Presenters:
Rodney Pelletier, Fitch Ratings
Vida Tayebi, Fitch Ratings
Romano Paredes, Morgan Stanley
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
Overview
→ What
are CMBS?
→ CMBS
Process & Players
→ Typical
→ Rating
CMBS Deal Structure
CMBS Transactions
→ Different
→ CMBS
Types of CMBS Deals
Market Overview
–
Sub-prime Impact
–
2008
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
What are CMBS?
→ CMBS
are bonds sold through the capital markets, whose payments are backed by commercial mortgage loans → CMBS
are a segment of the structured finance markets
(other segments include RMBS, ABS, ABCP, CDO, etc.) → CMBS
are typically rated by one or more credit rating agencies CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
CMBS Securitisation Process
Origination
& Aggregation
Origination and
Primary
Underwriting
Functions
Structuring
& Rating
Closing of
Mortgages
Independent
Rating
Issuance &
Secondary Market
Aaa/AAA
TRADING
Aa/AA
A/A
Borrowers
Multiple
Mortgages
Pool
Information
Structuring
Baa/BBB
Distribution
Securities
INVESTORS
Ba/BB
B/B
NR
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
TRUSTEE
MASTER
SERVICER
SPECIAL
SERVICER
CMBS Process & Players
1.
Lender originates a (number of) commercial mortgage loan(s) to
Borrower(s)
2.
Borrower provides mortgage security to Lender
3.
Arranger (investment bank) structures transaction and selects loan pool for CMBS issuance
4.
Rating agencies provide and maintain rating on CMBS notes
5.
CMBS issuer sells notes to Investors
6.
Issuer uses notes proceeds to purchase loan (pool) from originator
7.
Servicer collects principal & interest (“P&I”) on the loan pool and pays P&I on the notes and provides reports to Investors
8.
Security trustee enforces security in case of defaults
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
Typical CMBS Deal Structure
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
Typical CMBS Deal Structure
External Supports
• Liquidity facility
• Funded reserves
• Issuer level interest rate/base rate/currency swaps
• Excess spread trapping
Rent
Tenants
Security Package and P&I on Loan
External
Supports
Mortgage
Collateral
Lender/
Originator
Owner/
Borrower
Loan
Amount
Loan Security Package
• Registered Mortgage
• Rent Assignment
• Account Assignment
• Borrower Level Swap
• Share Pledge on Owner/Borrower SPV
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
Security Package and P&I on Notes
Issuer
Issuance
Proceeds
Investors
Issuance
Proceeds
Notes Security Package
• Assignment of Loan Security
• Funded Reserves
• Issuer Level Swaps
Typical CMBS Notes Structure
EUR 92MM
Investment Grade
CMBS
AAA/Aaa
AA/Aa2
A/A2
BBB/Baa2
EUR 4 MM
Unrated CMBS
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
First
Loss
Lowest
Risk
Credit Risk
EUR 4MM
Non-Investment
Grade CMBS
Ba2/BB
Loss Position
EUR 100MM
Pool of
Mortgages
Last
Loss
Highest
Risk
Sequential Pay Down Structure
P+i
A
A
A
B
i
B
P+i
B
i
C
i
C
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
P+i
C
100% Pro Rata Pay Down Structure
Subject to triggers reverting to sequential pay down structure
P+i
A
P+i
A
P+i
A
P+i
B
P+i
B
P+i
B
P+i
C
P+i
C
P+i
C
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
Modified Pro Rata Pay Down Structure
Subject to triggers reverting to sequential pay down structure
A
P+i
P+i
B
P+i
B
P+i
P+i
C
P+i
C
P+i
P+i
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
A
A
B
C
Priority of Payment (PoP) or Waterfall
→ Pre-Enforcement
→ Separate
→ Straight
vs Post-Enforcement
waterfalls for P&I
sequential or pro rata
→ Modified
sequential or modified pro rata
→ Sales
proceeds in liquidating pools with allocated loan amount pro rata and release premium sequential
→ Significant
impact on the tranching of the notes
CMSA-EUROPE CONFERENCE 2008
LONDON, 4-5 NOVEMBER
Typical Security Package for Notes
→ Assignment
of