Now the British knew not only that Tallmadge was head of the intelligence gathering, but that there was at least one active agent operating on Long Island through Connecticut by way of the Sound. Making matters worse, Woodhull was mugged on one of his trips to New York in May. Further complicating things, Woodhull discovered that John Wolsey, a Long Island privateer, had been apprehended by the British. In exchange for his parole, Wolsey divulged to the British that he overheard that Woodhull “was up to something dubious.” This information was given to Colonel Simcoe of the Queens Rangers. Captain Simcoe then proceeded to Woodhull’s home in Setauket, however, Woodhull had set out for another trip to New York only the day before. Woodhull’s father was beaten and his life was spared only because Colonel Benjamin Floyd vouched for his Loyalist sentiments. Because he was still under suspicion, Woodhull conveyed that he could no longer make the dangerous trips to New York. Washington would need a new and permanent man in New