Cognitive Behavioral Therapy: Article Analysis

Words: 1100
Pages: 5
Open Document
Expressing feelings can be effective and therapeutic, in this way Cognitive Therapy is flawed. It is also falling short in the fact that Ellis believed that human beings do not need love and acceptance from significant others to feel worthwhile. I believe the opposite, in that an individual needs to have a close relationship with another person to be emotionally healthy. The majority of the short comings inherent within Cognitive Therapy, in regards to multicultural factors, revolve around the clinician. The theory was developed by western minds and can have inherent western concepts of assertiveness, independence, and the communication of emotional content may unintentionally be forced upon a client. Thus the councilor must be careful to …show more content…
If a councilor finds that they are unable to remove a potentially damaging bias or is unwilling to do so they should recommend another professional to the client. It is also important to take into consideration a person’s past. It may be that the individual has dealt with trauma due to gender identity, race, socioeconomic status, or cultural identity. If these factors are not taken into account it is likely that the councilor will do more harm than good.
The similarities and differences between these two approaches is highlighted within the article Existential perspectives and cognitive behavioral therapy (Prasko 2012). Within this article they take a systematic approach to clarify the differences, short comings, and shared methods of these therapies. The article opens up by listing the limitations classical cognitive behavior theory to “existential questions, such as meaning of life, acceptance of unchangeable aspects, meaning of values, transcendence, significance of experiences, and heading into the future” (Prasko, 2012). While these differences are in fact significant, both therapies “accent the …show more content…
To do so one should be aware of one’s self, biases, and general philosophical view of the world they inhabit. It is not as easy as simply picking the current popular movement or what might seem easiest to implement. Existential therapy is the best choice in my mind, though far from perfect. It seeks to assist clients in answering truly important and increasingly difficult questions. The largest of these being why we exist. It is my view that without purpose or meaning to one’s existence there in point in existing. How can an individual hope to contribute to society, find the force of will to push herself/himself through the monotony of the day, or deal with an increasingly hostile world without a feeling of purpose? Is anything without purpose or meaning worth doing? I do not believe so. I personally pose this question several times a day, every day in hopes of discovering a deeper meaning. It is my belief that there must be a reason to go about the daily tasks present in life, greater than to simply continue to exist. If I do not see purpose or meaning in an action, completing said action becomes monumentally more difficult and increasingly less likely to be completed. This is not to say that I am unwilling to do work or need an epiphany to take out the trash. Meaning and purpose is needed to sustain oneself as well as to cause change. . I do not believe I am alone in this, apathy is growing among
Show More

Related Documents: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy: Article Analysis

Sarah Maraniss Vander Schaaff's Life: Article Analysis

Recently, The Washington Post released an article titled “Obsessive-compulsive disorder nearly ruined her life”. This article, written by Sarah Maraniss Vander Schaaff, reviews Schaaff’s life as she struggles to overcome her obsessive-compulsive disorder. In the article, she discusses the many hardships that she faced such as needing to see multiple doctors frequently over obsession of a mole, and constantly worrying that she left the stove on or that her babysitter was really a child abductor. These…

Words 698 - Pages 3

Feminist Analysis Model

these approaches to individual and family therapy are conducted apart from political and societal contexts. Additionally, they view and critique traditional approaches to personality and therapy as androcentric, and biased toward women as reflected in the articles of Weaver (2008) and Gadd (2004). Weaver (2008) presents a study focused on initiating change in men who are violent towards women. The article highlights the ineffectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral (CB) models that challenge perpetrator…

Words 697 - Pages 3

Group Facilitation Project: Post-Analysis

Post-Analysis of Group Facilitation Project The group facilitation project was a great experience and I learned a lot about myself in the process. There were many challenges to creating a plan and putting it into action. Several class concepts and theories were used to carry out our facilitation including, the five stages of the nursing process, Peplau’s nurse patient relationship, motivational interviewing principles and OARS. The peace and power theory represents the group dynamics and roles…

Words 1496 - Pages 6

Evidence Based Practice Assignment

Recreational Therapy and Evidence-Based Practice Assignment. Step 1 Formulate a clear clinical research question. Propose a PICO question/idea. In older adults with dementia living in long-term care (P), how does participation in a music therapy program (I) compared to standard care (C) affect agitation and anxiety levels (O)? B. Identify the search terms and conditions. You should have at least 3 terms for each category. For example, for the population category you might use older adults (as…

Words 1937 - Pages 8

Diversity of Psychology Essay

diversity provides for different vigorous demands on the field. The psychodynamic cognitive-behavioral, and humanistic point of view characterize varied points of view on individual behavior; each prolonging a stated resolution to psychological fight, or a clear-cut theory on the individual nature. The different areas of psychology have different characters that are specific to individual’s nature such as cognitive, social, spiritual, and unconscious sway, allows for different patterns, in individuals…

Words 1118 - Pages 5

Combining Treatments Essay

research has indicated that treating depression with antidepressants alone has a negative outcome ( e.g. Antonuccio et al., 1995; Grohl, 1995; Kirsch & Sapirstein, 1998; Knowlton, 1997; Racy, 1995). Recent research has indicated that cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), a branch of psychotherapy, is the best form of treatment for depression (e.g. Antonuccio et al., 1995; Grohl, 1995; Knowlton, 1997; Racy, 1995 ). Unfortunately, very little research has been conducted on the effects of combining…

Words 4786 - Pages 20

Cbt Case Studies

In Webb, Hayes, Grasso, Laurenceau, & Deblinger’s (2014) article regarding trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy (TF-CBT) in youth, the therapy was directed to patients ages 7-16 suffering of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). TF-CBT includes eight components divided into three phases, a total of 12-16 sessions were available to be completed in this experiment. The study consisted of 72 participants; 72 participants obtained pre-treatment, 70 participants completed 3-6 months of treatment…

Words 1486 - Pages 6

Anxiety: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy and Anxiety Noun Essay

Anxiety Hitting Home I chose the topic of anxiety because it is something that affects my life daily. I have an elderly mother who suffers so severely she does not leave the house unless I am with her. I have tried other methods of understanding and trying to help but they seem to only help temporarily. In my research I hope to find out what it is, what causes it and how to overcome it so I can better assist my mother who deserves a better quality of life. The first task is to get a clear understanding…

Words 1212 - Pages 5

Insomnia Paper

that have continued or chronic behaviors with insomnia may experience fatigue, impairment with cognitive performance, difficulties with attention, concentration, and memory, or possible difficulty with simple manual skills (American Psychiatric Association, 2013). Mental health care professionals may find that this particular abnormal disorder may have an impact on a person’s health as fatigue, cognitive focus and their mood could be affected (American Psychiatric Association , 2013). A sleep disorder…

Words 2634 - Pages 11

Discrimination: How Can I Heal If I Am Identified As A Gay And Lesbian Youth

IV. Risk Factors A. Protective Factors V. Desired Results A. Outputs B. Outcomes C. Impacts VI. Influential Factors VII. Strategies VIII. Assumptions IX. Statement of Need X. Literature Review XI. Logic Model A. Incidence Reduction B. Stakeholders Analysis C. Formative Evaluation D. Summative Evaluation XII. Staffing Infrastructure XIII. Budget XIV. Executive Summary XV. References Problem Statement Discrimination against gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender individuals has been around for decades…

Words 5758 - Pages 24