LEARNING OBJECTIVES
TO BECOME FAMILIAR WITH EACH OF THE
FOLLOWING:
Labour issues: Shift from SE to non-standard
employment (NSE)
Different perspectives on how to organize labour
and employment relationships
Managing Workplace Diversity
Employment
Employment is a form of work in which a person (an
‘employee’) is dependent upon, and mostly subservient to, an ‘employer’.
The employment relationship is governed by an
employment contract, which may set out specific rules, obligations, and rights applicable to the employer and employee, and is usually enforceable in a court of law, like other contracts.
Standard Employment Relationship (SER)
1930s to the 1980s was the golden age for the employment
relationship in Canada.
Employees who lose their jobs receive Employment Insurance.
Employees who are injured received Workers Compensation.
People had long term contracts that provided them with benefits,
pay increases and they were secured for the most part
Distinguishing “Work” from “Employment”
Many people who “work” are not “employed”. How can
that be?
-ie., independent contractors, self-employed, temporary
workers
Eg. Payroll clerk, graphic, artist, interpreter, translator, kitchen
staff…….?
Non-Standard Employment Relationship (NSE)
NSE Become the dominant form since the 1980s
Part-time, temporary, lower pay, fewer benefits, shorter job
tenure, no access to collective bargaining.
Recently accounts for about 35% of the workforce, mainly young
university graduates.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2pcLNTNfD3c
Temporary workers or precarious workers are
growing across the world!
Full-time employees are being replaced with
Temporary workers/independent contractors.
So what?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZgKKHKziFRo
What distinguishes an “employee” from an
“independent contractor”?
Degree of Control – IC’s can set their own schedules, change their
charges from project to project, have latitude on how to perform work; Degree of Economic Risk – IC’s take on risk of whether they get work
or not versus employee who earns a consistent salary
Degree to which the worker performs an essential service for an
organization - core functions of the business tend NOT to be made up of IC’s (versus clerical staff, sometimes HR staff, legal..)
Degree to which the organization provides the necessary tools
- IC’s generally bring their own tools/equipment to project
(eg. Plumbers, electricians, window cleaners, many groups/crews in film production…)
Nature of independent contractor relationship
Independent Contractor
Pros: “independence” - ie, freedom from employer
constraints – can move from job to job, can create more flexible hours… ?
Cons: lack of employment security and regular wage;
contractor assumes success of project, and risk of financial loss if it fails. Often lower income, more vulnerability 10
Nature of independent contractor relationship
For the business
Pros: temporary arrangement so much flexibility;
‘contracting out’ of services as strategy to reduce business’s overheads/fixed costs; Saves office space/full-time wage/termination costs etc.; don’t need to pay minimum wage; don’t need to pay benefits….
Cons: ?
11
OPENING DOOR TO EXPLOITATION?
12
Court’s adjudication criteria
In case of dispute whether relationship is employee or
independent contractor, court will ‘unveil’:
1. degree of control over hours worked and manner of
performance
2. who assumes economic risk
3. essentiality of work to core business activity
4. provision of ‘capital’: tools/equipment –who provides?
13
CURRENT ISSUES IN EMPLOYMENT
What’s worse than a temp worker? An unpaid intern?
Internships = employment?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XO9ExWTH2aY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwm07y6W3zk
See pp.105 and 102-103
14
4 perspectives of the nature of the
Employer-Employee relationship
Neo-classical
Managerial
Industrial Pluralist
Critical