Duty Of Disclosure Under Insurance Contracts Essay

Submitted By Summer913745G
Words: 4441
Pages: 18
Open Document
Duty of Disclosure under Insurance Contracts
Introduction
The insurance contract, as a sub-species of contract, shares the common rules of law as they are in general contracts. However, the uniqueness result of its nature makes it inevitable that specific rules exist. As the contract of insurance has been classified as one of utmost good faith, one party of the contract, usually the assured, is thus required not only to abstain from making misrepresentation but also to volunteer information. The duty of disclosure, therefore, plays a crucial rule in insurance contracts.
As it will be seen, the breach of duty of disclosure is a decisive factor in vitiating the insurance. However, the only remedy provided by law in the case of breach is extremely harsh. The absolute and uncompromising nature of such remedy, as a result, has never stopped the doctrine from being critically scrutinized. Besides, the archaic duty, born in 18th century, was also found to be hard to adapt in the modern world. The broad test for the duty of disclosure render it difficult for the assured to apply, and the scope of it is also too broad to be appreciated. In the area of consumer insurances, the unfairness it has brought to the consumers is too extreme, and the abolishment of the duty is thus inevitable. However criticized and questioned, in the area of non-consumer insurance, the duty of disclosure still has its irreplaceable and imperishable value. Perhaps for non-consumer insurances, the more logical way is to adjust the unsatisfying parts, rather than deny its value and eliminate it in a radical way.
1. Background
The concept of good faith, which implies a measure of fairness and honesty,1 exists in “all contracts and dealings”.2 There are two common types of a lack in good faith, one of which is that a contract is made by an inaccurate or misleading statement, generally known as misrepresentation. The other one is that two parties enter into a contract by one withholding information which is relevant to the other party in deciding whether to enter into a particular bargain.3 The principle of misrepresentation, designed to achieve procedural fairness, gives common law the backing in all contracts.4 In contrast, the duty to make a full disclosure of all relevant information are applied in insurance contracts, the specific nature of which expects the assured to do more than just not to make representation.
The principles underlying the duty of disclosure can be traced back to 18th Century when Lord Mansfield first took the opportunity to explain the necessity of the existence of such duty in insurance contracts in the case Carter v Boehm.5 Generally speaking, the assured has the knowledge of the facts upon which the contingent chance would be computed.6 This, however, leads to a vast imbalance of information in relation to the risk between the assured and the insurer who is traditionally regarded to have the knowledge on only what the assured has revealed.7 Besides, one cannot forget the nature of the insurance contracts by which the insurer agrees to provide a benefit on condition of the occurrence of an uncertain event in consideration of the promise of the assured who agrees to pay premium.8 The imbalance of knowledge and the speculative nature of insurance contracts, thus, requires the assured to make a full disclose in order to allow the insurer to consider either the acceptability of the risk or the terms of a policy based on fair dealings with regard to the equality of information.9 The rules of disclosure, have been codified in codified in Section 17 to Section 19 of the Marine Insurance Act 1906 (the MIA 1906), and it has been held to be applicable to non-marine insurance contracts as well. 10
In contrast, in other areas of commercial contracts, there is no need to apply the doctrine of good faith to its full extend. The parties to the contract are not required to volunteer information, regardless of the fact that the information might be
Show More

Related Documents: Duty Of Disclosure Under Insurance Contracts Essay

Australian Insurance Law Case Study Essay

insured-Steve was entitle to rely on the insurance policy he purchased to obtain indemnity after he misrepresented the material facts of the insured house. The focal point is whether Steve have constituted a violation of duty of disclosure and mis-presentation under Australian insurance laws. In Australian, the Insurance Act 1973 and Insurance Contracts Act 1984 are the main legislation relating to the body of law that mandates the insurance industry and insurance contracts, replenished by a series of other…

Words 2082 - Pages 9

Essay about Definitions: Health Care Practitioners

Definitions Chapter 1 (pg. 3-18) Health Care Practitioners: Those who are trained to administer medical or health care to patients. Litigious: Prone to engage in lawsuits Plaintiff: The person bringing charges in a lawsuit. Defendant: The person or party against who criminal or civil charges are brought in a lawsuit. Liable: Legally responsible or obligated Precedent: Decisions made by judges in the various courts that become rule of law and apply to future cases, even though…

Words 2957 - Pages 12

Duties Of Mandataries Essay

Business Law and Ethics Comm 315 Duties of Mandataries © Benito Aloe, Attorney B.A., LL.L. 15-03-01 © Benito Aloe, A,orney B.A., LL.L. 1 Business Law and Ethics • The content of these slides is copyright protected and owned by their author, namely myself; • The slides are provided to individual students exclusively for academic and study purposes; • Consequently, they cannot be published or otherwise shared with any other person without the explicit consent of their…

Words 2366 - Pages 10

Administrative Ethics paper

by her decision. Impact of this issue The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) of 1996 (Lotti & Stover, 1998) entitles Doe and any other citizen in America the patient confidentiality. Doe’s right to privacy was violated when the nurse chose to divulge Doe’s medial file to a family member. Doe filed a lawsuit alleging “common law breach of fiduciary duty to maintain personal health care information, breach of contract, negligent hiring, training, retention and/or supervision…

Words 1120 - Pages 5

Reasearch paper

international group was world's largest insurance company in 2007. Number of employees were 93 thousand and business was spread across 130 countries. Head of the organization was Maurice Greenburg. AIG had 95.8 billion outstanding equity shareholders to whom premium paid was 59.8 billion. General Re was world's largest reinsurance company. Genre was established 1921 , was owned by Warren Hathaway but led by Ronald Ferguson. AIG Came under Scrutiny when SEC discovered that AIG…

Words 1462 - Pages 6

Essay on GBL 295 EXAM 2

No­fault insurance has the goal of lowering premium costs by avoiding expensive litigation over the causes of accidents, while providing quick payments for injuries or loss of property. Further, no­fault systems often grant "set" or "fixed" compensation for cer…

Words 1544 - Pages 7

California Real Estate-State Test Prep

California Real Estate - State Test Prep Study online at quizlet.com/_1hvbj 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. "as is" A phrase used in sale contracts by sellers as an attempt to limit liability for the condition of the premises. If known latent defects or condition of a property is known to the seller, seller has the obligation to disclose. 1 square mile = 43560 square feet 3 years - broker documents Copies of all listings, deposit receipts, canceled checks, and trust records must be retained…

Words 3400 - Pages 14

Employment LAW FINAL Essay

Tort: A breach of legal duty that causes harm or injury to another person. Torts relevant to Employment Law include negligence, defamation, invasion of privacy, infliction of emotional distress, wrongful discharge in violation of public policy Employment-at-Will: The legal doctrine that allows the employer to terminate employment for cause or for no cause. Exceptions to employment at will: Implied employment contract: inferred by employer in words or writing, Public Policy: company acted in bad…

Words 2780 - Pages 12

Corporation Law Essay

Question 1 1. The principle or rule known as the maintenance of share capital is based on the need to protect shareholders and creditors. Share capital is the contribution made by shareholders by subscribing shares of the company. A company’s creditors can only look to the share capital for the payment in the event of a winding up. To protect creditors, a general rule known as the rule in Trevor v Whitworth was developed to prohibit a company from reducing its share capital because a reduction in…

Words 10471 - Pages 42

Tutorial Questions Essay

__________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________ 4. What are the different types of cases that come before the courts? What type of cases do you think business law mainly falls under? __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________…

Words 6802 - Pages 28