Court Case Observation Paper

Words: 1925

Pages: 8

Open Document

This paper discusses three evidentiary issues that arose during a court case observation. The court case was trying to decide whether or not a woman's parental rights should be terminated for her children. During the case, the defendant was trying to show that she could be a good parental figure, while the plaintiff was showing that the mother was not able to provide for the children. For these three evidentiary issues, the judge that was presiding was Honorable Scott Sparks. The three issues dealt with hearsay, relevance, and a compound question. For each of these issues, there will be a discussion of the Federal Rule of Evidence that is implicated, the judge’s ruling on the issue, and whether or not the ruling was appropriate by comparing it to the Federal Rules of Evidence. Each issue will be explained in detail with context of the conversation to show how it happened in the court case.

COURTROOM OBSERVATION ONE 3
Courtroom Observation One The court case that was observed was trying to decide whether or not a woman's parental rights should be terminated for her children. The judge presiding was Honorable Scott Sparks. The three issues dealt with hearsay, relevance, and a compound question. Each issue will be analyzed with the Federal Rules of Evidence to see if the judge's ruling was appropriate.
First Evidentiary Issue The first …show more content…
At this point in the case, the plaintiff started to talk about the woman's husband, saying that he was no where to found. This caused the defendant's lawyer to raise an objection of relevance because the husband was not the matter questioned in this case and should not be discussed. The judge disagreed and said that the husband could be talked about because it was something that needed to be included since the case was about whether or not the woman could provide for her children and the husband's absence affected

Essay on Memorandum Case Analysis

(“O’Brien”) as O’Brien negligently shot five shots in Sybil’s direction? 2. Does Crowley’s observation of Sybil’s death constitute the cause of her emotional distress when she had been hospitalized, diagnosed by a psychiatrist as clinically depressed, and had not return to work since the incident involving O’Brien shooting Sybil? 3. Is Crowley considered an “immediate family member” as defined in past case law when she raised Sybil since age three, solely as Sybil’s guardian after Sybil’s parents…

Words 2722 - Pages 11

Examples Of Court Observation

The courtroom that I chose to attend for my observation was the Toronto Courthouse located on 2201 Finch Ave. West. Since this was not my first experience at the courthouse I chose to observe plea bargains which addressed traffic and other bylaw matters. The reason for my decision to observe this form of courtroom proceeding was because I was curious what made people accept a plea bargain? The first thing I observed when I arrived at the court room was the structure of the space. The justice at peace…

Words 645 - Pages 3

Possum V Vic-Florest

Case Study:Friends of Leadbeater's Possum Inc v VicForests. Introduction This essay analysis centers around the case law Friends of Leadbeater's Possum Inc v VicForests, which was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. This paper was filed by the non-governmental organization Friends of Leadbeater's Possum Inc against the Victorian forestry enterprise VicForests, which was sued for logging forestry operations in 66 specified forest “coupes” in the Central Highlands region of Victoria. in 66 specified…

Words 1768 - Pages 8

Essay on Sustainability Case Assignment 1 1

Sustainability Case Study Assignment HF 270 Lodging Operations and Technology Project Assignment Information For this project, you will be working in groups of 2-3 and collecting information and profiling a hospitality property of your choice. You must acquire information for your profile from a hospitality employee, facility property owner or manager and through site observation. You may choose to make one or several site visits. Certain property information and details to complete in this assignment…

Words 903 - Pages 4

Alternative Dispute Resolution Essay

basis and is promoted by civil procedure rules. The act conducts it in a judicial manner. Its voluntary but courts maintain a supervisory role as its open to challenge by judicial review. Section says agreement in writing. Employment protection act 1996 better acas than tribunal. Ombudsman gives award. Solicitor training. Only in 1998 where there more contracts than those qualified. Courts and legal services act 1990 they can join judiciary at all levels not just as circuit judges. Their salary is…

Words 1196 - Pages 5

Timothy Dickerson Case Study

be seized.” The court appeared to adopt a categorical rule barring the seizure of any contraband detected by an officer through the sense of touch during a pat down search. The court further noted that, even if it recognized such a "plain-feel" exception, the search in this case would not qualify because it went far beyond what is permissible under Terry. The U.S. Supreme Court unanimously agreed that the cocaine in this case was inadmissible as evidence even though the Court held that officers…

Words 666 - Pages 3

Should National Government Be More Powerful State Government

is founded on the observation that since few men are wise enough to rule themselves, even fewer are wise enough to rule others.” – Edward Abbey One of the biggest flaws in running a stronger State government is the fragmentation of power that would result. Every state would have the freedom to create and enforce the laws that they designed, much to the detriment of transporting information or commerce. The supreme court sided with the national government in the court case Gibbons vs. Ogden (1824)…

Words 667 - Pages 3

Katz Case Study Summary

Abstract Utilizing the case studies of Katz, Jones, and Kyollo test, this paper reflects on the understanding of how law enforcement advancement in protocols influences the public’s view on government’s expectations of security and protection under the Fourth Amendment permissibly diminishing the scope of the rule. This paper does examines the cases of Katz “expectation of privacy,” Jones establishment of reasonability, and Kyllo pre-warrant searches to gather data to perpetuate the need for a warrant…

Words 1523 - Pages 7

Administrative Ethics paper

Patricia Pacheco HCS/335 16 April 2014 Katherine Watson Administrative Ethics Paper Introduction Summary The patient by the name of Doe was a being treated at a healthcare facility for a sexually transmitted disease. His privacy was violated when a nurse on staff recognized him as being the boyfriend to her sister in law. The nurse acted unethically when she used her power and authority to look up Doe’s medical records and tell her sister in law what Doe was being treated for. A string of events…

Words 1120 - Pages 5

The Observation of a 5 Year Old Boy Essay

Play Observation Checklist Observer:_______________ Play Setting:_______________________ Date:_____________ Approximate Child Age:___ Child Gender: M F Hand Preference: L R Initiation of Play Observed Yes No Comments / Questions Behavior Child quickly engages in play Child requires help in getting started Child needs encouragement Child directs his/her own play Child shows initiative or curiosity Child appears impulsive Child initiates…

Words 2211 - Pages 9