Causes And Consequences Of Violent Video Games On Presence And Aggression

Submitted By pearl_fire
Words: 7014
Pages: 29
Open Document
Kristine L. Nowak*
Department of Communication
University of Connecticut
850 Bolton Road, Unit 1085
Storrs, CT 06269-1085

The Causes and Consequences of
Presence: Considering the
Influence of Violent Video Games on Presence and Aggression

Marina Krcmar
Wake Forest University
Winston-Salem, NC 27106
Kirstie M. Farrar
University of Connecticut
Storrs, CT 06269

Abstract
The level of presence is likely to influence the effect of media violence. This project examines the causes and consequences of presence in the context of violent video game play. In a between subjects design, 227 participants were randomly assigned to play either a violent or a nonviolent video game. The results are consistent with what would be predicted by social learning theory and are consistent with previous presence research. Causal modeling analyses reveal two separate paths to presence: from individual differences and condition. The first path reveals that individual differences (previous game use and gender) predict presence. Those who frequently play video games reported higher levels of presence than those who play video games less frequently. Males play more games but felt less presence than women. The second path is related to perceived violence: those who perceived the game to be more violent felt more presence than those who perceived less violence in the game. Both of these paths were influenced by frustration with the game, which reduced presence. Those who felt more presence felt more hostility and were more verbally aggressive than those who felt lower levels of presence. Higher levels of presence led to increased physically aggressive intentions. Theoretical and practical implications are discussed.

1

Introduction

Understanding the factors that influence the sense of presence and its potential influence on aggression may provide insight into the process of media effects generally. The sense of presence is generally defined in terms of the sense of involvement with and engagement in media. Research has shown that presence influences how people respond to, and are affected by, mediated stimuli (Kim & Biocca, 1997; Lombard & Ditton, 1997; Steuer, 1992).
Therefore, understanding the causes and consequences of presence may help predict how and why people will respond to mediated stimuli, whether violent or not.
Both the exposure to mediated stimuli and the resulting levels of presence can influence viewers’ attitudes and behaviors. Both the level of presence with

Presence, Vol. 17, No. 3, June 2008, 256 –268
©

2008 by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology

*Correspondence to kristine.nowak@uconn.edu.

256 PRESENCE: VOLUME 17, NUMBER 3

Nowak et al. 257

the media (Lombard, 1995; Reeves, Detenber, &
Steuer, 1993; Tamborini et al., 2004) and aggressive responses to mediated stimuli (Bushman, 1995, 1996) are influenced by individual differences (e.g., gender, media use), features of the medium (e.g., screen size, interactivity, vividness, agency), and context. These same factors influence media usage and perceptions of appropriate behavior through the social learning process.
While individual responses to media depictions may vary, there is little doubt that violent media influences everyone to some extent. After four decades of research, scholars have concluded that exposure to media depictions of violence can cause aggressive behavior including the imitation of violent acts (Donnerstein, 1994;
Krahe & Moller, 2004; Paik & Comstock, 1994; Wilson et al., 1997). There is also evidence of desensitization in that those who see more violence have a greater acceptance of, and tolerance for, violent behavior
(Funk, Baldacci, Pasold, & Baumgardner, 2004;
Thomas, Horton, Lippencott, & Drabman, 1977). As
Anderson (2004) argued, the “scientific debate over whether media violence has an effect is over” (p. 114).
Research using experimental, longitudinal, and cross sectional methods
Show More

Related Documents: Causes And Consequences Of Violent Video Games On Presence And Aggression

Troy: Mobile Phone and Play Video Games Essay

Ridgemont High," while the top movies of 2012 are “Twilight: Breaking Dawn” and "Harry Potter: Deathly Hallows Part Two." I found it interesting that there are similarities between both teenagers. For instance, teens play video games. In the 1980s it was Caleco Vision and today it is Play Station Three and Xbox. A similarity is shared in the fact that teens still work. The only difference now is pay. Teens in 1982 were paid $60.30 a week and teens today are paid $130 a week, assuming each teen worked…

Words 646 - Pages 3

Thesis: Video Game and Child Essay

The Impact of Video Games Video games have been around for the last three decades. From its early years of Galaga and Mrs. Pacman at the arcade to Super Mario for Nintendo and Sonic the Hedgehog for the Dreamcast. Those historic games have been games have paved the way for the newer and more advanced video games that now surface the earth. Video games are no longer just in the arcades, but they have transitioned to being at-home game consoles and potable hand-held devices. These games provide a world…

Words 1893 - Pages 8

Violent Video Games Cause Aggression

Keyona Washington Mrs. Treglown Comp Two June 23, 2014 Violent Video Games Cause Aggression There are many people around the world that allow their children to play violent video games and play games that has violent things on them. I feel that young children should not be allowed to play video games that have violent things in them. Violent games can make young kids look at things in the world differently. There are thousands of games now days that show things that could drive a child to possibly…

Words 1795 - Pages 8

Video Games Essay

Video games and Children Recent years video game's popularity has risen to where everyone in the world is playing. It does many other things to human beside the fact playing video games gives you enjoy. Children should be allow to play video games more often. I understand that there are some cons with playing video games but also there are good sides. Generation has changed over years, many from kids, adults, parents, everyone is playing video games in the world now days. One…

Words 406 - Pages 2

9 Ways Video Games Can Actually Be Good For You Analysis

Are Video Games Good for the Brain? Today in the United States, video game, are played around the world. “There are children that play from 2-17. According the Benefits of Playing Video Games by Granic it says 91% of the kids in that age group play video games. In this article The Benefits of Playing Video Games by Granic it says 99% of the boys playing video games and 94% of the girls play video games. Parents always thought video games for bad for kids, but are they? Video games can be a…

Words 1409 - Pages 6

Essay about Video Games Can Bring Teenagers More Than Entertainment

Video Games Can Bring Teenagers More Than Entertainment As one of the products of technology development, video games are deeply enjoyed by people, especially teenagers. However, comparing with teenagers’ passion of video games, many of their parents are holding negative attitudes toward video games. As Kutner, Olson, Warner, and Hertzog (2008) said, the U.S. parents worry that their children may not be able to balance the time spent on playing video games and doing other valuable activities such…

Words 3932 - Pages 16

Games “Я” Us. Augment Essay

Games “Я” Us. Many kids who played their first video games in 70’s and 80’s have now become parents. The generation that grew up with Nintendo and SEGA video gaming consoles now very likely has Sony Playstation or Xbox in the house. Video games became a big part of our lives; it is impossible not to notice the growing size of video gaming isles in every toy store. Impressive graphics and improved game controls make it hard to stop playing and kids spend too much time submerged into the gaming world…

Words 1699 - Pages 7

Video Game Violence Research Paper

for a video game to have so much of an effect on someone that they feel the need to go out into the real world and hurt other people? Video games are a grey area that most people stay away from talking about because some are fun while others are ruthless and violent. It is hard for one to determine if video games are truly just a fun thing to do on a rainy day or if they can transform someone into a violent person in the real world. There are many factors that go into this; with some being play time…

Words 1805 - Pages 8

Professional Video Gaming Essay

Professional Video Gaming Nowadays, many people play video games, so the video game market is growing. In the article, “Video Gamers,” Seth Schiesel explains almost 50 million people enjoy playing video games in South Korea. The huge amount of people is gathering video gaming rooms, which are called PC bangs, everyday. Many young children want to be professional video gamer. Many video games are released everyday, and people are playing it. Some people believe that playing video games is a sport,…

Words 565 - Pages 3

Violent Video Games Essay examples

Violent Video Games: Effect on Child Development Every year the world of video games grows in influence and importance for the lives of American families. Amazing new games continuously outdo the previous games. Games now have higher levels, and new technologies unlock new possibilities for interaction, entertainment, and impact. According to MediaWise-Harris Interactive Poll, 9 out of 10 kids ages 8 to 16 play video games in their homes. Also the average age of gamers continues to increase, as…

Words 725 - Pages 3