Initially, Edna mistakes her feelings for Robert as the girlish infatuation she is so familiar with from her youth, but these emotions are different. For her, her relationship with Robert is a real and tangible connection; he is an attainable object of her affections. When Robert is away, Edna appeases her yearning for him through attention from Arobin, which is enough on a physical level, but not on an emotional level, the level Edna so desperately desires. Without Robert, Edna’s “entire existence [is] dulled,” but when he returns, so does the color return to her life (ibid. 46). Edna and Robert consummate their love in a few passionate embraces. While Edna’s kisses with Arobin were light and fleeting, her kisses with Robert are “full of love and tenderness,” expressing everything she’s felt since their stay in the Grand Isle (ibid. 107). Edna, a married woman, isn’t afraid of the consequences anymore; she wants Robert and only Robert, and now that the guilt is gone, she is no longer at war with herself. She knows that she deserves him, that she deserves happiness in its truest form: