Copyright: Copyright and Source Code Essay

Submitted By luhao24308161
Words: 1121
Pages: 5
Open Document
Software Copyright: An Idea-Steal-Allowed Copyright
On December, 2009, NEON Enterprise Software formally prosecuted IMB for anticompetitive behavior that IBM applied erroneous statements to force its customers to reject zPrime, a type of mainframe-related software produced by NEON. However, IMB countersued NEON of infringing upon IMB’s intellectual property and “inducing IMB’s customers to violate their agreements with IBM.” Finally, in 2011, the legal dispute is settled by NEON losing its operating rights for zPrime.
The well-known case brought a heated topic on intellectual property protection on intangible property, especially software copyright. In the case, the official judgment was that NEON Enterprise Software illegally implied the source code of IMB mainframe’s systems, which are zIIP and zAAP, to design zPrime. Therefore NEON broke the Intellectual Property Law and had to pay the punishment. By 1876, the United States had promulgated a series of Intellectual Property Law to legitimate various rights, including copyright, trademarks, patents and some design rights. With technological development, intellectual property protection confronts new challenges and a relatively important one of them is the software copyright because the software copyright infringement is difficult to be tracked, be evaluated and even be proved.
Historically, software, or called computer program, was not under protection for a very long time, since the computer program was not viewed as a “fixed and tangible” product. In other words, technically, software copyright is designated by the object code, which is an intangible good, produced from source code. Thus, to detect software copyright infringement needs comparisons of two programs’ source codes and object codes. The goal was very hard to achieve because, generally, designers have a strict security system to protect the source code from exposure; thereby others cannot obtain the code easily. For instance, there are two software implying exact the same source code; however, the outlook, manipulation and function are totally different, so, since the one cannot obtain other one’s source code without a legal authority, it is very hard to know that one commit software copyright infringement.
Also, the case of NEON Enterprise Software vs. IBM showed how important to protect the source code. When IBM just countersued NEON for hijacking IBM’s intellectual property, they had no evidences to prove that NEON illegally used reverse engineering to obtain their source code. In other word, IBM suspected that NEON designed zPrime which is directly based on IBM’s operating system because zPrime functioned as eliminating a huge amount of routine workloads running on the IBM mainframe’s central processor. Simultaneously, NEON improperly altered and dismissed zPrime’s development records to make infringement hard to be detected. Even though IBM successfully found evidences to sue NEON, the process took time and was grueling. However, if IBM had a more secure guard to prevent source code from reverse engineering the case would not exist. Therefore, the vital factor to protect software copyright is the source code protection; however, in the software field, the copyright only protects “expression”, but not “function”.
Protecting expression aims to protect idea’s expression. In other words, the copyright can protect the output of an idea, but not idea itself. Sometimes, the word “expression” can be considered as the source code. However, since there is no safety guard for the idea, the method of operating is not copyrightable, meaning that the function of software is not under protection. Moreover, the source codes of some small and medium software are relatively easy to be obtained by using reverse engineering, a technique that can get access to the ideas and functional elements. However, designers needs legitimate reason for using reverse engineering. For example, in the NEON Enterprise Software vs. IBM
Show More

Related Documents: Copyright: Copyright and Source Code Essay

Copyright Compliance Essay

Just twenty years ago, saying “copyright” to teachers most likely conjured images in their minds only of the fine-print notice in the front of a textbook. Today, with a world of Web 2.0 technology at their fingertips, copyright issues for teachers can be confusing and complex. Add to that an ever-increasing emphasis on technology literacy in our states’ education standards – forcing teachers to incorporate applications and resources that may be uncharted territory to them – and the waters get even…

Words 1004 - Pages 5

CON9080 Marion CON9080 Tips And Techniques For PeopleSoft PeopleTools Developers Full Essay

1 Copyright © 2013, Oracle and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. Tips and Techniques for PeopleSoft PeopleTools Developers Jim Marion PeopleTools Expert Oracle OpenWorld Bookstore  Visit the Oracle OpenWorld Bookstore for a fabulous selection of books on many of the conference topics and more!  Bookstore location: Moscone South, East Bridge  All Books at 20% Discount  Meet the authors 1:00 PM – 1:30 PM Wednesday and Thursday 3 Copyright © 2013, Oracle and/or its affiliates. All…

Words 2219 - Pages 9

Essay about Artistic Plagiarism

and industry it is a serious ethical offense,[7][8] and cases of plagiarism can constitute copyright infringement. Contents 1 Etymology 2 Legal aspects 3 In academia and journalism 3.1 Academia 3.2 Journalism 3.3 Sanctions for student plagiarism 3.4 Self-plagiarism 3.4.1 The concept of self-plagiarism 3.4.2 Self-plagiarism and codes of ethics 3.4.3 Factors that justify reuse 3.5 Organizational publications…

Words 2284 - Pages 10

Chapter 6 Essay

groups. Describe how to achieve cross-functional cooperation in teams. Copyright © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall 06-02 Chapter 6 Learning Objectives After completing this chapter, students will be able to: See the advantages and challenges of project teams. Understand the nature of conflict and evaluate response method. Understand the importance of negotiation skills in project management. Copyright © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall 06-03 FIGURE…

Words 693 - Pages 3

Financial Statements and John Wiley Essay

they influence financial reporting. • Explain the meaning of generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). • Explain the significance of professional judgement in applying GAAP. • Discuss some of the challenges and opportunities for accounting. Copyright © John Wiley & Sons Canada, Ltd. 2 The Canadian Financial Reporting Environment Financial Statements and Financial Reporting • Accounting and capital allocation • Stakeholders • Objective of financial reporting • Information asymmetry Standard…

Words 1760 - Pages 8

Unit 1 Essay example

Modern Systems Analysis and Design Unit 0 Course Information Agenda  Information about me and the course         About me Syllabus Others Lab Teams and Class Registration List Important Dates Chapter 1 Lab/Assignment Work To-Do Your Instructor- Leon Pan  More than 8 years university teaching in programming and software development  3 year at UFV 4 years at PUC  1 year at UoR and First Nation University  12 years senior programmer  Experienced with helping students   Education…

Words 2147 - Pages 9

Essay on Programming Language and Pearson Education

Software Solutions Foundations of Program Design 8th Edition John Lewis William Loftus Copyright © 2014 Pearson Education, Inc. Focus of the Course • Object-Oriented Software Development – problem solving – program design, implementation, and testing – object-oriented concepts • • • • • classes objects encapsulation inheritance polymorphism – graphical user interfaces – the Java programming language Copyright © 2014 Pearson Education, Inc. Instructor • • • • Bruce Link Ph.D. Computer Science…

Words 1840 - Pages 8

Serena Stone Legal Case

only received these DVD’s from a co-worker by the name of Serena Stone. Serena Stone’s boyfriend, Antonio Jones is the sources who created the bootleg copies. After Gallagher’s investigation, both Stone and Jones were charged with dealing in the pirated recordings of the DVD’s. Jones appeals the charge and implicates that although he aware of the federal law for the copyright for unauthorized distribution of the pirated copies.…

Words 796 - Pages 4

Type Of Data Cables

(COAX) Fiber-Optic Cable (FO) ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ Unit 3 Key Concept 1: Cable Types Copyright 2012, ITT ESI  1 UTP  ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ Four Pairs of Copper Cable Number of twists varies per inch No shielding Very easy to work with Most common cable for LAN Cat 3, Cat 5, Cat 5e, Cat 6, Cat 7 will be defined in standards later in the course ◦ Most susceptible to Electromagnetic Interference (EMI) o o Copyright 2012, ITT ESI 4 Copyright 2012, ITT ESI 6 Similar to UTP Pairs shielded Core shielded SCTP o…

Words 2771 - Pages 12

Essay on ECE 3561 Lecture 12 VHDL Overview

L9 – VHDL Overview VHDL Overview  Rules for State Assignment Application of rule Gate Implementation  Ref: text Unit 15.8   9/2/2012 – ECE 3561 Lect 9 Copyright 2012 - Joanne DeGroat, ECE, OSU 2 Overview  HDL – Hardware Description Language     A language that allows description of hardware for documentation, simulation, synthesis, verification, … To use an HDL you need a CAD system that supports it. Major CAD systems support VHDL, Verilog, System C, System Verilog CAD systems…

Words 1918 - Pages 8