He was confident in winning the case, because he had lived on free soil for two years. The court reached a decision and stated that he must continue to be a slave, because he was living in a slave state at the time. After losing his first trial, Scott then took his case to the U.S. Supreme Court. At the time, his new owner was John Sandford, Eliza’s brother. Scott was not ready to give up the fight for his own freedom. With the help of a new team of anti-slavery lawyers, he filed suit in St. Louis Federal Court in 1854 against John Sanford. Since Sanford was a New York resident, the case was taken to the Federal courts due to diversity of residence. Scott argued that his time spent in the free states and territories should entitle him to