Constitutional Law and European Integration Essay

Words: 1519
Pages: 7
Open Document
There are few cases that rival Factortame in being concurrently substantively clear and decisive, and perplexing as to its full impact. The scope of the change to the UK constitution that has been instigated by it and other European Court of Justice decisions has been conceptualised as ranging from a ‘legal evolution’ to ‘revolution’. Although some theories are more convincing than others, each faces its own weaknesses. However, notwithstanding the conclusion of this particular speculative debate, the processes of European integration has undoubtedly quickened the pace at which UK Parliament and courts as part of a globalised world have had to squarely confront these constitutional changes, especially the departure from Parliament’s …show more content…
These developments suggest that the “new view” is the most plausible representation of Parliamentary sovereignty today because referendum locks and the possibility for individuals to present a case in national courts on law derived from sources other than Parliament present limitations on Parliamentary sovereignty but not in the substantive sense discussed above. Proponents of the “new view” view that ultimate sovereignty remains with Parliament but it may have to conform to certain manner and form limitations. The appealing factor of this model is that it also accommodates for the limitations that Human Rights Act proposes on Parliamentary legal authority as well. Yet it is problematic in that the EU has explicitly stated in s2 of the ECA that on at least an EU level, Union law is regarded as supreme and this theory fails to encompass this dimension of the relationship between domestic and EU law. Most importantly, it accentuates how the increasingly multi-layered nature of the constitution must be taken into account in the broader debate. The holding of a point of absolute power faces pressure from outside as well as inside the nation. When the broader question of whether we should be edging away from political and towards a more legal
Show More

Related Documents: Constitutional Law and European Integration Essay

German Unification Essay

junior coalition partner. Pressures on the federal structure. • Although german unification was achieved with minimal changes to the constitutional structure the effects on the balances of federal systems have been significant, partly due to the increase number of Landers and the economic weakness of these states. • Contrary to the attempt of the Basic Law to create a strong decentralised federal system the trend during the 1970s and 1980s was increasing centralisation. Trend that had been…

Words 2800 - Pages 12

Russia Ukraine Crisis

military officers and their families from Crimean with the objective of saving their lives. The second agreement and the involvement of IGOs The second agreement pertaining to the issue of Russia-Ukraine crisis was made under the witness of the European Union and representatives of…

Words 2348 - Pages 10

American Exceptionalism Research Paper

History books often depict Native Americans as savages who couldn’t tame the frontier, and the term civilization tends to consistently follow Europeans while forgetting Native Americans. (Loewen, 99) This is far from correct, yet Rupert Costo, founder of the American Indian Historical Society, once said, “There is not one Indian in the whole of this country who does not cringe in anguish and frustration…

Words 1277 - Pages 6

EU Seminar 4 Essay

art267(2) and (3) ).It’s the prerogative of the ECJ to decide whether a body is a court or a tribunal for this purpose and national law categorization is inconclusive as per the case of Corbiau v administration des contributions. The ECJ takes an inclusive approach as indicated in Dorsch Consult that may include whether the jurisdiction is compulsory,whether it applies rules of law,whether procedure is inter partes..however the case of Cartesio at para56-7 emphasized that a reference can only be made if…

Words 2824 - Pages 12

Essay about Sovereignty Revisited Jens

The European Journal of International Law Vol. 17 no.2 © EJIL 2006; all rights reserved ........................................................................................... The Concept of Sovereignty Revisited Jens Bartelson* Beaulac, Stéphane. The Power of Language in the Making of International Law. The Word Sovereignty in Bodin and Vattel and the Myth of Westphalia. Leiden: Martinus Nijhoff, 2004. Pp. 200. €90. ISBN 9004136983. Ilgen, Thomas L. (ed.). Reconfigured Sovereignty. Multi-Layered…

Words 6205 - Pages 25

Course Study Guide Essay

womanizer, trying to have an affair with Orgon’s wife Tartuffe almost takes away Orgon’s house, but is eventually caught Read more about Tartuffe in the test review I made for the unit 1450-1750 Part I Locke Established natural laws of politics Argued for constitutional government Went against the idea of divine right Hobbes Start of liberal thought Thought that absolute government was necessary to stop complete anarchy Believed there was a social contract between a sovereign and their people…

Words 5048 - Pages 21

Enfranchisement Of Native Americans In The Late 19th Century

Indigenous people of North America had a longstanding history of independence, self-governance, and democracy that predated the arrival of Europeans in the Western Hemisphere. However, upon Columbus’ arrival in the Caribbean in 1492, the Indigenous people he encountered, falsely referred to as “Indians”, were initially regarded as savages far inferior to European Colonizers. In the centuries following, Indigenous people faced unceasing conflict with colonizers, who sought to eradicate the “Indian Savages”…

Words 1437 - Pages 6

Essay about World History Study Guide

Human sacrifice (Aztecs much more) Monumental Architecture Highly developed agricultural technologies Contrast: Inca state-run economy Aztecs have merchant class, Incas don’t Aztecs divided into city-states (not much integration), Incas a fully integrated empire (common language, common law, large bureaucracy) Sui Dynasty Accomplishments Built the Grand Canal Built granaries to prevent famine Reunified after Six Dynasties Period Status of Confucian scholar-gentry under the Tang Restored scholar-gentry…

Words 2006 - Pages 9

Indian Act Research Paper

claim that Indigenous people were ‘citizens minus’. Until the 16th century, Aboriginal people were the only inhabitants of what is now Canada, hence, they were independent and self-governing. Europeans finally had the capacity to dominate Canada’s original inhabitants and possessors (Elias 1). The European Invasion brought about The 1876 Indian Act, which was developed over time through separate pieces of colonial legislation regarding Aboriginal peoples across Canada such as the Gradual Civilization…

Words 1691 - Pages 7

Iceland Economy Essay

Commission to the European Parliament and the Council "Enlargement Strategy and Main Challenges 2012-2013", COM(2012)600 final) Iceland continues to meet the political criteria. Iceland is a well-functioning democracy with strong institutions and deeply rooted traditions of representative democracy. The country’s judicial system is of a high standard, and Iceland ensures the continuous strengthening of its already high level of protection on fundamental rights. The constitutional council’s proposals…

Words 2435 - Pages 10