Compatibilists: Should They Do Their Right Or Wrong?

Words: 538
Pages: 3
Open Document
The boys should be punished harshly I feel. They choose to go the extra mile, and assault those women. They should be charged as adults because they did try to rape the girl that was only 16 years old. So, they should get the full penalty for their actions. They choose to do their crime so they shouldn’t get off easy. I think that the five boys that assaulted that women could have got sympathy from the jury. They would had maybe got sympathy from the jury only if they didn’t choose to assault the other two girls. Doing that made earning the sympathy of the jury even that much harder to gain. I personally think that the don’t deserve any sympathy. If a compatibilist saw this, they would probably say that they were directed towards the robbery …show more content…
The compatibilist would say their guilty though, because they choose to go the extra mile and try to rape that woman. A determinist would just say that those boys were determined to be there at that time a decided to assault those three women. A libertarian would just say that those boys choose to do that on their own free will. The victim’s reaction is hopeful and I like it a lot. I can see why she can forgive the kids. They may not of had they best upbringing, but it doesn’t excuse them for what they did to her or those two girls. I am happy that her two kids feel bad for the boys, and see why not to do those actions. This statement helped clear up a lot of things that were over exaggerated by the media. She stated that not a single victim was raped. They were sexual assaulted by the five boys but not raped. She also said that was healing and that he kids were also healing. I feel like this wasn’t the best thing to release this statement. It is bad because it made the case harder for the attorney. Which he/she was trying to put them away for what they did to you. If a determinist was defending the boys, they would say that it was determined that the boys would assault
Show More

Related Documents: Compatibilists: Should They Do Their Right Or Wrong?

How Is Robert Harris Morally Responsible

violent behavior. A hard determinist, compatibilist, and libertarian would have different perspectives as to whether Robert Harris was morally responsible for the murders he committed. A hard determinist believes in determinism and agrees that the future is firmly fixed by the past. In addition, they argue that a fully determined future is incompatible with free will, thus saying true freedom requires control over the future, and since people lack control, they should accept that they are not…

Words 328 - Pages 2

free will Essay

Free will exist but it is limited. Compatibilist Free will does exist and every choice that we have at our disposal is proof of that. I will never deny that, however, it has a limit. Ultimately our paths have been written. The lessons we are supposed to learn will happen regardless of the path we take. With that said free will allows us to choose in sense weather we want to learn the hard way or the easy. Weather that knowledge that will open our minds and allow us to set back is there of not it…

Words 404 - Pages 2

A Good Man is Hard To Find Essay

Blackburn's theory of "Soft Determinism" people are responsible for their actions as long as true and available information is possessed. Blackburn's short story revises the compatibilist definition several times. The revised revised definition reads as follows: The subject acted freely if she could have done otherwise in the right sense. This means that she would have done otherwise if she had chosen differently and, under the impact of other true and available thoughts or considerations, she…

Words 914 - Pages 4

Free Will Research Paper

Do we have Genuine Free Will or Do we have Radical Free Will? In terms of free will, Jean-Paul Sartre’s “radical” opinion on free will is one of truth and axiom. Humans have the desire to perform actions. These actions can be deliberated on prior to performance, or they can be spontaneous. Nevertheless, the action is fulfilled by a choice made by the operant. That being said, any person has a decision to make when it comes to actions they participate in. That’s where the consciousness (the little…

Words 947 - Pages 4