Crime Control Vs Due Process Essay examples

Submitted By onelove711
Words: 1588
Pages: 7
Open Document
SU_CRJ1001_W3_A2_Pride_R.doc
Robert Pride
South University Richmond

Zero Tolerance was first defined as the enforced suspension and expulsion of policies in response to weapons, violent acts and drugs in a school setting. Zero Tolerance has since come to refer to school or district wide policies that mandate harsh consequences or punishments for various rule violations. Regularly, zero tolerance policies pertain to drugs, weapons, violence, smoking and disruption in an attempt to protect student’s safety and maintain an environment conducive to learning. Some teachers and staff are in favor of zero tolerance because they believe it will filter the bad student’s out of the school. They believe it sends a clear and concise message that ill-advised behaviors are not going to be tolerated in the school system. However, research indicates that zero tolerance policies are ineffective over time and are related to several negative consequences such as; drop outs, disciplinary infractions. Data from the U.S. Department of Education and the Center for Safe and Responsive Schools state that a minimum of seventy five percent of schools reporting having zero tolerance policies for offenses such as;
Firearms- 94%
Weapons other than firearms- 91%
Alcohol- 87%
Drugs- 88%
Violence- 79%
Tobacco- 79%
It is evident in New York where last year fifty thousand people (one every ten minutes) were arrested for possession of small amounts of marijuana.

Stop and frisk- Under the Terry ruling (1968), police officers are allowed to stop and detain an individual based on reasonable suspicion. And if the police suspect that the person is armed and dangerous, they may also frisk the individual for weapons. The police officer runs his hands across the individual’s outer clothing to see if the individual has a concealed weapon. The stop and frisk is one of the most controversial procedures police conduct. It’s a limited search done with the intent of preventing a crime before it takes place based on the person’s suspicious behavior. Stop and frisk had been a long practice of the police and it wasn’t until 1968 that the Supreme Court evaluated it under the Fourth Amendment’s protection against reasonable search and seizures. Under Fourth Amendment law, a search and seizure must be based on Probable Cause while a stop and frisk was usually conducted based on a reasonable suspicion which is a lower standard than probable cause. Stop and frisk is a law enforcement officer's search for a weapon that can be found on a suspect's outer clothing when they notice either a bulge in the clothing or the outline of the weapon is visible. The search is called a "pat down," and any further search requires either a search warrant or "probable cause" to believe the suspect will commit or has committed a crime (including carrying a concealed weapon, which itself is a crime without a permit to carry). The limited right to "stop and frisk" is intended to halt the practice of random searches of people in hopes of finding evidence of criminal activity or merely for purposes of intimidation, particularly of minorities.

"Mosque crawling" (undercover surveillance of city mosques). NYPD dispatches teams of undercover officers also known as “rakers” into minority neighborhoods. They monitor the daily operations of bookstores, bars, cafes and nightclubs. The police have also used informants who are also known as “Mosque Crawlers” to record events and monitor sermons. And they perform these acts even when there is no evidence of foul play. NYPD has gathered evidence on cab drivers, food cart vendors and any other job often held by a Muslim.
•Analyze whether these programs have been effective. To do this, you will need to locate crime statistics for New York City and determine whether crime and terrorism have increased or decreased.
For the first half of 1997, New York City was ranked 150th out of 189 cities that have populations in excess
Show More

Related Documents: Crime Control Vs Due Process Essay examples

Due Process Vs Crime Control Model

Crime Control and Due Process In my opinion our criminal justice system operates as both the Crime Control Model and as a Due Process Model combined. Although I feel that with the recent state of our country we are more heavily weighted to the Crime Control Model at the moment. The Due Process Model is still a vital part of our country’s criminal justice system and due to the United States Constitution it always will be. One example of the Crime Control Model over shadowing the Due Process…

Words 438 - Pages 2

Due Process Model Vs Crime Control Model

different models used in the criminal justice system to process crimes; the Due Process Model and the Crime Control Model. The Due Process Model is used more frequently but if it were up to me, I would have the Crime Control Model become the sole basis of the criminal justice system of the United States. There are more than enough reasons that prove that the Crime Control Model is a “better” model than the Due Process Model. For example, the Crime Control Model has proven itself to be fastest and most efficient…

Words 347 - Pages 2

Crime Control Model Vs Due Process Model

The packer crime controls and due process models have significant value. The crime control model contains traditional and conservative values and the due process models contain liberal and traditional values. The crime control model is about behavior control for criminals first and foremost and efficiency to speed up the process when it comes to criminal processing. Packer created this process based on an assembly line process. This does not make this control more efficient because you cannot always…

Words 561 - Pages 3

Essay on Assignment 1 Chapter 2 Crime Control And Due Process

Crime Control and Due Process Allen C. Wayman CJ 470-50 Making Sense of Criminal Justice: Policies and Practices, 2nd edition 2220 Steeple Chase Dr. New Bern, NC 28562 acwayman1@catamount.wcu.edu Prof. Aaron Vassey Western Carolina University January 21, 2015 Abstract Crime control model and due process model are two different types of criminal justice models constructed by Herbert Packer, a Stanford University law professor, these two ideas represent a conflicting system of opinions working within…

Words 1265 - Pages 6

Essay about Reasearch: Crime and Mental Health

Juvenile Waiver Process Corey L. Bulger Capella University Table of contents Abstract p.3 Introduction p.4 Trends and Literature Review p.6 Systems and Theory Evaluation p.11 Conclusion and Recommendations p.14 Reference List p.19 Abstract In the past 25 years juvenile crime has been increasing, which has increased juvenile wavier process throughout the United…

Words 4538 - Pages 19

Juvenile Justice System Essay

under the age of 18, and have committed a crime. The theories and practices of the juvenile justice system have evolved a great deal over the years. The juvenile system consists of five periods from 1646- the present. The first period of juvenile justice is the Puritan Period. This period lasted from 1646- 1824. It was believed that bad children were evil and there was no rehabilitation for them. If parents could not control their kids, then community control and punishment were deemed necessary. “According…

Words 552 - Pages 3

Together Love And Family In The Shadow Of The Prison Book Report

as courts correction they acknowledge that someone made the crime, but they have mental issues. Therefore, the two models of criminal justice came along, with due process and crime control model; the first establish librol model, which punish people with the idea of fairness, and the second one with conciverty mode the assembelitely line model of the idea of quickness and finality. With dealing with any type of crime, mala inse; crime that are wrong in themselves, and mala prijevety; something that…

Words 850 - Pages 4

Consistency Of Trial Essays

Each alleged offender or defendant in the Criminal Justice Process should be considered on an individual basis because consistency of process is fairer than consistency of outcome. Do you agree? The purpose of the criminal justice process is to basis of the criminal justice process is the idea that individuals will receive a fair and unbiased trial The purpose of the criminal justice process is to stand as a reasoning organisation dedicated to keeping order and honour in society. ^^Law enforcement…

Words 885 - Pages 4

Social Life Essay

is a machine with several parts that work together. Durkheim did the suicide rate and found that male protestants are more likely to commit suicide. He looked at social causes. They don’t care about choice, they predict and control, look at cause and effect and independent vs. dependent variables. E.g if parents/most friends smoke, the individual is more likely to smoke Interpretive theory: By Max Weber. He thought positivitism was egoistical. Basic Tents: Truth is subjective and constructed…

Words 1597 - Pages 7

The Ins And Outs Of The Police Management Tool

called CompStat. This model has been credited with decreasing crime and increasing quality of life in New York City, and various cities throughout the country. The driving force behind the creation of CompStat’s methodology was Jack Maple. Jack Maple worked as a Lieutenant for New York City’s Transit Police and began tracking robberies in the subway by pinpointing them on several maps on his wall. Maple used his maps to track crime patterns and dispatched police officers accordingly. Maple however…

Words 1368 - Pages 6