Beyond The Black Cloud: Looking At Lifecycles

Submitted By saraidlove919
Words: 2240
Pages: 9
Open Document
4
Beyond the Black Cloud:
Looking at Lifecycles

W

hen you’re behind a bus that’s belching black clouds of exhaust, you can’t help but think about the consequences of environmentally insensitive design. It’s easy to be disgusted by what the bus is doing to air quality. It’s also easy to miss the fact that the billowing fumes represent only a tiny fraction of the environmental impact of the bus. It’s harder still to remember that the bus may also have major environmental benefits, despite its obvious eco shortcomings.
Let’s start with the total impact. Think about the individual parts that comprise the bus. Thousands of them, globally sourced from a hundred different manufacturers and suppliers around the world, were brought together to a central location for assembly.
Think of the energy expended and the waste created in the process of obtaining the basic materials and manufacturing each of those parts.
Consider the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of the cargo planes and freighters and delivery trucks that brought the parts through the supply chain and ultimately to the assembly plant.
Think of the fossil fuels burned by workers commuting to and from that final assembly plant—and all of the other assembly plants where the subcomponents were built.
Consider the fact that some of those parts may have used toxic and carcinogenic substances either in the manufacturing process or within the parts themselves, and that those substances will eventually be heading to our landfills. Consider the waste materials left over after the bus has served its useful life: the massive tires with their polyester belts and steel cords, the petrochemical-based seat upholstery, the batteries with their lead oxide plates and

37

38

CITIZEN ENGINEER

rich assortments of acids (all of them with the potential to leach toxins into our soil and water).
And don’t forget that the emissions and contaminants and waste of the bus are only one form of its environmental impact—there’s also the noise pollution, the damage done to roadways, the visual pollution of the ads and graffiti on the sides of the bus, and so on.
The bus example helps to illustrate two of our engineering challenges.
First, the environmental impact of any one product or service is multifaceted and dependent on many factors, and when you’re designing something to be
“eco-friendly,” you need to take all of those factors into consideration.
Second, much of the impact of a product may lie outside any single company.
If you’re the owner of the bus, or even the company that did the final assembly, understanding the manufacturing process or waste issues is challenging at best.
We have no agenda against buses. In fact, they provide a great example of how something that has its own set of environmental impacts can also have a very positive effect: getting cars off the road. If we need to get 40 people from one place to another, a bus is far more environmentally friendly than
40 cars, even after the full accounting of the aforementioned impacts. This illustrates another of our challenges: Even eco-friendly programs, such as mass transit in this case, have an impact that can’t be ignored. When justifying a decision based on environmental impact, it is important to consider the full lifecycles of the proposed solution and the alternatives.
This point was driven home by syndicated columnist George Will, who argued in a 2007 opinion column that a Hummer is more environmentally efficient than a Toyota Prius hybrid.1 He even went so far as to say that “perhaps it is environmentally responsible to buy [a Hummer] and squash a Prius with it.” It’s a claim that sounds patently ridiculous—until you take a closer look at the concept of “lifecycle analysis.”
Yes, the Prius is fuel-efficient by today’s standards, but when you factor in the environmental costs of mining and smelting the zinc required for the battery-powered second motor, the production processes for turning the zinc into the component that goes
Show More

Related Documents: Beyond The Black Cloud: Looking At Lifecycles

Chapter 4 Essay

Chapter 4 May-28-13 11:44 AM Job Satisfaction: • Job satisfaction: pleasureable emotional state resulting from the appraisal of one's job or job experiences -- how you feel about your job and what you think about your job • Employees with high job satisfaction experience positive feelings when they think about their duties or take part in task activities • Employees with low job satisfaction experience negative feelings when they think about their duties or take part in their task activities •…

Words 1994 - Pages 8

Chapter 4 Essay

chapter iCh. 4: This chapter is all about cells make and use energy.  4.4 – A chapter about cellular energy is really about the unit of energy that cells use: Adenine tri-phosphate (ATP). This molecules is really similar in makeup to a nucleotide. Figure 4-8 shows how ATP can be used over and over again. All of the energy is stored in on phosphate chemical bond, so you break it off to get the energy and put it back on again to store energy. Technical terms to know: ATP, ADP.  4.5-4.10 – All…

Words 515 - Pages 3

CHAPTER 4 Essay

CHAPTER 4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 4.1. Trans-esterification of WCO with methanol 4.1.1. Effect of the variation in quantity of alcohol (methanol) upon the yield of bio-diesel. The methanol-to-oil ratio is one of the important factors that affect the conversion of triglyceride to Fatty acid methyl esters (FAME) i.e. the yield of Bio-diesel. In Trans-esterification, three moles of methanol are required for each mole of triglyceride, but in practice, a higher molar ratio is required…

Words 1097 - Pages 5

CHAPTER 4 Essay

Chapter 4- Parliament law making process Bill: A proposed law to be considered by parliament Delegated legislation: Law making powers given by parliament to subordinate bodies. Legislation: An act of Parliament or piece of delegated legislation Legislative process: The process used by parliament to pass laws Parliamentary counsel: A public servant responsible for drafting legislation at the request of a member of parliament (usually a minister) Private members bill: A proposed law introduced…

Words 1493 - Pages 6

Chapter 4 Essay

Chapter 4 Your perceptions will have either sustained or undermined the happiness of your relationship Social cognition – the process of perception and judgement with which we make sense of our social worlds Concern = way we think about our relationships Our perceptions and interpretations of our partnership are of enormous emportance What we think helps determine how we: Feel and then how we acts Shouldn’t be a problem if our judgements were correct Usually variety of ways to interpret an…

Words 5432 - Pages 22

Chapter 4 Essay

This week’s topic of Inductive Arguments presents the notion that inductive reasoning generates broad arguments and conclusions from specific situations. Unlike Deductive reasoning, Inductive reasoning does not give us any certainty that a conclusion will be true. The three concepts of Inductive Arguments that I found most interesting and helped me to think more effectively are: the importance of statistical principles, Mills’ Analysis of Cause and Effect and the notion of multiple causes. The…

Words 540 - Pages 3

Chapter 4 Questions Essay

Chapter 4 Critical & Creative Thinking Questions Tania Correia PSY103 January 26, 2015 Brian Hawkins Chapter 4 Critical & Creative Thinking Questions 1. Sensation and perception are closely linked. What is the central distinction between the two? The central distinction between sensation and perception would be the sensation begins with specialized receptor cells located in our sense organs (eyes, ears, nose, tongue, skin, and internal body tissues). When these sense organs detect stimulus (light…

Words 315 - Pages 2

Chapter 4 Essay example

Chapter 4: Discussion Questions: 1. Libel: this could happen if a worker or company makes a written statement that can be taken in a way that makes someone look bad Slander: This can happen in the workplace in ways such as gossip that puts a negative light on an employee. Negligence: This can happen if an employee or employer acts in an irresponsible way in which others may be harmed. 2. When a person has been judged to be responsible for a loss. When an employer does not do proper maintenance…

Words 634 - Pages 3

chapter 4 solutions Essay

Chapter 4 Solutions, 2nd Day Exercise 4-6 (15 minutes) Weighted-Average Method 1. Materials Labor Overhead Units transferred to the next department 790,000 790,000 790,000 Work in process, ending: Materials: 50,000 units × 60% complete 30,000 Labor and overhead: 50,000 units × 20% complete 10,000 10,000 Equivalent units of production 820,000 800,000 800,000 2. Materials Labor Overhead Cost of beginning work in process $ 68,600 $ 30…

Words 389 - Pages 2

Notes Chapter 4 Essay

CHAPTER 4 NOTES Cost-Volume-Profit analysis considers, individually and in combination, the effect(s) on profit of Selling price Sales volume (activity) Variable cost per unit Total fixed cost Product mix The contribution margin income statement (introduced in Chapter 3 if you need to refer back) can be expressed in total dollars, in dollars per unit (for sales and variable costs only), and also, as we’ll see a little further on, as a percent of sales (usually, but not always, for variable costs…

Words 1257 - Pages 6