Civil Disobedience Essay example

Submitted By onesickchoi
Words: 1075
Pages: 5
Open Document
The most influential forms of action may originate in the very absence of action. The refusal to pay taxes, the objection to cast a vote, and the rejection of personal property are all declarations of disapproval directed to an unjust government. The people of any unfair system are obligated to tailor their government through relentless civil disobedience or rebellion. For the sake of the governed, immediate action, or lack of action, must be taken when a government deviates from its course. It is not a man’s duty to eliminate any wrong, but he must not participate in any wrongdoing. With such alienations from direct or indirect misconduct, the governed can effectively respond to the injustices of their government. The uninformed involvement in senseless wars, incapability of the voting system, and the issuing of unjust laws have lead to a deterioration of trust between governments and their subjects. Civil disobedience has become an effective form of nonviolent rebellion against an unjust government or system. The governed must rebel against the government’s astounding ability to launch itself into unjust wars that claim countless lives. The American War in Vietnam was such a war, Tim O’Brien recounts that, “Vietnam seemed to be wrong. Certain blood was being shed for uncertain reasons. I saw no unity of purpose, no consensus on matters of philosophy, history, or law. The very facts were shrouded in uncertainty” (962). O’Brien discovered how ridiculous the war was, people were being sent overseas for reasons not made apparent to them. O’Brien could not identify a definite purpose of the war, and so Americans were dying unjustly. The war in Vietnam had arrived for O’Brien in the form of a letter, yet he was not prepared, he believed he “was above it” and that the occasion called for civil disobedience. In his rage, O’Brien thought to himself, “If you support a war, if you think it’s worth the price, that’s fine, but you have to put your own precious fluids on the line. You have to head for the front and hook up with an infantry unit and help spill the blood” (963). O’Brien wished that those who supported the war were the ones who needed to kill and risk death in Vietnam, not the innocent subjects of the government such as himself. The system was unjust, the war was unjust, and the people dying in Vietnam were dying for no apparent reason other than to “stop the Communists”. O’Brien was never given the opportunity to vote on the matter of Vietnam, nor was he given a choice to fight when drafted, his only option was to rebel against the flawed system of the government. O’Brien was determined to avert the war and he, “began thinking seriously about Canada. The border lay a few hundred miles north, an eight-hour drive. Both my conscience and my instincts were telling to me to make a break for it, just take off and run like hell and never stop” (964). O’Brien had never supported the war, yet he was being drafted into it, he chose to disobey the government and drive north. O’Brien was afraid of dying “in the wrong war” in which he was given no choice but to fight in. Thoreau would agree that O’Brien owed it to himself to avoid the draft of a government that he did not support. O’Brien’s actions were justified and venturing towards Canada in a desperate effort to avoid the draft of a war he did not believe in was warranted.
Citizens are obligated to rebel in every way against an unjust government that they do not intend to support. However, their efforts to “refuse allegiance” may all be for naught, as Thoreau emphasizes. In revulsion, Thoreau speaks of the men who claim they would never assist the government that they defy, “these very men have each, directly by their allegiance, and so indirectly, at least, by their money, furnished a substitute” (945). He states that those who declare opposition to the government are yet aiding the cause by paying the very taxes that supply the soldiers. In a contemporary context, if a
Show More

Related Documents: Civil Disobedience Essay example

Civil Disobedience

States was founded upon the principle of disobedience of the British Monarchy in order to build a nation where unalienable rights are bestowed to everyone. Citizens continually make it their priority to elect officials who have similar views in order for them to create beneficial laws, but at times some laws are deemed unconstitutional or the elected official is seen as a threat to the constitutional rights which in turn generate protests. Civil disobedience leads to a positive impact on a free society…

Words 597 - Pages 3

Civil Disobedience

To fully understand the meaning of civil disobedience first we would have to say that the meaning of civil disobedience is the denial to obey certain laws or pay taxes and fines, as a peaceful form of political protest. The concept of civil disobedience evolved from the idea that there are laws of the state that don't secure citizens. This concept evolved over a long period of time and was grasped from different types of cultures. The act of civil disobedience was most effective in the twentieth…

Words 696 - Pages 3

Civil Disobedience

Americans began to resist the taxes imposed by the British. This effort culminated with the Boston Tea Party, in which Samuel Adams and the Sons of Liberty snuck onto a ship and dumped more than 45 tons of tea into the water. Prior to this act of disobedience, Adams had attempted to convince the governor to follow other colonies, refusing to accept the tea shipments in the first place. Despite his arguments, the governor and the consignees refused Adams, who proceeded to do what he felt was necessary…

Words 704 - Pages 3

Civil Disobedience

I am primarily dedicated to civil disobedience for the simple reason that no one gets hurt, however; the government left the ANC with no choice. I could not allow our unarmed protesters to be gunned down in the streets; thus I unwillingly was forced to respond with militant actions such…

Words 943 - Pages 4

Civil Disobedience Consequences

Native American, African American, and Immigrants. In history, Civil Disobedience is something every race does, consequences always follow civil disobedience, and today some of the consequences have changed. In the start of the United States, the country known for its freedom, was created due to civil disobedience. When the colonist refused to follow the taxes the king instructed to be collected the colonist reacted with civil disobedience. In the days when the English, French, and Spanish came to…

Words 625 - Pages 3

Thoreau's Civil Disobedience

To history, civil disobedience is the driving force that is integral to keeping a free society free. It is in civil disobedience that we find the keys to social change. From Thoreau's Civil Disobedience, one of the first intellectual writings supporting the idea, to the Black Lives Matter movement, and the Women's March on DC after President Trump's inauguration, civil disobedience is found as a prominent theme, a theme that keeps government as the tool to serve the will of the common many, rather…

Words 629 - Pages 3

Civil Disobedience Controversy

despotic rulers to contemporary civil rights movements opposing institutionalized discrimination. This demonstrates the natural human spirit of perseverance and the desire for a more just and equitable society. Disobedience has served as both a catalyst for productive change, but also a flashpoint for controversy. These points of controversy concerning both intelligent and civil disobedience raise the questions of the productivity of disobedience. Ultimately, disobedience may promote great, positive…

Words 1771 - Pages 8

Civil Disobedience Examples

obligated to do so.” I believe that civil disobedience not only positively impacts a free society, but it also helps to keep it honest and working for the people. This is shown through the civil disobedience of Gandhi, Harriet Tubman, and most recently Bree Newsome. Mahatma Gandhi was a anti-war activist who spent his life fighting racial segregation and the rule of the British over India. He is possibly one of the greatest examples of the impact that civil disobedience can have on a society. Gandhi led…

Words 701 - Pages 3

Peaceful Civil Disobedience

through civil disobedience and taking action to gain the freedoms we deserve. Peaceful civil disobedience is an effective tool that we the people can use in order to achieve the free society that our founding fathers envisioned for us. It would be counter-intuitive to suggest that civil disobedience negatively affects our free society because of our storied history. I do not know where we would be without the brave acts of so many Americans that achieved so much through peaceful civil disobedience…

Words 615 - Pages 3

Civil Disobedience Unjust

Civil disobedience as a way to resist unjust laws positively impacts a free society. Why? For three, simple reasons: it's mandatory when looking to achieve equality, it's a moral responsibility of the citizens, and it has always been a part of the democratic process. People who honestly seek change understand this, and will use peaceful resistance a means of achieving their goals. Throughout American history, and even beyond American history, change has come through peaceful resistance. They earnestly…

Words 797 - Pages 4