Understanding Islamic Intellectual Patterns In Africa

Submitted By hennabk1
Words: 4030
Pages: 17
Open Document
EXPLORING ISLAMIC INTELLECTUAL TRADTIONS IN AFRICA.
-define Islamic intellectual tradtions
-classical literature vs modern litertature
- Islamic ideology in Africa
-

Is there room for critical thought within classical Islamic thinking and does modern Islamic thinking have a future within the study of Islam.
A critical spirit has been central to Islam from its inception. The Qur'an is generously sprinkled with references to thought and learning, reflection and reason. The Sacred Text denounces those who do not use their critical faculties in strongest terms: "the worse creatures in God's eyes are those who are [willfully] deaf and dumb, who do not reason" (8:22). A cursory look at the life of Muhammad reveals that his strategic decisions were an outcome of critical discussions. The way he decided, for example, to fight the Battle of Badr outside Medina, or, later on, defend the city by digging a trench. The Prophet's basic advice to his followers, in one version of his " Farewell Pilgrimage", was to " reason well"1. The scholarship that evolved around collecting the traditions and sayings of the Prophet was itself based on an innovative and detailed method of criticism. It is widely acknowledged that debate and discussion, argument and counter-argument, literary textual criticism as well as scientific criticism were hallmarks of the classical Muslim civilisation2. Roger Allen traces the Islamic tradition of criticism right back to Abu Tammam (d.846) and ibn Abd Rabbihi (d.940), two poets who also excelled in literary criticism3. Islamic philosophical theology is littered with critical works, such as those of Ibn Hazm (994-–1064) , ibn Sina (990-–1037) and ibn Rushd (1126-1198). Critical discernment is clearly evident in the work of Muslim scientists of classical period such as al-Haytham (965-–1040), who excelled in optics, the natural and social scientist al-Biruni (973-–1048), and the astronomer al-Battani (858-–929). Debate and discussion, as for example the one between al-Ghazzali (1058-–1111) and ibn Rushd, were the norm in classical Islam.
Yet, with the exception of a relatively small number of reform oriented scholars, thinkers and activists of all ages, this critical spirit is lacking in the modern Muslim world.
The reasons for the evaporation of this critical thought are many and diverse. Perhaps it was all the fault of al-Ghazali, as "a widely held view" has it: he "strongly attacked philosophy in The Incoherence of the Philosophers" and, as a result, "their role was significantly reduced in the Sunni world"4, along with the importance of criticism. Perhaps it was "the well-known decree of al-Qadir in 1017-18 and 1029", that banned the rationalist thought of the Mutazalites, the school of speculative theology that flourished in Baghdad and Andalusia between eighth and twelfth centuries, as the late Mohammad Arkoun suggests. As a consequence, "to this day, the ulama officially devoted to the defence of the orthodoxy, refuse to reactivate the thinkable introduced and developed by original, innovative thinkers in classical period"5. Perhaps it was the closure of "the gates of Ijtihad", the "sustained reasoning" that a jurist had to undertake to critically interrogate Islamic law and reach an independent decision, that sealed the door to criticism. :While no one actually closed the gate, it came to be treated, as Sadakat Kadri notes, "as a historical fact rather than a poetically pleasing way of saying that jurists were no longer as good as they used to be"6. Perhaps it was because Muslim societies could not develop "legally autonomous corporate governance", Arabic thought is "essentially metaphysical" and incapable of developing universalism, and Muslim culture and ethos is just too reverential to religious authorities, as Toby Huff has argued7. Perhaps criticism died out because of a lack of any kind of state support or protection for dissent; or maybe it was the colonization of the Muslim world.
Show More

Related Documents: Understanding Islamic Intellectual Patterns In Africa

Essay Critical Thought #8

Debra Norby (Howell) HUSR 242 Mr. Tapia 11/14/13 Critical Thought Paper #8 The advantages of effective drug testing at work are: it increases productivity it decreases accidents decreased turnover it decreases absenteeism The disadvantages of effective drug testing at work are: invalid or false result invasion of privacy humiliating Notice that I have written effective drug testing in the above statements. Many drug tests are not done…

Words 334 - Pages 2

Essay on Thought and Critical Thinking Skills

and processes (dictionary.com). Before I attended Psychology 201 my thoughts on psychology were pretty simple. When I heard the word psychology I would think about a psychotic patient sitting in a room with a therapist discussing his/hers problems in life and the therapist trying to find an overall solution to that person’s problem. Once undergoing the course I realized that there is more to psychology than what I had thought. From the different kinds of sleeping people fall into to the left side…

Words 350 - Pages 2

Critical Thought Journal: Clinical Activity And Reflection

Critical Thought Journal third week 1. clinical activity and reflection. a. The course introduction and reflections on how it will contribute to your professional development. This week and as indicated by the presentation and the group introduction I need to more concentrate on that will help me to improvement my remedial nursing mediations and correspondences as the great restorative correspondence with people, gatherings, and populace encountering financial, social, natural, and mechanical…

Words 858 - Pages 4

Critical Thought Essay 3 Insanity Plea

University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus in Aurora, Colorado in 2011. In 2012 his academics began to decline, and he began to have some disciplinary issues. He was said to be seeing a psychiatrist, which suspected that he was having homicidal thoughts and reported it a month before the crime to the police. He had told another student to stay away from him because he was “bad news” prior to the crim. He also had a notebook, but information is still unknown about what is written. Prior to the shooting…

Words 1019 - Pages 5

Critical Thinking Essay

July 5, 2013 Critical Thinking Dictionary.com defines critical thinking as “the mental process of actively and skillfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing, and evaluating information to reach an answer or conclusion. Disciplined thinking that is clear, rational, open-minded, and informed by evidence: The questions are intended to develop your critical thinking”. Knowing that you would not be bias but could see the whole situation and not judge is condemned. Having a better…

Words 462 - Pages 2

What Is Critical Thinking

February 17,2013 Critical thinking can be defined as the process an individual takes that includes thinking in a logical and sensible manner in order to make a rational decision. Critical thinking also requires an individual to think past their normal capacity or “outside of the box” while improving the quality of thought. “The thinker improves the quality of his or her thinking by skillfully taking charge of the structures…

Words 317 - Pages 2

Essay On Stages Of Critical Thinking

University of Phoenix Material Stages of Critical Thinking Complete the matrix by identifying the six stages of critical thinking, describing how to move from each stage to the next, and listing obstacles you may face as you move to the next stage of critical thinking. |Stages of Critical Thinking |How to Move to the Next Stage |Obstacles to Moving to the Next Stage | |EXAMPLE: |Examine my thinking to identify problems…

Words 531 - Pages 3

Critical Thinking Research Paper

students are constantly being asked to critically think. Critical thinking is a part of daily life. There is "yes" and "no" questions and there is right and wrong answers however, critical thinking is taking an account all of your information and making a logical decision based off prior knowledge. It can start an early age and scientists have often asked when did this thought process all begin? Richard Paul stated, “The intellectual roots of critical thinking are as ancient as its etymology, traceable…

Words 739 - Pages 3

Response to Ruggerio’s “What Is Critical Thinking” Essay

Composition I 15 April 2013 Response to Ruggerio’s “What Is Critical Thinking” After reading Ruggerio’s “What Is Critical Thinking” I was able to understand the difference between a critical thinker and a non-critical thinker. The issue I came across with this essay is how Ruggerio emphasized that you are either one or the other. Take myself for example; there are situations that come about where I will fall into the critical thinker category. There are in turn some instances that I act on…

Words 301 - Pages 2

Essay about Critical Thinking Summary

Critical Thinking Discussion and Summary Christopher Schemers PHL/320 March 23, 2015 John Preis Critical Thinking Discussion and Summary Everyone thinks. It is in our nature to do so. However much of our thinking by itself, is biased, distorted or outright prejudiced("The Critical Thinking Society", 2015). The quality of our life and the quality of what we produce or build depends squarely on the quality of our thought process. Poor thinking is costly, both in business and in our quality of life…

Words 577 - Pages 3