Debate of Justice (the Republic) Essay

Submitted By shivdaddy
Words: 693
Pages: 3
Open Document
Shivansh Rastogi
Philosophy
The Debate of Justice

The Republic discusses the existence and validity of justice. In book 1, Thrasymachus argues that Justice is invalid and in fact only beneficial for the individuals who are unjust, and the system of justice is simply illegitimate. Socrates refutes these claims in books 2, 3 and 9 through the virtue and ideals behind justice, and the health of the individuals who are just and unjust. Injustice may provide artificial gains, but it will never yield a healthy soul and will ultimately lead to failure.
Thrasymachus believes that it always better have a life of perfect injustice rather than justice because that life would yield the least hardships, pain and misery. The following quote exemplifies his belief, “You will understand it most easily, if you come to the most perfect injustice, which makes the unjust man most happy, and makes those who are wronged and will not be unjust most miserable."(Plato, Book 9, 344a) Thrasymachus views perfect injustice as injustice done by the tyrants of society, this type of injustice tends to be ignored because of the high social status of these tyrants. These individuals are able to shield themselves from justice when they commit unjust acts because of the social standing and in turn harms the just man who belongs to the middle class, as he is the victim of these crimes. Therefore Thrasymachus believes justice is advantageous to those who are strong, because the strong are able to exploit the just behavior of those who are weak, and the weak are unable to do anything to rectify their situation. Thrasymachus further believes that justice is a social practice that is placed on individuals simply because of tradition and it does not impose individuals to obey it, thus the strong do not. Thrasymachus believes that in this society, the best way to resolve this problem would be to ignore justice altogether. Thrasymachus’ points convey that injustice should be pursued and those who pursue justice in the eyes of society are foolish and will inevitably suffer. Socrates argues that although justice may not always prevail, it is still essential to act in accordance with it. Socrates undermines Thrasymachus by stating the fact that wisdom is a virtue, and that if wisdom exists then injustice should not, as they are contradictory. Socrates main point derives from the Tyrannical Soul that justice is what brings order and maintains the health of the human soul. He claims that individuals who act unjustly, act this way because they lack inner harmony or have a weak soul, thus injustice is not beneficial. He further states that justice will lead individuals to success because once harmony of the soul is
Show More

Related Documents: Debate of Justice (the Republic) Essay

Thrasymachus Vs Socrates Research Paper

Thrasymachus vs Socrates Throughout Plato’s book The Republic of Plato, there is the constant debate about the definition of justice. Justice is seen very differently by two very different philosophers. For example, the philosopher, Socrates, deems Thrasymachus as this “wild beast”, mainly because of his negative view on justice. Socrates, on the other hand, believes that justice is like an art. He compares justice to other aspects such as medical practices and pilots of boats, saying that the person…

Words 615 - Pages 3

Essay about Student: Capital Punishment and Litigation Death Penalty

The Death Penalty The debate over the death penalty is not always the primary topic in legislation, but it’s one that never goes away. As recently as February 7, 2013, a federal District Court Judge, James Brady, halted an execution of a prisoner who is convicted of murdering his 12-year old stepson. This is because the State of Louisiana failed to provide details about its new execution protocol. Why are the details of the protocol so important? They are important and necessary because the defendant…

Words 1182 - Pages 5

The Good Old Days Analysis

[to] conservative” in “terms of debate”, Alfred S. Regnery argues that this couldn’t occur without William Rehnquist laying the “groundwork”: In fact, when he shifted federal power in the Supreme court, Rehnquist promoted progressive legislation, thereby increasing small-governments and leading to conservative votes on issues such as gun control and abortion. The author looks to Rehnquist’s friend who describes that judge (who thinks like an “old right… Republic[an]”) believes in “majority rule…

Words 357 - Pages 2

Samuel Warner's Argumentative Analysis

Prior to the Civil War and the approval of the 13th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, a great debate began among abolitionists and those who wanted to preserve slavery. This political debate on slavery was highly centered around the newly acquired territories, and if slavery should be permitted there. Abolitionists used political and moral arguments to counteract the case made by their pro-slavery counterparts and work to keep this territories slave free. In the Declaration of Independence, it…

Words 508 - Pages 3

How Did George Washington Establish The Power Of Government

During the 1790, the republic had many problems that confronted the new independent nations. Other nations are born in anti-colonial revolution, the U.S. faced challenges building a sound economy, preserving national independence, and creating a stable political system for opposition. George Washington thought the new government would not last 20 years. Only about 5% of white male adults voted for the new Constitution. The U.S. Constitution created a general government. The president would get say…

Words 516 - Pages 3

Why Did Rome Fall Dbq Analysis

develop in the sciences and the arts. Grecian influence and geographic advantages set Rome up for success. However, as the empire grew in size there was a need for supplies, causing economic and political tension, eventually transforming their renowned republic into a dictatorship. In the years that followed, government instability, martial negligence, and invasions caused Rome to fall. Generally, government instability is characterized by regime or government change, violence in society, and policy…

Words 873 - Pages 4

My Country Is The World And My Religion Is To Do Good

motion and circuit from the very beginning. This is the essential element of civic prudence: to see the paths and turns of commonwealths, so that when you know in what direction any action tends, you can hold it back or anticipate it.” ([1]On the Republic,II,47) Cicero believed that it is only through practical political experience and empirical inquiry; that you can accurately predict what policies the state can pursue in the future based on what their present actions are. Elaborating this fundamental…

Words 3785 - Pages 16

Mexican American War Research Paper

their economic landscapes in the aftermath. The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, which ended the war, led to Mexico ceding vast territories to the U.S., impacting Mexico's economy significantly. Furthermore, the war indirectly contributed to internal debates in the U.S. over slavery expansion and the organization of new states, highlighting how economic interests intertwined with political decisions during this period. "The Mexican-American War was a conflict driven by the expansionist ambitions of the…

Words 1535 - Pages 7

Separation of Powers Essay

require all offices to take an oath to the queen and the upholding of the Australian law and constitution * Judicial independence: separation of powers, not being influenced by political agendas, not being influenced by other judges * Natural justice: transparent process, open to scrutiny, providing reasons for actions and allowing a free media to report issues/incidents * Exercising of power: must be accountable to the people who have given the mandate/power Australian Constitution…

Words 5525 - Pages 23

Democracy: Democracy and United States Essay

Democracy in America Democracy is a unique type of government, and the purpose of this essay is to illustrate the strengths and weaknesses that a democratic government provides. I will detail that many components of this type of society are both strengths and weakness as each component has beneficial aspects as well as unavoidable pitfalls. A democracy is a government by the people, in which the power is vested in the people themselves. The people then elect representatives who conduct their power…

Words 2244 - Pages 9