One of Murray's main issues with our contemporary cultural requirement for a four year degree is that not all people are cognitively ready to pursue such a course of study, nor do all Americans have the natural desire to do so. Murray notes that the majority of general education requirements at a typical university do not impart skills that have any practical value, nor are skills that most employers demand. Why Murray asks, is a young man or woman who states a preference to learn a skilled trade, such as electrical work, plumbing, or auto maintenance, excoriated as someone who is unmotivated and intellectually lazy? For one thing, a young person who successfully completes an electrician's apprenticeship. Will be unlikely to ever be out of work, and a successful electrician can earn a comfortable salary. Murray stated, "Seen dispassionately, getting a traditional liberal education over four years is an odd way to spend one's time"(page 240). With regards to this statement, and the current state of our economy, Murray has a valid