Comparative Criminal Justice System Essay

Words: 2170
Pages: 9
Open Document
Unit 4 Written Assignment:
By: Alysia Pietrangelo
Professor
CJ509: Comparative Criminal Justice Systems
September 1, 2011

With so many different cultural and historical perspectives, it can change the way the criminal justice system works. Two types of criminal justice systems in which bring a lot of historical and cultural perspective include Iraq and Italy. Both countries also have legal tradition in which help in the way the criminal justice system works. In addition, both politics and legal issues can also cause the criminal justice system to change. However, the answer to the question relies on how this all does play in to the criminal justice systems for both Iraq and Italy. Beginning with Iraq, there was many …show more content…
To begin with, the main criminal law in the Italian legal system is the Italian Criminal Code. It is the currently in force and dates back to 1930 and can also be referred to as the Rocco code, named after the Minister of Justice. It was inspired by the Napoleonic Code of 1810 and also the 1870 Code of William. In addition, it was also inspired by the coded of the nineteenth century by the extent of Liberalism. Nonetheless, there is an authoritarian state, the original Code was severe and gave a highly repressive role to the states powers (“The criminal justice,” 2000). Therefore, the death sentence, was banned by the Criminal Code of 1889, but then was reintroduced with many strengths; there was to be more strict penal sanctions to those forms of behavior (in primis violence) depending on if they individual was from a lower or middle class. However, once the Fascist regime was overthrown changes were made to the Criminal Code. In 1944, Legislative Decree No. 222 abolished the death penalty. In 1958, Law No. 127 modified the Penal Code, “proof of guilt”, punibility became dependent on proof of guilt. While many other changes have been made in addition to what has been stated, there was also a change to where the Rocco Code was no longer the main source of the Italian criminal justice system but yet the secondary and supplementary use (“The criminal justice”, 2000). Also, Italy then revised the penal code which replaced the old “inquisitory” system
Show More

Related Documents: Comparative Criminal Justice System Essay

Historical Policy Comparison Essay

Historical Policy Comparison University of Phoenix CJA 463/Criminal Justice Policy Analysis Historical Policy Comparison In the past fifty years, the American system of criminal justice has undergone a number of critical changes involving policing, the courts and corrections. Landmark Supreme Court rulings, such as Miranda v. Arizona, and Mapp v. Ohio have shaped the way that law enforcement, as well as our courts, deal with individuals accused of committing crimes (Marion and Oliver, 2006)…

Words 2184 - Pages 9

Equity Theory Of Motivation In The Criminal Justice System

fairness in the justice system. The way a person views the treatment of other employees by the management and the organization in relation to how they are treated greatly affects the motivational level. In this theory of motivation, fairness and how the employees perceive it being distributed in the organization and the workplace. In other words, employees are usually sensitive to how they are treated by the management compared to their colleagues in the…

Words 1922 - Pages 8

Respectarianism Vs Comparative Egalitarianism

II. Responding to Objections from Respectarians and Egalitarians Some punishment theories including respectarianism and comparative egalitarianism seek to uphold the need for equal treatment and the dignity of the offender. However, these do not seem to be adequate to overcome the overall conflict in which Yost seeks to address regarding the influence of punishment to structural oppression. In assessing these theories, Yost makes the point that the main conflict resulting from differential punishment…

Words 1554 - Pages 7

Essay about organized crime

Comparative Analysis Paper Enchandrel Malone CJA/374 January 20, 2014 Debra Nadeau Comparative Analysis Paper The American Judicial system is broken into two separate systems called the adult and juvenile court systems. Before the juvenile system was established in 1899 (Juvenile Justice System, 2012). Youths were in courts and placed in facilities with adults. This concept made the government re-evaluate how youths are treated and felt that they were different from adults because of their…

Words 1180 - Pages 5

Comparative Criminal Justice Essay

Comparative Criminal Justice System Criminal Law has and will continue to be a fluid and ever-changing aspect of humanity, and yet the distinctive base of religious belief is still a foundation for a variety of laws today. While the separation of church and state is in effect, history states a wide range of laws have been established based on religious beliefs and ideals, the Bible for one, and currently the Qur’an, which is the basis for Islamic Law. It is the only true form of law in the present…

Words 1352 - Pages 6

Welfare-Based Model

youth justice system should follow the UN Convention to ensure that the best interests of young people are given primary consideration based on the welfare-based approach. In addition to examining Canada’s compliance with the Convention, I will do a comparative analysis and explore how Canada compares to Scotland’s implementation of the Convention with their welfare-based model. Based on this approach, I will end the paper by explaining recommendations aimed to create a more effective system for Canada…

Words 1233 - Pages 5

Juvenile Justice

Topic : Comparative Study of Juvenile Justice in China and US Introduction In the 1899, the first juvenile court was established in US, delinquency, status offender, criminal, civil, and administrative cases committed by juveniles are all under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court. The juvenile justice in US contains the main ideas of the state acting as the legal guardian for the juveniles who are in need of protection, proper education, and emphasizes the individualized correction and rehabilitative…

Words 1435 - Pages 6

Criminal Justice and Society Essay

Criminal Justice and Society CRJ 201 Melissa King I. Corrections is most relevant to the Eighth Amendment of the . The Eight Amendment, which states, “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.” This prohibiting the federal government from imposing excessive bail, excessive fines or cruel and unusual punishments, including torture. Laws should be applied to persons equally, without discrimination on prohibited grounds…

Words 831 - Pages 4

Gabbidon's Race Ethnicity, Crime And Justice

Shaun L. Gabbidon’s Race Ethnicity, Crime and Justice attempts to provide an explanation for the status of racial and ethnic minorities in countries such as Great Britain, the United States, Canada, Australia, and South Africa. Gabbidon contends that colonization plays a crucial role in explaining the disadvantageous status of racial and ethnic minorities in these countries, but seeks to understand if the effects of colonization impacted all societies the same and whether particular racial or ethnic…

Words 687 - Pages 3

Megan Kanka Case

law moves away from traditional justice system responses, which is treatment/rehabilitate. These “registration laws explicitly reject the idea that the state can rehabilitate sex offenders.” (Bedarf, 1995). In 1989, the United States Department of Justice conducted a study and found that rapists have a lower recidivism rate, 7.7%, for the same offense than any other class of offender except murderers (Beck & Shipley, 1989). Another study funded by the U.S. Justice Department in 2008 determined that…

Words 927 - Pages 4