Critical Essay

Submitted By jofimar
Words: 6670
Pages: 27
Open Document
J e n n i f e R

R i d d l e

h a R d i n g

•

21

“he haD neveR wRiTTen a woRD oF ThaT”: RegReT anD coUnTeRFacTUals in hemingway’s “The snows oF KilimanJaRo”
JENNIFER RIDDLE HARDING
Washington and Jefferson College

ERNEST HEMINGWAY IS KNOWN—AT TIMES EvEN PARODIED— FOR SHORT STORIES that rely heavily on dialogue interspersed with clipped narrative reports offering little evaluation or interpretation. This style is prominent in some of his best-known stories, such as “The Killers,” “A Clean, WellLighted Place,” and “Hills Like White Elephants.”1 How surprising, then, that “The Snows of Kilimanjaro” has joined these others as one of his most anthologized stories, appearing, for example, in The Norton Anthology of American Literature. Longer, divided into several distinct sections, and focalizing the main character’s thoughts and judgments quite extensively, “Snows” stands apart from many of Hemingway’s other stories. In fact, because it uses so many fragments with varied narrative techniques, “Snows” is an unusual short story not just for Hemingway but for the genre as a whole. Reading “The Snows of Kilimanjaro” requires integrating all of its fragments into a coherent narrative experience.2 The fact that several fragments represent not what did happen but what didn’t—are counterfactual with respect to the main narrative—further complicates this formidable task. Counterfactuals are mini-narratives describing events that “might have been” realized, but which are viewed as unrealized from the perspective of the characters and/or the narrator.3 Ontologically, these embedded counterfactual stories are not on the same level as the main narrative (Dannenberg 45-64). But emotionally and thematically, they resonate as much and perhaps more than the main narrative, and certainly contribute to its global meaning. In this paper, I will argue that the analysis of “counterfactuals” as a thematic element provides a means to identify coherence and unity in a seemingly fragmented text. The central theme of “The Snows of Kilimanjaro,” I believe,
The hemingway Review, vol. 30, no. 2, spRing 2011 Copyright © 2011 The Ernest Hemingway Foundation. Published by the University of Idaho, Moscow, Idaho.

22

•

T h e

h e m i n g w a y

R e v i e w

is the exploration of unrealized alternatives and the coincident judgments of these alternatives by characters, narrator, and implied author. The explorations of “what might have been”—which appear in some form in every section of “Snows”—unite the story’s fragments and provide the key to its total thematic effect, inviting the reader to participate in the process of judgment. WHAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN: BRIEF THEORETICAL GROUNDING Examination of the counterfactual as a linguistic form has a long history in the study of language, and the consideration of “counterfactual thinking” has more recently emerged as an important area of research in social and cognitive psychology. The “counterfactual” has traditionally been defined in technical terms as a conditional sentence with a false antecedent (see Lewis). I use the term as it has commonly been used by psychologists, to refer to narratives of unrealized alternatives, or what-might-have-been scenarios (Roese and Olson 1). It is important to keep in mind, though, that a counterfactual scenario has both a linguistic and cognitive dimension, a fact that has been investigated at length by cognitive linguists including Dancygier and Sweetser, Fillmore, Fauconnier and Fauconnier in partnership with Turner. As described by Gilles Fauconnier in his book Mental Spaces, speakers typically introduce the counterfactual into discourse by using a specific set of grammatical and lexical forms to indicate that a scenario is counterfactual and not actual; these forms include negatives, modal verbs, and conditional sentences (111-116). The counterfactual scenario departs in some specific and meaningful way from events viewed as actual by the speaker.
Show More

Related Documents: Critical Essay

Critical Lens Essay

Literary Analysis Essay: Responding to a Critical Lens Your Task: Write a literary analysis paper that interprets how the critical lens quotation connects to Romeo and Juliet. What is a Critical Lens? Like the lenses in a pair of glasses, or the lens of a camera, the quote brings what we are looking at into focus, and gives us a way to analyze, interpret, and think about the text. Choose one below to explore throughout your essay: “The ultimate measure of a man is not where he stands in…

Words 667 - Pages 3

Essay on Critical Thinking

Individual Critical Thinking/Writing Assignment Bus 121, Lab B01 In the current technological era, people are comfortable doing important things online as long as their information is protected by passwords; however, news of the “Heartbleed” bug in April has brought the public’s attention to computer security again. It is advised that web users should always be security-conscious when they use online services and developing a good security habit could effectively reduce the opportunity of…

Words 941 - Pages 4

Critical Evaluation Essay

Arrington 1 Karen Arrington English Katherine Oneil 22 July 2012 CRITICAL EVALUATION ESSAY Introduction In W.E.B. Du Bois’ “Of Mr. Booker T. Washington and Others,” Du Bois criticized Washington’s policy of racial accommodation and gradualism. Du Bois rejected the latter’s willingness to avoid messing with the racial issues and…

Words 1015 - Pages 5

Critical Lens Essay

Amanda McGovern Critical Lens Essay J.P Morgan once said, "A man always has two reasons for doing anything: a good reason and the real reason." When doing anything, a man always has a motive for his actions; something he truly believes is the truth, and the actual truth behind it. Examples of this quote can be seen through the works of literature, Othello by William Shakespeare, and The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald. Characters in both readings can often be misguided by outside…

Words 473 - Pages 2

CRITICAL ANALYSIS ESSAY

CRITICAL ANALYSIS ESSAY- THE ROCKING HORSE WINNER VERSUS THE DESTRUCTORS ROSEMARIE ESTEVEZ MAY 29, 2009 ENGLISH 102 Rosemarie Estevez English 102 May 30, 2009 “The Destructors”, by Graham Greene and “The…

Words 698 - Pages 3

critical thinking Essay

Critical Thinking and Language Essay How and what linguistic we use regulates how we think. Critical thinking is no diverse. What language we think and use to define something vital injunctions how cruelly we scrutinize it. The critical thinking process comprises looking at something and tentative it many altered ways. If the dialectal we retain is inadequate, our different ways of examining a focus are limited as well. If on the other hand the language we possess is widespread, then we can observe…

Words 725 - Pages 3

Smith Critical Essay

Smith Critical Essay By Aileen Campbell Smith by Leon Garfield is an exciting book that’s hard to put down. It is a book about a young pick pocket who is brought up by his two sisters; Miss Fanny, Miss Bridget and his best friend Lord Tom. The twelve year olds name is Smith and the book is set in 19th century London. He pickpockets an old man in an alleyway, and instead of retrieving money, he takes a document. Straight after he pickpockets the old man, he is brutally murdered by two men in brown…

Words 744 - Pages 3

Shotgun critical Essay

Critical Essay about John Biguenet’s Shotgun Race Relations Under the Same Roof After one of the worst storms in the history of New Orleans ravaged the city and its populace, the recovery of the decimated city ground along slowly. Among all the frustration building towards the government for the failure to recover swiftly after the tragedy, was the undercurrent of continued hatred among the different races of New Orleans. As one writer put it “On the eve of the second anniversary of Hurricane…

Words 1647 - Pages 7

Critical Review Essay

CW1 - Critical Review Essay Culture is a complex term and has many different meanings. To some, it relates to upper class people; like theatre, opera and galleries, however to others, it means to have travelled and seen the world. The idea of culture changed dramatically from someone tending crops and farming to the idea of the human mind at its best work. There are many different cultural forms which have changed over the past centuries, for example, a few that I am going to discuss in this essay…

Words 1644 - Pages 7

Nein: Frankenstein Critical Essay

Frankenstein Critical Essay The 19th century was a time of enlightenment where science and discovery were at the forefront of man’s being. During this time of enlightenment and exploration however, the ideas of Christianity clashed with man’s newfound affinity for science. Men like Darwin began to question the long held beliefs of creationism, and there was a lot of backlash, especially from the Church. Many people still were in fear of these new discoveries, which questioned and threatened to…

Words 300 - Pages 2