Corporate Payout Policies Essay

Submitted By mitch190
Words: 2219
Pages: 9
Open Document
Corporate Payout Policy
Corporate Finance
Mitchel Toman-20080713
Signaling theory and Miller and Modigliani’s (MM) dividend irrelevance theory are two approaches to payout policy that oppose each other. Through analysing the recent payout policies of major firms in today’s financial market and investigating the literature on the theories we can see some of the assumptions of MM’s theories can’t be true. Asymmetry of information and investment policy are a part of the financial world and prevent MM’s theories from being relevant while helping to prove the basic concepts of signaling theory.
MM’s theory on payout policy was developed due to other theories at the time being incomplete. Prior to MM most economists believed the larger the dividends a firm declared the greater the value of the firm (Allen and Michaely 2003). This would result in some firms issuing shares to fund large dividend payments (Brealy, Myers and Allen 2013) regardless of any future repercussions. MM introduced the idea that dividend payout is irrelevant as long as investment policy remains constant. This theory doesn’t change as repurchasing becomes more popular as it doesn’t affect investment policy.
The fundamental concept of MM is that firms cannot create value for stockholders over and above the income generated from their investment policy (DeAngelo, DeAngelo and Douglas J 2009). Payout policy is important in that managers distribute 100% FCF generated over the financial period as not doing so would decrease shareholder wealth. Payout policy becomes irrelevant as managers under the MM model must pay out 100% of FCF generated, they have no choice. A profound example of the misunderstanding of this theory is that 58.4% of CFO’s that had not paid dividends or repurchased shares in the previous three years had said they may never do so again (Brav, et al. 2005). Effectively minimizing shareholder wealth- the exact opposite of a firm’s goal.
For MM’s theory to be relevant there are some key assumptions that have to be met and it is here that MM struggles to be applicable: * Investors are rational * Contracts are complete * Information is symmetrical * There are no taxes * Markets are complete * Cash flows from investment policy must remain constant
When analyzing these assumptions the two that pose the biggest problem for MM is that cash flows remain constant and information is symmetrical.
The assumption that information is symmetrical is rarely applicable. Even today, with the abundance of laws requiring transparency of information from firms, a manager will always hold greater knowledge of value of a firm compared to an investor. This is the core concept for dividend signaling theories. As an alternative to models such as Gordon (1959) which proposed that dividends increased firm value by having a more secure, immediate payment, signaling theories develop the idea that dividends affect share price due to the information they represent (Allen and Michaely 2003).
Battacharya (1979), John and Williams (1985) and Miller and Rock (1985) all developed dividend signaling theories. These models help explain the market shifts that occur with a change in dividend payment or the announcement of a share repurchase, and they make basic sense. It is unlikely that managers and investors will share the same level of knowledge about a company in the real world and the symmetry of information is therefore an assumption of MM that often falls flat.
A survey in 2004 (Brealy, Myers and Allen 2013) highlighted 3 ideas that were important to financial managers: 1. Manager are reluctant to make dividend changes they may have to reverse. 2. Managers smooth dividends 3. Managers focus more on dividend changes than dividend levels e.g. a rise of 15% is more significant than dividend levels staying steady.
These 3 points can be supported with the dividend announcements of BHP, Rio Tinto and FMG in tables 1 and 2. Rio recorded a
Show More

Related Documents: Corporate Payout Policies Essay

Dividend and Payout Ratio Essay

Payout policy at Linear Technology Outline Analysis of the general background Ability to return cash: funding requirement analysis Return cash or retain cash: Cost of retaining cash How to distribute General background Basic description: Exhibit 1 1986: first IPO 1992 starting paying dividends: increasing the div by about 0.01$ per share each year 2002: significant drop in sales: -47% in sales, - 54% in profit 2003: an other increase in dividend to 33.1% of payout ratio. Historical payout policy…

Words 822 - Pages 4

253 Sample Essay

The dividend policy has a significant influence on shareholders’ investment to gain more profits. The optimal dividend policy of a corporation relies on capital gains and they always would like to quit dividend now for future returns, they realize the risk which is associated with delay of returns as well (Adeoti& Oladipo, 2013). Meanwhile, investors are attracted to various companies which can provide them with their desired dividend pattern. When the companies change their policies, investors will…

Words 1124 - Pages 5

UST Case all Essay

FIN 5104 Corporate Finance UST Case Ken Atavatkul Yi-Fan Lin Jingjing Xu Fall 2013 1. What are the primary business risks associated with UST Inc.? What are the attributes of UST Inc.? Evaluate from the viewpoint of the bondholder. (i) Brand name and market position: UST possesses strong brand name and high market share. For UST inc, the company is identified as the leading producer of moist smokeless tobacco products and well known for its conservative debt policy. Superior (ii) Cash flow…

Words 1209 - Pages 5

KazMunaiGas Exploration Production Company Analisys Essay

carefully about the way of efficiently organizing financial activities of the company, improving the management of financial resources and differentiating company’s policies and performance for firm’s future prosperity. This term paper addresses such issues for KazMunaiGas Exploration Production Company by the analysis of firm’s structure, corporate governance, financial statement and all other important factors that determine a financial condition of the company. A. Objective The main goal of this work…

Words 4849 - Pages 20

Ust Inc Case Summary

Whether you agree with this business or not; their product causes harm to the public. But, UST Inc. is the leading manufacturer in the moist smokeless tobacco industry, and is capable to increase high profit by using their low financial leverage (Exhibit 1). This company dominants market share by 77%, the firm is able to maintain their customers even when the firm increases their price on their products. UST is one of the most profitable firm in America, in addition Forbes recognize the firm by achieving…

Words 938 - Pages 4

Linear Technology Case Study Essay

What is Linear Technology Current Payout Policy? Linear Technology (LT) is like many firms where it used a combination of dividend payments and share / stock repurchases to distribute cash to its shareholders. With a cash dividend, cash is paid directly to shareholders while, with a stock repurchase, a firm uses its cash to buy back its own shares from the market which in turn reduces the number of outstanding shares (Titman and Keown et al., 2011). LT wanted to be able to attract different dividend…

Words 4551 - Pages 19

Discounted Cash Flow and Dividend Discount Model Essay

There are many methods to corporate valuation Asset based methods, using comparables such as the p/e ratio or the Price to sales ratio and option based valuation. Another method that has been described in our question is the free cash flow method. The underlying principles of the free cash flow method start with the dividend discount model and this can best be described when we look at the way investors buy shares in a publicly traded company when it is traded in a free market. By understanding…

Words 2053 - Pages 9

Essay on Koito Case

Koito-Pickens-Toyota Case Question 1 The Japanese corporate governance system differs vastly from the US system. Discuss corporate governance issues that may arise under the Japanese keiretsu. The corporate governance system in Japan is widely different from the US one insofar as it mostly involves a unique business model called “Keiretsu”. A Keiretsu is a form of corporate structure that groups a set of companies with interlocking board of directors and common business interests. Thus, due…

Words 2204 - Pages 9

Carnival: Finance and Debt Equity Ratio Essay

British-American cruise line companies. It was established in 1972 and since then the organization has just grown over the years. Today, it stands as a huge name in the corporate world having revenue of over 10 billion USD (“Carnival Corporation and Royal Caribbean--nd”). It has around 40,000 employees on ships and ports working for tourists and corporate clients. In this particular paper, we shall take account of various aspects of financial analysis of the company (“Carnival Corporation--nd”). The whole paper…

Words 948 - Pages 4

payout policy finance Essay

PAYOUT POLICY When firms generate FCF, they need to decide on how to use that cash. They can reinvest and increase the value of the firm. (by investing in positive NPV project). When firm has excess cash they can use this either as cash reserve or pay to shareholders (as dividend or repurchase share from current shareholder, these are the types of payout policy). A firms payout policy is shaped by market imperfections such as taxes, agency costs, transaction costs and asymmetric information…

Words 1313 - Pages 6