its status in the field of surrogacy, as that of a booming industry, at the international level. This status makes it necessary to address this need of its new found importance as a surrogate hub. A legislation on surrogacy not catering to the needs of the international arena is fails to serve a huge purpose and is merely incomplete. The problems arising through surrogacy are indeed complex, and hence, a legislation competent to handle every issue is
Show More

Related Documents: Case Study Of Surrogacy

Baby M Case Study Harvard CTB Essay

position on the case of Baby M Kako Kyoda Baby M Case, was a custody case that occurred in the New Jersey Supreme Court involving the custody battle between a child's birth mother and the father who contributed his sperm for fertilization. Even though the father with his wife signed on a surrogacy agreement, however, I think the morality must be taken into consideration, because the Baby M case posed complex moral issue. The Baby M case is very…

Words 975 - Pages 4

Assisted Reproduction Research Paper

infertile couples to have a child. Some of the techniques can help parents to select children who do not suffer from some (genetic) disease. The three most well known techniques are artificial insemination (AI)2,3,4, in vitro fertilization (IVF) and surrogacy. Artificial Insemination is a relatively simple procedure. The overall success rate of artificial insemination is about 85%. There are several types of artificial insemination: Homologous (uses the sperm obtained from the mail partner), Heterologous…

Words 1065 - Pages 5

Judges Report Essay

ROY McKENZIE CENTRE Families in Transition Seminar 17 August 2009 A new Adoption Act for the new Millennium Acting Principal Family Court Judge Paul von Dadelszen1 1. Introduction Making an adoption order can be a very happy occasion for a judge. For once we are not solely focussed on dealing with the consequences of the breakdown of a relationship. In fact, we are making a family. At the same time, we recognise that adoption is one of the most significant decisions we can make. that…

Words 6036 - Pages 25

Shelby Inquiry and Research Essay

and adoption often frame their criticisms in terms of what's best for the child without presenting any resounding evidence supporting this claim. Below I hope to dispel the many myths surrounding gay and lesbian parenting and also showcase numerous cases where same sex parents raise successful and well-rounded children. “For the most part, we’re just like any other couple; we have the same ups and downs, we have the same hope to build a future and family together,” says Gary Stein sitting along…

Words 2610 - Pages 11

Parenting And Caring Notes Essay

Injection (ICSI) A variation of IVF, in which the egg is directly injected with a single sperm through a microscopic needle. Social parents Social parents are people who may or may not contribute to a child’s genetic information and in majority of cases are not involved in the conception of the child. Legal and social issues, as well as technological change can have varying influences or impacts on social parenting. This includes factors such as legislation, reproductive technology/technological change…

Words 7549 - Pages 31

Essay on Human Rights and Key Words

Differences in Breast and Cervical Cancer Screening by Disability Status, 19 WOMEN’S HEALTH ISSUES 406 (2009). Key words: Accessible Information on Sexual and Reproductive Health; Women with Disabilities Movement; Statistics and Data Collection; This study looked at data from the 2008 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System Survey to assess state-level disparities in breast and cervical cancer screening among women with and without disabilities. In thirty-one states, significantly fewer women with…

Words 4493 - Pages 18

Essay on To what extent has law reform been effective in dealing with contemporary issues concerning family members

same-sex and de facto relationships. Indeed to an extent law reform has been effective in dealing with contemporary issues concerning family members, these contemporary issues include same-sex marriage, changing nature of parental responsibility, surrogacy and birth technologies and care and protection of children. The recognition of same-sex relationships in Australia has evolved and has recently been given recognition under the law whereas in the 1980’s same-sex relationships were seen as a criminal…

Words 1286 - Pages 6

Family Is Family Research Paper

environment and standard of living in an orphanage. The book goes on to mention, “One in three lesbian couples and one in six gay men couples in the United States are raising FAMILY IS FAMILY 4 children- either from previous marriage, surrogacy, or adoption and 41% of childless lesbians and 52% of gay men express they want to raise a child.” (Gates et al. 2007. P.54). These statistics are expected to increase over time, as they have been in the past 30 years. This ever-growing statistic…

Words 1942 - Pages 8

EWS 425 Final Essay

Instead they are exploited by the development of the stem cell research industry. As a result, this is causing a shift in the global capitalist bioeconomy transactional exchange of women’s biological material for regenerative potential. Even in the case of a transactional exchange where women are compensated for their donation of stem cells, it would only amounts to a fraction of the final price of the procedure and profit doctors as well as the research companies earn. There are different means of…

Words 3145 - Pages 13

Should Same-Sex Marriage Should Be Legal

With many cases being brought to The Supreme Court as of late, same sex marriage has been a major topic of discussion. Ayn Rand once said, "The political function of rights is precisely to protect minorities from oppression by majorities." That is to say that voting on a person’s rights should not be allowed. Yet, same sex marriages are still considered illegal in 40 states due to majority vote. Should same-sex marriages be legal? There are those who could argue either side judiciously, but who is…

Words 1660 - Pages 7