Assess The Strengths And Weaknesses Of Using Experiments To Investigate Power And Authority In Prisons.

Submitted By Giuseppe-seal
Words: 793
Pages: 4
Open Document
Using material from item A and elsewhere, assess the strengths and weaknesses of using experiments to investigate power and authority in prisons

DAT- An experiment is conducted by researchers in a laboratory, field or natural conditions. Depending on the conditions, the experiment could end up with either qualitative or quantitative data. In this context, it’s a field experiment.
P- (a cage) A Practical disadvantage of using experiments in prisons is that they tend to be very segregated from the rest of society and thus are very hard to gain access to for research reasons. The process of a sociologists getting granted access could take weeks or even months, even when allowed access to the prison, the experiment itself will be extremely slow and vigorously checked by prison guards to prevent danger to the researcher.
Furthermore, factors such as class, age and gender may influence the information received from prisoners. For example, if the researcher is female, the prisoners may act in a certain way to try to impress the female researcher, which would also cause problems for the experimenter. This will also make it hard for the researcher to gain accurate information and could also put the researcher at risk of abuse, both sexually and physically.
In addition, field and natural experiments could take a long time to conduct and also variables are not being controlled, so you cannot establish an association between the variables.
E- (Includes i.c.e .v.c) There are many particular ethical issues when studying prisons, safety is a major issue for researchers in prison especially when dealing with those who have committed serious offences. However, the researcher may have ‘guilty knowledge’ told to him by a prisoner and this suggests that the researcher has a moral right to break the rules of privacy and has to tell the police.
Individuals involved in either field or natural experiments are not usually aware that they are being researcher, this is kept secret to maximise natural behaviour, but this also raises some ethical issues such as lack of informed consent. This is an ethical issue because the pps must sign the consent form to allow the researcher to publish the results from the study and also the pps must be aware of their rights, such as their right to withdraw from the study. Moreover, re-creating power and authority relationships in an artificial laboratory situation can cause other ethical problems, as seen in Professor Zimbardo’s prison experiment.
R- One advantage of conducting experiments in prisons is that detailed video footage will be available for other researchers to view and thus be able to conduct a similar experiment with the footage and additional information they have about the procedure of the experiment. One disadvantage of conducting experiments in prisons is that they tend to be unique, this is because prisons vary around the world. For example, prisons in the UK tend to be more civilised than prisons in Mexico. This suggests that because it’s unique, it would be extremely hard for other researchers to replicate the experiments and obtain similar results.
V- Validity of the field experiments would be quite low. This is because the prisoners would
Show More

Related Documents: Assess The Strengths And Weaknesses Of Using Experiments To Investigate Power And Authority In Prisons.

Max: Prison and north American Prison Essay

American Prison System and the novel Rita Hayworth and the Shawshank Redemption. A prison is an institution for the confinement of persons convicted of criminal offenses. Nelson Mandela once said “When a man is denied the right to live the life he believes in, he has no choice but to become an outlaw.” The prison system has been a way to keep violent criminals away from society and should also help to reform convicts and enable them to reintegrate into society. It may be true that prisons exist for…

Words 2170 - Pages 9

History of Prisons Essay

Anissa Clarke 100428742 Research Essay The Rejuvenated Soul: European Prisons of the 17th and 18th Centuries I declare that this assignment is original and has not been submitted for assessment elsewhere. I DO NOT agree that the assessor(s) of the assignments may, for the purpose of assessing the assignments: communicate a copy of the assignments to the electronic plagiarism detection service known as Turnitin.com. I accept the option of using…

Words 2115 - Pages 9

People in Prison Essay

In the essay “A Hanging” by George Orwell, the author watched an execution of a prisoner in Burma. The author describes the whole process, his feeling and the environment in the prison. It seems that, once the human being goes into the prison, they are no longer respected. The have bad living environment, are not respected by the warden, and after they die, their dead body is not respected either. The place where the prisoner lives, according to George Orwell, is “…like a small animal cages. Each…

Words 523 - Pages 3

Essay Prison: Prison and Justice Statistics

worlds population. However, we house more than twenty-five percent of the worlds inmates. The percentage of people in the U.S in prison or jail is a little less than 1% of the population. With over 1.6 million people in jail, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics in 2010, the number of inmates increases year after year. Men make up ninety percent of the prison and jail population, and they are more than ten times more likely to be in incarcerated than women. Most of the men incarcerated are…

Words 1140 - Pages 5

Essay on Prison and Prison Society Course

12 INCARCERATION AND PRISON SOCIETY Course Outline I. Introduction: The modern prison • Maximum security prisons prior to the 1950s was a massive wall institution • In the South the massive wall were less common as prisoners worked outside on large farms • The 1960s saw a move toward rehabilitation and “correctional institutions” • Since the 1970s minority representation has increased and gangs have raised the level of violence in prisons II. Goals of incarceration…

Words 959 - Pages 4

Essay Jail And Prison Response

Jails and Prisons Response Ephrem Larry CJS/200 12/13/13 William Patton In this essay I am going to identify the four types of prisons. I am also going to explain the concept of prison as a total institution. I will briefly explain why jails play an important role in the criminal justice system. The four types of prison are minimum, medium, maximum, and ultra-high security. The minimum security prison inmate are generally housed in a dormitory like setting. They work…

Words 505 - Pages 3

U.S. Prison Costs Essay

U.S. Prison Costs After reading the essay, “A Homemade Education,” an autobiography of Malcolm X, I became quite curious about how many dollars America spends toward the prison system and how it affects our society. The autobiography itself covers how Malcolm X gained a homemade education simply by reading books while serving time in prison. He claimed, “I don’t think anybody ever got more out of going to prison than I did…prison enabled me to study far more intensively…sometimes as much…

Words 1627 - Pages 7

Essay on the prison industrial complex

What is and how do we make sense of the ‘prison industrial complex? 
The United States has the highest prison rate in the world, incarcerating 743 people per 100,000 of their national population (Fulcher, 2011). The U.S makes up five percent of the worlds population, but incarcerates twenty five percent of the worlds prisoners; Since 1978 the number of prisoners in the US has tripled (Schlosser, 1998). 
The increase of incarceration can be traced back to the abolition of slavery. The development…

Words 2803 - Pages 12

Prison Bootcamps Essay

particular program. The first of these public boot camps was set up in Oklahoma and Georgia in 1983. The Georgia program was a two-part program consisting of a rigorous 90-day tour in a prison boot camp followed by a less structured period of community supervision. The program was designed as an alternative to prison, and participation was mandated by the sentencing judge as a condition of probation. Oklahoma had 4 separate boot camp programs within the state, with an overall capacity of 446…

Words 1743 - Pages 7

Life in Prison Essay

Life in Prison Sociology of the Criminal Justice System Life in Prison There are many increased precautions in ultra-prisons where the prisoners are locked into small cells for approximately 23 hours a day. They have almost no contact with other human beings and no group activities. The cells have no windows and lights are controlled by guards who leave them on night and day. For exercise there is usually only a room with high concrete walls and a chin-up bar. Showers may be limited to…

Words 352 - Pages 2