Essay Midterm

Submitted By elixaneumann
Words: 1437
Pages: 6
Open Document
The Problem of St. Patrick
Finding the Truth behind the Missionary

Elixa Neumann – 13101442
Exchange from University of Ottawa, Canada
HI221: Medieval Ireland, 5th-9th Century
Dábhí Ó Cróinín
Word Count: 1,447
November 1st, 2013

“The wise person is known through speech, and also understanding and knowledge and the teaching of truth.” ~ St. Patrick1
Finding truth can be a very difficult path. Historians have often debated the topic of St. Patrick and the many issues in regards to truth that have arisen from his story. There are many contradictions amongst historians as to what actually happened in history when St. Patrick came to Ireland in and around 432 AD and the time that he spent here until the his death. A general consensus has never been determined despite the many theoretical ideas that have been discussed over time. Despite this, there are certain facts that we hold as positively true from St. Patrick’s personal written works such as the Confession and the Letter which can help us to confirm his identity. The main problem of St. Patrick is to determine what the truth is behind who he was as a missionary to the Irish people. In developing this question, it is crucial to first of all identify what we know for certain about St. Patrick and then examine the link between what was his own workings and what could potentially be the collection of work from others who worked for the same cause and were instead masked by his footsteps. Therefore, it is difficult to understand a man with a hidden identity and so it is easy enough to confuse the truth.
Many centuries have been spent trying to determine the truth about who St. Patrick was and what he accomplished. There are very few facts that we know for certain about St. Patrick. From his written works, we can deduce with certainty his real name, who his father was, who his grandfather was, his hometown, the age at which he was taken from home, how many years he spent as a slave and finally the place where they landed in Ireland. Other than these particular facts, it is possible to question what St. Patrick wrote. This is due to the fact that he wrote his story after the fact and in addition, the stories told about St. Patrick were also documented years afterwards rather from direct observers and recorded within the same century.
This being said, St. Patrick’s works were not published by himself, rather, they were found and published for the first time in the year 1606 as part of the Book of Armagh. This book represents a collection of writings, brought together by scholars at Armagh in the ninth century2, although this does not mean that the writings were not changed when collected to be a part of this book. The scholars would have examined his works to try and solve their own questions in regards to the apostle of Ireland as Patrick became of great fascination to be studied and analyzed. This was due to the fact that he was the only man of the Roman Empire to have been taken by raiders and sold as a slave and who was able to document his journey.3 However, they were no closer to a solution in regards to Patrick back in the ninth century than we are today.
It is necessary, when examining the story of St. Patrick, to also take into consideration another man who came to Ireland, only a year before Patrick himself supposedly arrived on this island. This man goes by the name of Palladius. According to the Annals of Ulster, Palladius arrived in Ireland in 431 AD with a mission given to him by Pope Celestine in Rome. It is said that Palladius was “consecrated by Celestine, bishop of the city of Rome,” and “is sent to Ireland…as first bishop to the Irish so that they might believe in Christ”.4 Having said this, it could be expected that more would be available about Palladius and his mission to help the Irish convert their faith to Catholicism, but only handed-down stories remain.
The first steps taken in Ireland towards organizing the first Irish Christian communities
Show More

Related Documents: Essay Midterm

Midterm essay

Jennifer Frey October 27, 2010 History 202B 8:00-8:50 History Midterm Essay Throughout the 20th century the government played a significant role in the United States economy. In early parts of the 20th century, the government agreed in the thought of laissez faire which is the quote of saying “Let it be”; government hands off of private business expect to retain law and order. In later parts of the 20th century many organization such as small businesses, farms and labor movements began…

Words 728 - Pages 3

Midterm Essay

Varvara Protopop Essay # 4 (Midterm In-class Essay) ESL 192 –Professor Garlock October 29, 2014 My life-changing experience as a college student Mostly every student enters college expecting good times, friendship, love, knowledge and a new sense of direction. They find out soon that college comes with its own challenges and struggles because of the great demands that are put on the importance of education. College students have to get through a lot of daily stress in order to become successful…

Words 486 - Pages 2

Midterm Essay

Midterm Exam Amber Wash November 1, 2014 Sullivan CSC610 1. Define software. Explain how system software is different from application software. Describe networking operation system (NOS). Describe enterprise applications. Differentiate between a horizontal system and a vertical system. Define legacy systems. Software is the computer programs that govern the operation of the computer. System software is used for basic computer operations such as startup and printing for example Windows 7. Whereas…

Words 1824 - Pages 8

Midterm Essay

Gambhir 1 Somya Gambhir January 29, 2015 Mr. Guarino US History II Per. 4 Talkies in the 1920’s The vitaphone, a device that synchronizes audio and video of a motion picture, was a device that changed the future of movies forever. A major studio in Hollywood, known as the Warner brothers began to emerge into the scene with this device, unknowing of the final result. Fortunately, as many may have guessed, this initiative turned out to change the lives of many people. As many people know as general…

Words 862 - Pages 4

midterm essay

Gabrielle Jones 01, June 2014 International Business The Best Political and Economic System A political system is one which involves politics and government officials. An economic system is a system which focuses on production of goods and services. I do not believe there is "such thing" as a perfect political or economic system, however, I do believe that a Individualism Political System and a Market Economic System would be best. From my research, I've learned that Individualism and Collectivism…

Words 417 - Pages 2

History7 MIDTERM WORKSHEET Essay

INSTRUCTIONS FOR HISTORY 7 ONLINE MIDTERM ESSAY Al Parker, Prof. Emeritus, History Spring, 2015 Class code 44593 The essay is to be submitted as a digital copy by way of the Assignments link. Submit as an attachment. Do not submit by insertion into the text box. Do not submit as an attachment to a Mail message. See document named “How to Submit Written Assignments,“ available in the Printable Information folder accessed by way of the Course Contents link on the Course Menu. The essay is due before 10 p.m.,…

Words 1255 - Pages 6

Midterm Essay Questions

Midterm Essay Questions Legal and Ethical Environment of Business 1. Identify an action that would violate social norms but would not violate any laws. Can you identify any violation of law that would not violate any social norms? Not everything that is legal is also appropriate or morally correct. Not following the law has legal consequences like fines or imprisonment but there are no penalties for acting not according to social etiquette except maybe that people might see your behavior as rude…

Words 1778 - Pages 8

Monroy Midterm Essay

Mayra Monroy Midterm essay 03/20/15 Every immigrant has to start at the base. During the 19th century many immigrants from across the world came to the United States to improve their living. Little did they know that it was not going to be as easy as they thought? Many had to start off by learning the language. It was easy for some but difficult for others. When it came down to finding a place to lodge everything was out of their budget and the only thing affordable was the tenant housing. Real…

Words 1316 - Pages 6

Midterm Study Guide Essay

Ethics Midterm Examination Review The midterm examination will consist of ten multiple choice questions worth four points each, three short answer questions worth ten points each, and one approximately page-long essay question worth thirty points. I will give you four short answer questions on the exam from which you will choose three to respond to. I provide here a set of three essay questions. Two of these will appear on the exam, and you will choose one of them to respond to. The essay questions…

Words 755 - Pages 4

Midterm ENG 246 Essays

ENG 246/ WGS 201 Spring 2014 Midterm Exam Choose two of the following three prompts and write for each a 3-4 page essay (double-spaced, approximately 800 words). • Work with a variety of works from our reading list. • Structure your essay according to the logic of your argument. Weave ideas together, and make connections when appropriate. • I don't expect you to include outside sources; however, you may. You can use bits of your own previous writing for this course but none of other student's…

Words 570 - Pages 3