Edgar Allan Poe Is Insane

Words: 671
Pages: 3
Open Document
Edgar Allan Poe is known for writing very dark and horrid stories. Tales of murder, ravens, cats, the list goes on. His short story, “The Tell-Tale Heart,” is a story about an old man and his caretaker, which is told from his perspective. His caretaker rants on how he is disturbed by the old man’s pale blue eye. He then explains, how he plans how resolving this issue. Eventually, he tells the reader on how successfully he executed his murder. But all comes to an end when he finally confesses to the police. Furthermore, it is debatable whether the narrator is sane or not. I believe, there is enough evidence to prove that he is insane.
First things first, he wanted to kill the old man due to his pale blue eye. And yet, he also mentions how …show more content…
In his defense, he is not a madman but a calculated killer. Although, this can be equally backed up. I say he’s insane. He also takes pride in his work. Evidence to support my claim is, “But why will, you say that I am mad? The disease had sharpened my senses-hot destroyed-not dulled them...How, then am I mad? Hearken! And observe how healthily-how calmly I can tell you the whole story.” (pg.1) This quote illustrates how the narrator thinks of himself. The second piece of evidence to support my claim is, “Now this is the point. You fancy me mad. Madmen know nothing. But you should have seen me. You should have seen how wisely I proceeded with what caution-with what foresight-with what dissimulation I went to work.” (pg.2) This quote illustrates the narrator's opinion on how he is executing the old man. In conclusion, the old man is insane. He wanted to kill the old man because of his vulture-like eye. He also claimed he could hear the old man’s heart, even after being long dead. And most importantly, he is in denial of being crazy and is proud of himself. Based off these reasons, the narrator is quite unstable and doesn’t seem to know how to solve problems appropriately. Neither is he capable of lying, with the exception of
Show More

Related Documents: Edgar Allan Poe Is Insane

Is Edgar Allan Poe Insane Or Insane

Edgar Allan Poe wst like any other person, there were many tragic things that happened to him throughout his life. Mr. Poe wrote many poems and short stories that were mainly dark because of what happened in his life. We are reading one of his stories called “The Tell-Tale Heart”, this short story is dark and you might say a little odd. In his short story the narrator tries to convince the audience that he isn’t mad or insane, but i think the quite opposite of what he says. The narrator of “The Tell-Tale…

Words 397 - Pages 2

Poe Reading Response Essay

3/5/2015 Reading Response for “Poe and the Horror Story” Edgar Allan Poe, the most well-known and popular American writer to live, is famous for writing horror stories that install fear and excitement into the minds of the readers. Many of his stories consist of “narrators who have committed some horrible crime, such as horror, or who reveal some terrible secret about taboo subjects, such as incest or necrophilia” (133). Through this horrific acts and unexpected plot twists, Poe aims to surprise and excite…

Words 482 - Pages 2

Compare And Contrast Tell Tale Heart And The Black Cat

are stories that show how insane the narrator's really were. The 2 stories show a lot in common but also have a lot of differences. The most common things about the stories are pretty obvious, the 2 narrators were both crazy in the head that committed a crime by killing someone. They both thought they were sane, when we all know as readers that killing someone because of an eye is just insane and killing your wife because of a “black cat” annoyed you, really shows how insane you are. The 2 narrators…

Words 393 - Pages 2

Tell Tale Heart Eq

Tell-Tale Heart EQ: How did Edgar Allan Poe use the literary device of setting to create a dark, threatening tone in his short story The Tell-Tale Heart? Edgar Allan Poe used the elements of setting to create a dark, threatening tone in a “Tell-Tale Heart” by using atmosphere, location, elapsed time, man-made geography and population. The narrator is also insane and a liar making the reader feel scared and concerned. He often tries to convince the readers he isn’t insane but he proves himself wrong…

Words 562 - Pages 3

The Black Cat Symbolism

Edgar Allan Poe lost so many people he loved to the disease Tuberculosis. He grew up with only a mother because his father abandoned their family. He also had two other siblings. Mrs. Poe died from Tuberculosis. Edgar Poe and his siblings were split up into different homes. He was adopted by Mr. and Mrs. Allen. Mrs. Allen also ended up dying from T.B. and his wife died from T.B. as well. The losses Poe suffered influenced the literary elements he used. Poe’s literature often requires the reader…

Words 515 - Pages 3

Comparing Poe's The Tell-Tale Heart And The Black Cat

Edgar Allen Poe said, “ I became insane, with long intervals of horrible insanity.” Poe was a very complex person. A very awkward person, but yet he is considered to be a good friend for anyone. His maladjusted and self conscious life have all played a huge part in his eminence writing style. The Tell-Tale Heart and “The Black Cat” are two perfect examples of Edgar Allan Poe’s classic horror stories. Each story is both unique in their own ways, although there are similarities that show the comparison…

Words 203 - Pages 1

Edgar Allan Poe's The Tell-Tale Heart

“The Tell-Tale Heart” Edgar Allan Poe How does Poe use the senses (particularly sight and sound) to demonstrate the narrator's madness in "The Tell-Tale Heart"? The author of the “The Tell-Tale Heart” is Edgar Allan Poe. He is famous for writing the short stories with the sinister themes, violence and psychological precarious characters. In this short story, the protagonist is insane. Poe uses many situations to prove this. The narrator kills the old man who lives with him. He mentions, “Object…

Words 306 - Pages 2

Tell Tale Heart Research Paper

are sane or insane. What is the difference between sane and insane? Sane is some who is not mentally ill and insane are people who are mentally ill. The narrator of “The Tell Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe is a sane person because of his madness, conspiracy to commit murder, and have a conscience when he murder the old man. The narrator is madness because he have this rage for an old man because of his eye. “He had the eye of a vulture—a pale blue eye, with a film over it” (Poe). Usually there…

Words 508 - Pages 3

Doggy: Edgar Allan Poe and Poe Essay example

Luke Naoumovitch Period 2 12/11/13 Poe Lives On! Poe was a very influential man in literature. He influenced people around the world with his newly introduced fiction detective stories. His writing style popularized the macabre. Poe wrote about big factors in his life including alcohol, women, and death. Even though Poe’s works shaped American literature today, he didn’t get nearly enough respect as deserved. He was only paid about fourteen dollars for “The Raven” because he made the mistake…

Words 602 - Pages 3

Tell Tale Heart By Edgar Allan Poe Literary Devices

Edgar Allan Poe use the literary device of setting to create a dark, threatening tone in his short story "Tell-Tale Heart." He manipulated with some primary elements of setting which include the time of day, mood and atmosphere, also man-made geography. The author Edgar Allan Poe included mood/atmosphere or lighting to be precise, when he wrote about the lantern. The black color of the lantern camouflaged with the night and the soft glow of the lantern, gave a sense that something was there.…

Words 400 - Pages 2