English Essay 2 Western Genre

Submitted By marsgabriel
Words: 1408
Pages: 6
Open Document
Jodie Hanelin
Professor Bernhoft
WR 100 NA
10/25/12

Violence and Social Order in Western Society
The natural order and hierarchy in Western genre films involves a great deal of violence to upkeep its structure. In the film The Searchers, the main character Ethan Edwards embodies a western “gun-slinging hero”. He returns home from the Civil War to his brother’s house, only to encounter even more fighting with the Comanche Indians. Once leaping from one fight to the next, Ethan and his fellow Westerners including Martin, a relative not by blood, seek revenge on the Comanches for murdering and kidnapping Lucy, a family member. The conflict between the Comanche Indians and the Westerners surrounds the entire film, essentially war encompasses their lives. This sheds light on the fact that violence and fighting shapes the natural order of civilization. It remains a question whether violence is for the sake of fighting, or to protect people in danger. Ethan’s actions throughout the film while seeking revenge and searching for Lucy appear violent, but it is the way of life for these Westerners. Violence governs the natural order and ladder of Western society in The Searchers, and defines their different social positions. The proper place of violence in Western society is constantly being challenged by the differences between Ethan, who uses excessive violence, and Martin, a figure of civility.
While Western civilization attempts to make itself appear tranquil with the scenic and panoramic scenes in the film, it is soon interrupted with violence and fighting from Ethan and Martin. As soon as Ethan walks into his brother Aaron’s home, trouble is assumed due to the gold coins he produces from his pocket, leading the viewer to insinuate that he is up to no good. This is then followed by news of cattle being stolen by the Comanches, which leads Ethan to go track them down and fight. This represents the constant violence which interrupts the tranquil scenic views and lighthearted music taking place in between scenes. “We notice that the Western depicts a world of precarious balance in which the forces of civilization and savagery are locked in a struggle for supremacy” (Shatz 49). It appears as if there is a struggle between the calm and quiet of the world around them and the constant violence that is plaguing their lives. The violence takes innocent men like Ethan’s brother and kills them when he is merely at home with his children and wife.
The social positions of the men in Westerns are also defined by their roles in fighting and war. For instance, the Reverend/Captain has two seemingly contradictory jobs. He first preaches the words of God but then is able to go fight with Ethan. The Captain’s ability to switch from a Reverend to a violent fighter against the Comanches further displays how violence governs their social order. Ethan on the other hand is a “man of leisure, whose possessions are irrelevant, and [he] has no concept of employment” like a typical “gun-slinging” Westerner and only represents the violent aspect of the Western man (Warshow 107).
The duality of the Reverend’s character further exemplifies that violence plays a role in almost every aspect of Western life, from religious purposes to fighting. Looking at his character, it is unexpected that he is an active member of the Texas Rangers, but it comes with the territory of being a Western Man. Martin too is seen as an orderly and not outwardly violent individual, and a figure of civility. He is forced to begin fighting and search for Lucy as soon as his family is threatened, further highlighting his Western values of prevailing against opposing forces, specifically, the Indians. He therefore too plays a dual role, as most Western men must.
The violence in The Searchers seems unnecessary at times, but the savage actions committed by both the Westerners and Indians determined their social positions of who was the victor and who was defeated. The way the
Show More

Related Documents: English Essay 2 Western Genre

Department of English Spring 2014 Course Descriptions Essays

Department of English Spring 2014 Course Descriptions 89S. Imagining War. Instructor M. Maiwald. WF 8:30-9:45 In this course, we will consider how the experience of war has been represented in American fiction, non-fiction, and film. We will investigate how attitudes toward war have evolved throughout American history: our timeline begins with the Civil War—the traumatic event that birthed the modern American state—and ends with the recent conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq. In particular…

Words 9501 - Pages 39

Compare And Contrast Mexican Culture

As I begin this essay comparing two separate cultures I feel it is necessary to first describe what exactly culture is. Culture has been called "the way of life for an entire society." It includes codes of manners, dress, language, religion, rituals, norms of behavior such as law and morality, and systems of belief. Various definitions of culture reflect differing theories for understanding or criteria for evaluating human activity. Edward Burnett Tylor writing from the perspective of social…

Words 1173 - Pages 5

Did the Impact of the Beatles Sgt Pepper Album Help Redefine Popular Music as a Culturally Significant Art Form? Essay

artist from the period 1900-1970 and to examine their relationship to the cultural and social framework of their era with reference to an important or influential album. Introduction In this essay I will be critically analysing and evaluating ‘The Beatles’ Sgt. Peppers album in relation to their associated genre, their lyrics, their musical creativity, their social and political context, their overall impact on music and popular culture and…

Words 4155 - Pages 17

English Language and le ha Essay

Journal of English for Academic Purposes 8 (2009) 134e146 www.elsevier.com/locate/jeap Strategic, passionate, but academic: Am I allowed in my writing? Phan Le Ha Faculty of Education, Monash University, Australia Abstract This article is about the struggles to sustain identity as writers while accommodating the demands of the university experienced by Arianto and his thesis supervisor, myself. It shows how critical EAP was the on-going conversation between us about how to negotiate norms…

Words 9247 - Pages 37

Essay on Renaissance Terms

basis for a newpolyphonic composition. Choralis Constantinus: A collection of over 350 polyphonic motets (using Gregorian chant as the cantus firmus) written by the German composer Heinrich Isaac and his pupil Ludwig Senfl. Contenance angloise: ("The English sound") A term for the style or quality of music that writers on the continent associated with the works of John Dunstable (mostly triadic harmony, which sounded quite different than late Medieval music). Counterpoint: Combining two or more independent…

Words 3905 - Pages 16

Essay on Lincoln rhetorical

first-person point of view (I, we), the second-person (you, your), or the third-person (he, she, it, they). Syntax: The study of the rules that govern the way words combine to form phrases, clauses, and sentences (and one of the major components of grammar). (2) The arrangement of words in a sentence. Adjective: syntactic. Level of formality: the style that your audience expects and that fits your purpose; exists on a scale of formal, semi-formal, and informal Attitude: usually used for a synonym for tone;…

Words 6267 - Pages 26

Example Research: Critical Discourse Analysis Essay

bridge these levels, and thus to arrive at a unified critical analysis: Members–groups: Language users-engage in discourse as members of (several) social groups, organizations, or institutions; and conversely, groups thus may act "by" their members. 2 Actions–process: Social acts of individual actors are thus constituent parts of group actions and social processes, such as legislation, newsmaking, or the reproduction of racism. 3 Context–social structure: Situations of discursive interaction are similarly…

Words 9518 - Pages 39

Frank: Novel Frankenstein Essay

article is about the novel. For the characters, see Victor Frankenstein or Frankenstein's monster. For other uses, see Frankenstein (disambiguation). Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus Volume I, first edition Author Mary Shelley Language English Genre Horror, Gothic, Romance, science fiction Published 1818 (Lackington, Hughes, Harding, Mavor & Jones) Pages 280 Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus is a novel written by British author Mary Shelley about eccentric scientist Victor Frankenstein…

Words 7465 - Pages 30

103 American Literature Final Exam Essay example

characters living as survivalists in the sparsely populated hinterlands of the United States. (C) the inner psychological lives of privileged upper-class characters. (D) the exploits of characters with startling accomplishments and impressive abilities. 2. What qualities distinguish practitioners of “naturalism” from practitioners of “realism” as a general movement? (A) their use of unspoiled natural settings for their fiction, rather than urban or agricultural spaces shaped by…

Words 5468 - Pages 22

Essay on Physical theatre

Physical theatre Physical theatre is a genre of theatrical performance that pursues storytelling through primarily physical means. Several performance traditions all describe themselves as "physical theatre", but the unifying aspect is a reliance on physical motion of the performers rather than or combined with text to convey the story. In basic sense, you talk through hand gestures, body language, thought track and many more physical features. Dympha Callery suggests that all physic…

Words 6691 - Pages 27