Education and Educational Achievement Essay

Submitted By paulotucay
Words: 1779
Pages: 8
Open Document
How useful is the labelling theory in helping to explain differences in educational achievement?

We often view ourselves as a reflection of how others see us. Positive praise could lead to confidence. Negative comments could lead to unconfidence. Being given a label could cause a tendency for the person to adopt and act in terms of it. Take education as an example. Teachers labelling has been shown to have a huge impact on student success. There are researches that teacher’s assumptions for their students tend to live up to the expectations that their teacher said to them. The studies have been thoroughly investigated by the Interactionist as they have examined the day-to-day interplay of teachers and students in schools (Holborn and Langley, 2004). On this occasion, this essay will be looking at how labelling affects the students social class, gender and ethnicity in explaining educational achievement.
Interactionists in the UK have different explanations of educational achievement based on labelling theory. According to their studies, teachers initially evaluate pupils in relation to their social backgrounds (Browne, 2002). When it comes to educational achievement the children from middle-class background have positive labelling or better assessment than the children from working-class background. Famous study by Becker (1971) has proven that teachers in Chicago were operating with a definition of the “ideal pupil” as a positive label. These “ideal pupil” were manifested by the children from middle- class background as they are seen to be interested in lessons; they have a good conduct and appearances. They work hard, they are co-operative and polite. Those from the working- class background were seen as less able or the opposite of ‘ideal pupil’ (Browne, 2002).
Another analysis was done in America by Ray Rists (1970) where he found out that children had been allocated according to their social background and ability. Teachers used the children’s home background and appearance to different group. Those middle-class children who have neat and clean appearance were placed on ‘higher-ability’ table, with working-class children being placed on the ‘lower ability’ table (Holborn and Langley, 2004).
Research by Neil Keddie 1971 presents a similar picture. Keddie found that teachers taught those in higher-stream classes differently from those in lower streams. Higher-stream classes involve middle class background whilst lower streams include working –class background. Higher-stream classes ere expected to behave better and do more work, and teachers gave them more, and different types of, educational knowledge which gave them greater opportunities for educational success. Working-class pupils might therefore underachieve in education partly because they have not been given access to the knowledge required for educational success (Browne, 2002).
As a result, teachers prefer to label middle-class children as bright and highly motivated as they are more likely to be successful in education. So teachers spend more time to them. Whereas, working-class children were labelled as slow or of low ability, teachers expect less from these pupils and deny them with the knowledge and skills they deserve (Pilkington et.al, 2005).
If middle rather than working-class pupils are labelled ‘able’ and ‘well behaved’, this may well disadvantage working-class pupils. These pupils may see themselves in terms of the label and act accordingly- so fulfilling the prophesy teachers have made about them (Browne, 2002). Research done by Rosenthal and Jacobson (1968) in California provided useful evidence of self-fulfilling prophecy. They found that a randomly chosen group of pupils whom teachers were labelled as bright and could be expected to make good progress, did in fact make greater progress than students not so labelled. Rosenthal and Jacobson claimed that the teachers’ expectations significantly affected their pupils’ performance (Browne,
Show More

Related Documents: Education and Educational Achievement Essay

Outline The Impacts Of Educational Policies On Achievement Essay

“Outline the impacts of educational policies on achievement. “ Throughout the years, educational policy has been changed in many ways and forms to boost educational achievement among pupils. An educational policy refers to different plans and strategies for education which are introduced by the government. During 1880, education - and the level of education that you did in fact receive - was heavily based on social class differences. This was down to the fact that during this time period, if you…

Words 675 - Pages 3

assignment 9 Essay

Educational triage is where pupils in education are sorted out on those who will pass, hopeless cases, those who could pass with help and concentrating on the last group Three types of pupil subcultures that might be found in schools are rebellion (going against the rules, not doing what they’ve been told), retreatism (daydreaming and mucking about), and also ingratiation (being the teacher’s pet). Marketisation and selection policies in some ways may produce social class differences in educational…

Words 587 - Pages 3

Achievement Gap In Education

results of minority children's underperformance in school. Thus, in order to adequately address the achievement gap, or the disparity between performance of different groups of students, federal and state governments need to allocate more funds into implementing the programs that work. The achievement gap has been an issue in the United States for a long time. A National Assessment of Educational Progress' report conducted in 1970 reveals that there is a persistent 30 point gap in reading and math…

Words 2961 - Pages 12

cultural deprivation Essay

language, reasoning skills and self-discipline, being culturally deprived is shown to have a direct impact on achievement and the three main aspects are language, attitudes and values and intellectual development. Firstly Intellectual development, this is the student’s development of thinking and reasoning skills as well as the ability to solve problems. Many working class children lack educational books and activities to stimulate intellectual development. J.W.B Douglas found that working class pupils…

Words 901 - Pages 4

Assess the view that the education system serves to maintain consensus in society Essay

that the education system serves to maintain consensus in society. (24 mark) Functionalism investigates institutions to consider the functions they perform in society. The functionalist premise is that if an institution exists, then there must be some reason for its existence. As regards education, functionalists assume that educational institutions serve some societal need. Educational institutions are examined for the positive contribution they make towards maintaining society. Education is seen…

Words 565 - Pages 3

Disparity Among African-American Students

For years the academic achievement, or more appropriately, underachievement, of African-American students has been a topic that has been greatly researched, discussed and debated by educators and researchers. Much of the significant research is devoted to discovering why students do not achieve at the same level as White students (Samuel, 2014). The achievement gap refers to the disparity in academic performance between groups of students (Porter, 2007). The goal of this study is to understand the…

Words 1271 - Pages 6

Material and Cultural Deprivation Essays

5) One material factor that may cause educational underachievement in the working class is a poor diet. A 2001 study by Howard suggests that the working class may not be able to afford enough food to adequately feed their children. This could have a negative effect on achievement, as the children may struggle to concentrate in class, or even be ill more often and therefore do less well in education. Another factor is poor, overcrowded housing. This could be due to a lack of space to carry out school…

Words 458 - Pages 2

Middle Class and Intellectual Development Essay

class are inadequately socialised and therefore lack the right culture needed for educational success. Cultural deprivation theorists argue that most of us start get the basic values, attitudes and skills that are needed through primary socialisation in the family. People need the cultural equipment which consists of self discipline, language and reasoning skills. A child’s chances to achieve the best in the education system are based on their social class background. Normally, children from middle…

Words 1385 - Pages 6

Wide Range Achievement Test 4

Literacy Assessment Study The Wide Range Achievement Test 4 is a test that measures the basic academic skills. The test consists of four subtests: word reading, spelling, math computation, and sentence comprehensive. The subtest directions for administration are simple and the subtests are easy to understand. The only subtests that can be given in small groups of five examinees are the second parts of spelling and math computation; the Wide Range Achievement Test 4 also has the score conversion appendices…

Words 756 - Pages 4

Social Performance: Part 1 Essay

Performance: Part 1 May 2, 2013 Second Home Educational Child Care (SHECC) is a organization that provides child care services to parents for an affordable price. This mid-sized child care company serves children from 6 months to six years of age. Our unique services are safe and secure, providing the parents with an excellent place where their children can be educated and taken care of. Second Home Educational Child Care will base our operations in Havertown and Brookhaven,…

Words 1406 - Pages 6