Copyright Infringement Essay

Submitted By rrucker217
Words: 1979
Pages: 8
Open Document
Russel Rucker
Prof. Davis
English 101
29 April, 2014
Research Paper
Copyright Infringement The United States Constitution states that, “The Congress shall have Power... to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and their Discoveries” (US Const. Art. I, Sec. 8, C1. 8). This is the underpinning of the Copyright Act of 1976, which states, “an 'original recording' is any article on which sounds or images, or both, have been recorded with the authorization of the holder of the copyright for the material recorded.” Copyright laws are placed to defend creators of original works. “Copyright infringement is the violation of copyright law through the illegal use of protected material” (Wankel). Any article written, lyric sung, or image painted belongs to its creator. “’Counterfeit recording’ means any article on which sounds or images, or both, have been copied from an original recording, without the authorization of the holder of the copyright for the material recorded” (“Copyright Act of 1976”). Without the permission of the creator of a work, copied work is counterfeit work. Copyright infringement increases yearly in society, strips artists of rewards for their hard work, and can have serious penalties. The Copyright Act of 1976 states, “Any person who sells or rents counterfeit recordings, or possesses counterfeit recordings for the purpose of sale or rental, shall be guilty of a class A misdemeanor if natural person, or guilty of a class B felony if any other person.” Copyright infringement can take forms in music, film, literature, and even photography, and those found guilty pay a heavy price. Most cases of copyright infringement, where the defendant is found guilty, award hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars to the plaintiffs. Infringing on others' work can hurt infringers more than it helps them. One of the most famous cases in music copyright is Three Boys Music v. Michael Bolton. The Isley Brothers released a song in 1966 called “Love Is a Wonderful Thing.” In 1991, Michael Bolton released a song under the same name and even with some of the same lyrics. Bolton's song infringed upon the Isley Brothers’ song. Bolton defended himself, saying that there was insufficient evidence in the judge's findings, but the judge ruled in the Isley Brothers' favor. Bolton and the record company associated with him, Sony, was required to pay $5.4 million to the Isley Brothers (Green 210-212). The awarded $5.4 million to the Isley Brothers is the greatest sum ever given in association with a case of plagiarism in music. There are huge consequences when an artist infringes on another artist's song. Another famous court case involving music piracy is Bright Tunes Music v. Harrisons Music. George Harrison released a song in 1971 called, “My Sweet Lord.” He released the song under the Apple label, and it became number one and remained on the charts for twenty-seven weeks. Yet, in 1962, the Chiffons came out with a song titled “He's so Fine.” They came out with the song before George Harrison signed under the Bright Tunes Music Corp label in 1971. Both songs were essentially similar, with minor differences between note and chords. Eventually, the case went to court, and the judge was in favor of Bright Tunes Music, resulting in $587,000 in damages to the Chiffons (Green 210-212). Musicians are not the only people being accused of infringement. Movie directors like James Cameron are being accused by screenwriter directors like Elijah Schkeiban of stealing ideas. James Cameron, director of The Terminator, Titanic, and Avatar, was accused of stealing ideas from Elijah Schkeiban, novelist and screenwriter of Bats and Butterflies. Schkeiban accused Cameron of stealing ideas that were incorporated in Cameron's popular movie, Avatar. Schkeiban argued that elements such as a “weak hero” and a plot twist where the “bad
Show More

Related Documents: Copyright Infringement Essay

Essay on Copyright Infringement and Millennium Copyright Act

everyone could take the file for free. The legalities arose when music became the common file to share. Musicians and record label companies who owned the rights to the music brought Napster to court believing the sharing of their music was copyright infringement. The idea and case of “file sharing” over the internet had never been dealt with prior to and so the courts had to make decisions based on what they believed the law inferred. The real questions of topic were, was there a crime being committed…

Words 1087 - Pages 5

Copyright Infringement and Electronic Bulletin Board Essay

Information Technology Acts The No Electronic Theft Act of 1997 is a bill that was aimed at amending the provisions of dealing with criminal liability for copyright infringement despite the infringer’s lack of a profit motive. Prior to this bill criminal copyright infringement required that the infringement was for the purpose of “commercial advantage or private financial gain.” Around this time in history it was possible for an individual to upload and download files on the internet without any…

Words 377 - Pages 2

Plagiarism: Copyright Infringement and In-text Attribution Essay

Plagiarism is the incorporation of someone else's work – including their language and ideas – without providing adequate credit.[1] The University of Cambridge defines plagiarism as: "submitting as one's own work, irrespective of intent to deceive, that which derives in part or in its entirety from the work of others without due acknowledgement."[2] Wikipedia has three core content policies, two of which make it easy to plagiarize inadvertently. No original research prohibits us from adding our…

Words 434 - Pages 2

Controversy: Copyright Infringement and Reference List Essay

news (January 18,2012) the proposals will protected against copyright violation and theft of intellectual theft property .Those bills are supported by many entertaining and companies but also rejected by Internet advocates and providers like Silicon Valley which claim that those potential laws will stop the freedom on the World Wide Web In text-citation: “The bills are intended to strengthen protections against copyright infringement and intellectual property theft, but Internet advocates say…

Words 908 - Pages 4

Essay on Copyright Infringement of Software and Software Piracy

The Global Economy and Software Piracy Stephanie Crowe CS300T 17970 Computers In Society Kurt Maly October 17, 2013 Software piracy is the unauthorized copying or usage of copyrighted software, and in 2011 the market of pirated software grew to a record 63 billion dollars in commercial value, and 57% of computer users self-reported that they used pirated software in a recent survey conducted by Business Software Alliance. The study also found that most piracy occurs in countries with…

Words 1756 - Pages 8

Assignment: Copyright Infringement and A&m Records Essay

The case begins A&M Records, Inc. filed a lawsuit against Napster, Inc. for vicarious infringement. A brief explanation of vicarious infringement is when a party is responsible, such as Napster, Inc. for infringing conducted by another when A&M Records and Napster share an employer-employee relationship. As Napster attained huge popularity by sharing mp3 music files among peer-to-peers. As Napster becomes more popular, it caught attentions of major music companies that are unhappy about their music…

Words 434 - Pages 2

Copyright Infringement and Media Piracy List Essays

RESEARCH ESSAY PLAN: MEDIA PIRACY AND ITS AFFECTS The country with the worst history for media piracy is Armenia with a staggering 93% of the media market being pirated. A cause of piracy is low economic stability with the masses unable to afford movies but in countries with high economic standard like Australia it isn’t so prominent. The bottom 15 which is good in this case has as the worst 29% pirated media all the countries in the bottom 15 are financially stable countries, well in some areas…

Words 759 - Pages 4

Case 9-1 Essay

Copyright - Infringement - Defence of mistake and innocence - Claims for injunction and damages. Headnote This was an application for injunction and claim for damages for infringement of copyright. The defendant played three musical records in public without obtaining a licence from the plaintiff who was the owner of the copyright. The court found that the infringement was for one day. The defence was that the performance was done innocently and under mistake. Held: (i) Under s. 13 of the Copyright…

Words 3808 - Pages 16

Are Peer-To-Peer Networks Or File Sharing Websites Liable For Copyright Breaches?

Are peer-to-peer networks or file sharing websites liable for copyright breaches? Or it is users duty not to infringe copyright law? Since we are living in digital era everyday a new digital technology has introduce to it’s users .One of these technologies which has varied the way people use electronic products is peer to peer networks and file sharing sites. They allows users to watch clips and movies, listen to the music, read EBooks or even sometimes download any of these products…

Words 1561 - Pages 7

Assign 12 Essay

Australian copyright law Copyright is a form of protection provided by the laws of the United States to the authors of “original works of authorship” including literary, dramatic, musical, artistic, and certain other intellectual works. This protection is available to both published and unpublished works. It is legal for anyone to violate any of the rights provided by the Act to right owner of copyright. These rights, however, are not unlimited in scope. There are limitations on these rights. In…

Words 691 - Pages 3