Cherokee Vs Georgia Case Summary

Words: 1806
Pages: 8
Open Document
1.What were the decisions of the court cases The Cherokee Nation v. The State of Georgia and Worcester v. Georgia?
After these cases worked their way up the courts, each had differencing results. The case of The Cherokee Nation v. The State of Georgia was rule that the individual state of Georgia’s laws are not under the court’s jurisdiction and that the Cherokee were in effect under the care of the government, where Judge Marshall calls them “wards.”
While the Court chose to step aside from The Cherokee Nation v. The State of Georgia, they did rule on Worcester v. Georgia. In his deciding opinion, Marshall finds that the Cherokee Nation is its own nation thus have their own sovereignty within the borders of their land holdings. This opinion …show more content…
First, the Ridges accept that the only way to remain a Cherokee Nation is to give up the land. They are outspoken about this, pushing their belief of relocation is the only way to survive. The second blow is that the Ridges were going to have John Ridge (the younger) run for Primary Chief. They felt John Ross canceling elections and suppressing their voice, is a dictatorial move, while Ross felt that this is the only way to keep the powerful Ridges from forcing their conclusions on the fellow Cherokees. With the murder of John Walker Jr., a member of the Ridges group, there is a total break down between the two sides.
j. What treaty did the Ridge faction negotiate in defiance of Chief Ross and the National Council? Why did they do this?
By signing the Treaty of New Echota, the Ridges are committing treason against the Cherokee Nation. They are going against their people’s wishes, and signing without any authority of the Nation. In their hearts they felt they are doing what is best for the people. That if they sign at least they get something out of it where if they sit it out and are forced out, then they get nothing to help start rebuilding in the new lands. They sign knowing that this could lead to their deaths.
k. Ross presented to the Senate a petition to overturn the treaty. What happened to it on the Senate
Show More

Related Documents: Cherokee Vs Georgia Case Summary

Cherokee Vs Georgia Case Summary

to Native Americans? The Bureau of Indian Affairs was established in 1836 to administer to Native Americans. 4. Examine the attached document on the Cherokee Indian cases of the 1830’s and do the following: a. Describe the facts of the Cherokee Nation v. Georgia case & Worcester v. Georgia case. In the cases of the Cherokee Nation v. Georgia case in 1831 and Worcester…

Words 2154 - Pages 9

Essay on Dbq Ap

Indians if they did not assimilate cultures with the Americans. At first the Indians tried to do this but happened to give up. Another decision the Jacksonians made was declaring Cherokee Indians not independent. In the Worchester vs. Georgia case Andrew Jackson had heard what Chief Justice John Marshall had declared the Cherokee an independent nation. Andrew Jackson responded by saying “you made your decision, now let me see you enforce it.” About a decade later Andrew Jackson had created the Trail…

Words 480 - Pages 2